#INZpirED Archive
This is a weekly chat often based around one or two questions to spark discussion & debate around educational issues.
Friday October 7, 2016
10:30 PM EDT
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 10:30 PM EDT
@PranSang
@Ajarn_Adam
@deem_ellen
@JenaiaMorane
@RekhaPuriNYC
morning all
#INZpirED
ready to chat
#ditchthattextbook
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:30 PM EDT
Hi everyone, welcome to
#INZPirED
- please introduce yourself and let us know where you're joining from...
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:30 PM EDT
@VipulaSharma1
@PranSang
@deem_ellen
@JenaiaMorane
@RekhaPuriNYC
Hi Vipula!
#INZPirED
JKatzaman
Oct 7 @ 10:31 PM EDT
Joining
#INZpirED
from Maryland.
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:31 PM EDT
Sunny joining in from Delhi
#INZPirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:32 PM EDT
@VipulaSharma1
@PranSang
@Ajarn_Adam
@deem_ellen
@RekhaPuriNYC
#INZpired
Hi Vipula!
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:32 PM EDT
@JKatzaman
Welcome Jim :)
#INZPirED
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:32 PM EDT
@KSThakral
Morning Sunny!
#INZPirED
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:32 PM EDT
@Ajarn_Adam
@VipulaSharma1
@PranSang
@deem_ellen
@JenaiaMorane
@RekhaPuriNYC
Morning everyone
#INZPirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:33 PM EDT
#inzpired
Jena Ball, CritterKin and Not Perfect Hat Club creator tweeting from North Carolina in USA with Hurricane Matthew headed our way
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:33 PM EDT
@JenaiaMorane
Stay safe Jena.
#INZPirED
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:34 PM EDT
Today we are discussing how can ditching textbooks help us to create more
#INZPirED
lessons?
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:35 PM EDT
@JKatzaman
Morning Jim
#INZPirED
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:36 PM EDT
@JenaiaMorane
Hope you are OK Jena
#INZPirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:36 PM EDT
@Ajarn_Adam
#INZPirED
Textbooks belong to the manufacturing model - everyone must learn same thing the same way in the same order & schedule
PranSang
Oct 7 @ 10:36 PM EDT
Join us now on
#INZPirED
@bakshiaarti
@Ms_SheilaD
@naghma_khn
@bashaierk
@babushayagnik
@WillcoxJoe
@askMsQ
https://t.co/xv7h0h9Ugy
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:36 PM EDT
@Ajarn_Adam
#INZPirEd
I am, honest. More worried about friends on the coast.
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 10:37 PM EDT
I teach
#EAL
& we hv many textbooks on shelves which we dip into but really prefer making use of current events to develop Lang
#INZPirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:37 PM EDT
#inzpired
Instead of textbooks, let's involve the kids in deciding what and how they will learn.
PranSang
Oct 7 @ 10:37 PM EDT
Morning all on
#INZPirED
ready to learn!
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:37 PM EDT
@JenaiaMorane
True, there is often a rigid structure associated with them
#INZPirED
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:39 PM EDT
@VipulaSharma1
That's a great point re EAL, & definitely 1 reason I started looking beyond textbooks
#INZPirED
lauriemeston
Oct 7 @ 10:39 PM EDT
Hello all. Laurie joining from Maple Ridge BC. It's Friday evening here
#inzpired
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:39 PM EDT
@JenaiaMorane
@Ajarn_Adam
Couldn’t agree with this more. Same as row based seating, T at the front & grading
#INZPirED
#industrialmodel
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:39 PM EDT
#inzpired
Better yet let Ss document & chronicle what & how they learn 2 share so that they understand their voices=heard & have an impact
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:39 PM EDT
@PranSang
Morning:)
#INZPirED
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:40 PM EDT
@lauriemeston
Hi Laurie. Welcome and we are discussing how we should move beyond textbooks in the classroom
#INZPirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:40 PM EDT
@Ajarn_Adam
#INZPirED
I used to write them for McGraw-Hill I'm embarrassed to say. They were AWFUL to write & even worse to edit & read.
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:40 PM EDT
@VipulaSharma1
@JenaiaMorane
The tech side is a definite advantage when it comes to ditching
#INZPirED
lauriemeston
Oct 7 @ 10:40 PM EDT
@JenaiaMorane
Stay safe Jena. I'm sending you positive thoughts and prayers.
#INZpirED
PranSang
Oct 7 @ 10:41 PM EDT
@Ajarn_Adam
good evening Adam
#INZPirED
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:42 PM EDT
@Ajarn_Adam
@VipulaSharma1
@JenaiaMorane
Wondering at times if we should also ditch the digital textbook
#INZPirED
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:42 PM EDT
@lauriemeston
Hi Laurie, welcome :)
#INZPirED
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 10:43 PM EDT
@Ajarn_Adam
@JenaiaMorane
some publishers r going online & getting more creative too, esp mfl
#INZpirED
they must in order to stay relevant
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:44 PM EDT
#inzpired
Wish
@HeadofSchool
was here. Head of American International School, Hong Kong & chucked all textbooks. Quite eloquent about it
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:44 PM EDT
Being distracted by a very playful Lab telling me to ditch that laptop.
#INZPirED
https://t.co/Yri4qy19EM
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:44 PM EDT
Are there any possible disadvantages to ditching textbooks?
#INZPirED
PranSang
Oct 7 @ 10:44 PM EDT
@KSThakral
@Ajarn_Adam
@VipulaSharma1
@JenaiaMorane
wouldn't the Ss need some reference matter to read on a topic
#INZPirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:45 PM EDT
@lauriemeston
#INZPirEd
Hi Laurie! Thank you so much. It's my friends on the coast who worry me. I'm in the middle of the state.
lauriemeston
Oct 7 @ 10:45 PM EDT
Hi
@Ajarn_Adam
. Good to be here.
#INZpirED
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 10:45 PM EDT
Hey Sunny, not sure about that as maybe there is a need for some subjects or Ts and even Ss
#INZpirED
@KSThakral
@Ajarn_Adam
@JenaiaMorane
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:46 PM EDT
@VipulaSharma1
@Ajarn_Adam
#INZPirEd
Depends on what you mean by relevant. Pearson's stated goal="teacher-proof" classrooms. Criminal IMHO
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 10:46 PM EDT
@PranSang
@KSThakral
@Ajarn_Adam
@JenaiaMorane
some of our Ss and Ps definitely want access to reference material
#INZpirED
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:46 PM EDT
@VipulaSharma1
@JenaiaMorane
There are some great biology resources available e.g.
https://t.co/CP0k9y0b6P
#INZPirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:46 PM EDT
@KSThakral
#INZPirED
I am so in love :-)
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:47 PM EDT
@PranSang
@KSThakral
@VipulaSharma1
@JenaiaMorane
Yep, Ss often like to have one place to use a reference source
#INZPirED
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:47 PM EDT
@PranSang
@Ajarn_Adam
@VipulaSharma1
@JenaiaMorane
thinking substituting one for a digital one doesn't make much diff in learning
#INZPirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:48 PM EDT
@KSThakral
#INZPirED
Agree. Use of creative elearning programs like Captivate have potential, but most use 2 create slideshows. Sigh....
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:49 PM EDT
@PranSang
@Ajarn_Adam
@VipulaSharma1
@JenaiaMorane
textbooks have to evolve digitally. Use multimedia, differentiated materials
#INZPirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:49 PM EDT
@VipulaSharma1
@PranSang
@KSThakral
@Ajarn_Adam
#INZPirED
Reference & resources aren't textbooks. Agree Ss need to learn how to find info.
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:50 PM EDT
@KSThakral
@PranSang
@Ajarn_Adam
@VipulaSharma1
#INZPired
Think need a new definition of textbook. Not a SET thing but evolving w/SS' input
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:51 PM EDT
@VipulaSharma1
Especially when many education systems are heavily exam-based
#INZPirED
PranSang
Oct 7 @ 10:51 PM EDT
#INZPirED
https://t.co/N6Xod8lsji
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 10:50 PM EDT
@KSThakral
@PranSang
@Ajarn_Adam
@JenaiaMorane
true you can gt so creative wth iBook, our Options book for Yr9's is now an interactive book
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:52 PM EDT
@VipulaSharma1
@PranSang
@Ajarn_Adam
@JenaiaMorane
Thinking cognition load - Have incomplete textbooks which Ss have to fill
#INZPirED
PranSang
Oct 7 @ 10:52 PM EDT
@KSThakral
@Ajarn_Adam
@VipulaSharma1
@JenaiaMorane
completely agree
#INZPirED
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:53 PM EDT
@JenaiaMorane
@KSThakral
@PranSang
@VipulaSharma1
Have Ss create their own 'textbooks'?
#INZPirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:53 PM EDT
#inzpired
After typing new definition of textbook I laughed. Think of publishers that go out of biz. Edu publishing=very lucrative
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 10:55 PM EDT
@Ajarn_Adam
I agree, I think that is probably the biggest fear
#INZPirED
also with Ss maybe moving schools esp in int sector
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:55 PM EDT
@Ajarn_Adam
#INZPirED
Not textbook in traditional sense, but doc of what & how learned that can be passed on & added 2 by those who follow
PranSang
Oct 7 @ 10:55 PM EDT
@JenaiaMorane
hope
@PearsonNorthAm
is not listening...
#INZPirED
JKatzaman
Oct 7 @ 10:55 PM EDT
Keeping textbooks depends on the textbook. Math texts seem pretty cut and dried. History texts might be challenged for accuracy.
#INZPirED
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:55 PM EDT
@lauriemeston
Had a convo with a P abt a research task who said give source to find the answer. I was like defeats the purpose
#INZPirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 10:57 PM EDT
@lauriemeston
#INZPirEd
Thing I object 2 most about textbooks=force feeding data. Assumes Ss' like hard drives. Makes 4 passive bored Ss
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 10:57 PM EDT
@JenaiaMorane
I read about a teacher who did a similar thing but had Ss develop a website over several years
#INZPirED
lauriemeston
Oct 7 @ 10:57 PM EDT
An interesting idea Student created textbooks.
https://t.co/UQVmLFR5VV
#INZpirED
PranSang
Oct 7 @ 10:57 PM EDT
@JKatzaman
so true, some time back read an article where Indian community in US complained against inaccurate Indian history
#INZPirED
lauriemeston
Oct 7 @ 10:58 PM EDT
@KSThakral
sure does...
#INZpirED
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 10:58 PM EDT
Ooo nice idea, I like that and will be stealing it Sunny!
@KSThakral
@PranSang
@Ajarn_Adam
@JenaiaMorane
#inzpired
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:00 PM EDT
#Hyperdocs
are another way to
#ditchbook
- check out these resources
https://t.co/Q0WSnRt4Yy
curated by
@KarlyMoura
#INZPirED
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 11:00 PM EDT
@lauriemeston
thanks for sharing this, great quote, if Ss own the learning and can lead it that should raise levels of engagement
#INZpirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 11:01 PM EDT
#INZPirEd
@VipulaSharma1
Sweet! Here is a book SS in Iowa created of the newspaper we did together:…
https://t.co/Uj27kYDvbY
lauriemeston
Oct 7 @ 11:02 PM EDT
@JenaiaMorane
i agree. Brain scans of people memorizing facts=little brain activity When active learning lots of areas "light up"
#INZpirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 11:02 PM EDT
@Ajarn_Adam
#INZPirED
So smart and talk about a legacy! Just think how proud Ss could be of what they passed on to kids coming behind them.
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 11:02 PM EDT
@Ajarn_Adam
@KarlyMoura
@padlet
you beat me to it Adam, I was just about to share the exact same thing,
#hyperdocs
#INZpirED
JenaiaMorane
Oct 7 @ 11:05 PM EDT
@agileschools
@lauriemeston
@edutopia
#INZPirEd
Hahaha not much to sue over. Just quoting them :-)
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 11:06 PM EDT
Has anyone come across this site
https://t.co/GwbL8u9zJi
#INZpirED
I think this pretty much sums up what we can do without textbooks
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:06 PM EDT
What are the ways you ditch the book in lessons? I use GAFE,
@fireflyteam
@nearpod
, iPads, learning village,
@mangahigh
& more
#INZPirED
lauriemeston
Oct 7 @ 11:08 PM EDT
An excellent article about teaching chemistry without a textbook
https://t.co/BzU6iZvuVH
#INZpirED
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 11:08 PM EDT
@KSThakral
@fireflyteam
@nearpod
@mangahigh
I like to make use of
@Newsela
to work on Lang and improve current world knowledge
#INZpirED
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:08 PM EDT
@VipulaSharma1
Haven’t. Thanks Vips. Will come in handy
#INZPirED
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:09 PM EDT
@KSThakral
@fireflyteam
@nearpod
@mangahigh
I have Ss use
@Wix
to create their own websites, pretty user friendly
#INZPirED
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:10 PM EDT
@lauriemeston
Another great article. Def. will come in handy to convince science colleagues
#INZPirED
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:11 PM EDT
@KSThakral
@fireflyteam
@nearpod
@mangahigh
Also lots of options for creating videos, infographics etc = more voice & choice
#INZPirED
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:12 PM EDT
@Ajarn_Adam
@fireflyteam
@nearpod
@mangahigh
@Wix
ICT is indeed becoming intuitive - focus should be on audience/purpose.
#INZPirED
KRScienceLady
Oct 7 @ 11:14 PM EDT
Spent today digging into OER . Huge implications for implementation
#NGSS
#INZPirED
https://t.co/TeZZcbUzzL
lauriemeston
Oct 7 @ 11:08 PM EDT
An excellent article about teaching chemistry without a textbook
https://t.co/BzU6iZvuVH
#INZpirED
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:18 PM EDT
@VipulaSharma1
@Newsela
sounds interesting - will tap you for tips for my Korean/Japanese learners - bright but struggling
#INZPirED
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:18 PM EDT
@KRScienceLady
Hi Kathy, thanks for sharing - this looks interesting!
https://t.co/v4R8mxmYKd
#INZPirED
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 11:18 PM EDT
Good points made here
https://t.co/0L4gLG63gZ
Textbooks don't always grab Ss attention
#inzpired
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 11:20 PM EDT
@KSThakral
@Newsela
academic language is tough to master for all Ss but esp for
#EAL
lots of scaffolds and sentence frames
#inzpired
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:21 PM EDT
Huge culture shift needed to see textbook as another resource rather than the be all & end all. It is the same as one website
#INZPirED
PranSang
Oct 7 @ 11:24 PM EDT
@KSThakral
would access to digital libraries and public libraries help?
#INZPirED
PranSang
Oct 7 @ 11:26 PM EDT
@KSThakral
that's still lacking in India
#INZPirED
KRScienceLady
Oct 7 @ 11:26 PM EDT
Another site
https://t.co/cPfWvUr6mH
#INZPirED
https://t.co/o1BMskNhqz
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:18 PM EDT
@KRScienceLady
Hi Kathy, thanks for sharing - this looks interesting!
https://t.co/v4R8mxmYKd
#INZPirED
VipulaSharma1
Oct 7 @ 11:27 PM EDT
Thanks all at
#INZPirED
for the chat, ready for school now after our midterm break. Final share has to be some visu…
https://t.co/9HlH5Fd9tQ
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:27 PM EDT
@PranSang
Need a platform like
@KognityEd
with a subscription model aka Netflix instead of pay per book.
#INZPirED
KSThakral
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:29 PM EDT
@PranSang
Cost is the number one factor in India. Second is PD. Need to think of better solutions
#INZPirED
Ajarn_Adam
- Moderator
Oct 7 @ 11:29 PM EDT
Thanks to everyone for joining in with another great
#INZPirED
chat today - enjoy your weekend!