#IOLchat Archive
#IOLchat meets Wednesdays at 12PM ET to discuss trends and issues in online education.
Wednesday February 1, 2017
12:00 PM EST
MrsMurat
Feb 1 @ 12:00 PM EST
My Ss provide evidence they are Digital Leaders!
https://t.co/Pjh5jwBm4K
#iolchat
#LDchat
participatechat
Feb 1 @ 12:00 PM EST
Participate in the upcoming
#IOLchat
by sharing resources and collaborating at
https://t.co/tXOC3ozmZ8
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:01 PM EST
Welcome to
#IOLchat
! Who is joining in today?
#onlinelearning
#onlineteaching
#InsideOnlineLearning
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:04 PM EST
A1 grade infl is result of no student left beh & rate my Prof 40% A's really?
#iolchat
#edchat
#highered
#education
https://t.co/7GPP6wItrC
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:05 PM EST
Hi Michael! Welcome to the chat this week.
#iolchat
In reply to @clowningar
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:06 PM EST
thought I'd get a jump on things... lol
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:06 PM EST
Hello and welcome, Angela! Don't forget to add our chat hashtag:
#IOLchat
:)
In reply to @smrtang
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:07 PM EST
Q1 coming up! ....
#iolchat
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:09 PM EST
Q1) What do (or should) grades represent or tell us about a student?
#iolchat
AssignmentHelpN
Feb 1 @ 12:10 PM EST
#iolchat
#LDchat
17 for ’17: Experts on E-learning & EdTech Trends for 2017
https://t.co/I9aiwWWsrV
massignmenthelp
Feb 1 @ 12:10 PM EST
#iolchat
#LDchat
Project based learning
https://t.co/u8MMjb1Oxk
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:11 PM EST
A1 that the S has a stellar grasp of the course? I love this doc on
#highered
https://t.co/kmLb8ZGn1z
#iolchat
#edchat
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:11 PM EST
A1: I'd like to believe level of learning achieved. Maybe idealistic?
#iolchat
#edtc0560
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:12 PM EST
A1 Ideally grades should reflect SLO acheivement and mastery. Grades may tell conformity or institutionalization
#IOlchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:12 PM EST
Hi Paul! Hope all is well with you this week. :)
#IOLchat
In reply to @philosophypaul
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:14 PM EST
Moving forward. Hope you are enjoying the week and a new month.
#IOLchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:14 PM EST
Agreed. And is the S working for grades or mastery?
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul, @CenterOnlineEd
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:15 PM EST
Learning achievement and understanding of material seem to be a consensus here. Agreed! To
@smrtang
's question -is this idealistic?
#iolchat
In reply to @smrtang
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:15 PM EST
2017 seems to be flying already ...
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:16 PM EST
Context may determine if S works for grades or mastery. What does T communicate? What does institution communicate?
#IOLchat
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:14 PM EST
Agreed. And is the S working for grades or mastery?
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul, @CenterOnlineEd
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:16 PM EST
Intersesting question - grades as a motivator, pros and cons perhaps?
#iolchat
In reply to @smrtang, @philosophypaul
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:18 PM EST
Ss lost their curiosity when
#middleschool
peers
#embarrassed
them over asking
#Questions
#iolchat
#edtechchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd, @smrtang
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:20 PM EST
To
@philosophypaul
's point, grades as a motivator implies T and institution are communicating letter over learning
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd, @philosophypaul
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:20 PM EST
curiosity leads to learning outcomes,,, Parents pushing for grades
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd, @smrtang, @philosophypaul
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:21 PM EST
Yes indeed - the overall concern about grades begins well before college. Good point to remember here.
#iolchat
In reply to @clowningar, @smrtang
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:23 PM EST
and the msg received = grades more NB than learning :-(
#iolchat
In reply to @clowningar, @CenterOnlineEd, @philosophypaul
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:23 PM EST
Do parents perceive value of curiosity and creativity or quantitative record? If the latter, may not be allies in learning.
#IOLchat
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:20 PM EST
curiosity leads to learning outcomes,,, Parents pushing for grades
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd, @smrtang, @philosophypaul
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:23 PM EST
I like to connect Creative spaces with mobile edu ie like zoo with animal based course
#iolchat
https://t.co/1jMzSbRCbI
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:25 PM EST
Q2) Should we be concerned about rising GPAs in highered? (national trends:
https://t.co/m2TckOJTEd
)
#iolchat
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:26 PM EST
HS Ss are getting 4.5's so need to tackle there as well
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:26 PM EST
A2 Grade inflation can be a temporary fix but a long term tragedy when Ss cannot transfer learning to work, life
#IOLchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:27 PM EST
Can you say more about the "temporary fix?"
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:28 PM EST
Seems we expect a grade, a single letter, to convey a lot of different things.
#iolchat
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:28 PM EST
Depends on the reason for the trend. Is it about learning or assessment?
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:28 PM EST
The "transfer learning to work, life" is something I hadn't thought of re: grades, but I see that in some courses.
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:29 PM EST
Thoughts?
#gradeinflation
RT
@smrtang
@CenterOnlineEd
Depends on the reason for the trend. Is it about learning or assessment?
#iolchat
In reply to @smrtang, @CenterOnlineEd
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:29 PM EST
A2 I'm pushing for Life exp like gap year bef
#highered
with credit-by-exam my Vlog on subject
https://t.co/YVYpcvYrir
#iolchat
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:30 PM EST
A2 2nd reply Push-back on grd. inflation may be Dept. of Ed's expectations for post-graduation career or grad sch
#IOLchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:32 PM EST
A2 cont) Are Ss learning the material well or are assessments too easy? How are outcomes measured?
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:32 PM EST
A2 move from test & Sage on Stage to
#PBL
/
#socratic
&
#experiential
learning get results
#iolchat
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:33 PM EST
If
#gradeinflation
results from assessment, it is the lowering of standards that raises outcomes?
#IOLchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd, @smrtang
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:33 PM EST
I like this move, too. It changes the type of assessment as well, another factor in what grades could mean, tell us etc
#iolchat
In reply to @clowningar
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:34 PM EST
Hello all - Jennifer from Atlanta..better late than never =(
#iolchat
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:34 PM EST
get rid of the curve
#iolchat
#edchat
In reply to @philosophypaul, @CenterOnlineEd, @smrtang
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:34 PM EST
A key question here, I think - does grade inflation = lowering of educational standards?
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul, @smrtang
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:35 PM EST
Hi Jennifer! Great to see you. :)
#iolchat
In reply to @jshamsy
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:35 PM EST
W
#PBL
#socratic
&
#experiential
the problem of
#gradeinflation
should be neutralized
#IOLchat
In reply to @clowningar
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:35 PM EST
A1) Wholeheartedly agree Paul. grades tell us how well a S can master the SLO..how good are they at school
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:36 PM EST
instead of grades I'm leaning towards 1st, 2nd etc Ss entering comp's like FRC, state fair etc
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:36 PM EST
"How good are they at school" - great addition to the convo on grades.
#iolchat
In reply to @jshamsy
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:37 PM EST
A2) I see grade inflation as a huge problem - it has become a "game of school" less about learning - lrng is a side activity
#iolchat
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:37 PM EST
I think we need to move towards performance improvement where it is about applying "on the job" as opposed to testing
#iolchat
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:38 PM EST
Interesting. Expectations, like grds, can take focus away from actual learning.
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul, @CenterOnlineEd
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:39 PM EST
spelling bee's,, x-prize etc and other forms of learning outcomes with growth
#iolchat
In reply to @jshamsy
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:39 PM EST
A2) I think you have to look at students holistically - grades/tests/what they are doing in real life
#iolchat
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:40 PM EST
I think we're all getting at something new transcript initiatives are trying to capture - more than just a list of courses, grades
#iolchat
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:41 PM EST
When the first question is "what do I have to do to get an A?"..learning has been lost
#iolchat
In reply to @smrtang, @philosophypaul, @CenterOnlineEd
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:41 PM EST
Reimagining the College Transcript:
https://t.co/nvbnQdmjkq
#iolchat
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:42 PM EST
thanx for noticing and Flw thought I'd disrupt a bit on
#iolchat
today
In reply to @jshamsy
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:43 PM EST
I'll read this thanx
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:43 PM EST
Do you mean new methods of assessment?
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:44 PM EST
Complements today to transcript is Ss ePortfolio w career objectives, course outcomes, and reflections
#IOLchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:44 PM EST
Different* assessment methods, perhaps, but also providing info about activities, growth ...
#iolchat
In reply to @smrtang
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:45 PM EST
I think envolvement, Ss teaching Ss and community activity should be apart of grade
#iolchat
In reply to @smrtang, @CenterOnlineEd
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:45 PM EST
Great point..because synthesis is at the top of Bloom's and by far the hardest..what can Ss do with the info?
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:45 PM EST
I see the term standardization and wonder if it brings us full circle in this dicussion?
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:45 PM EST
Absolutely! Portfolios can be really powerful in this way - convey more than just a grade received. Context.
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:46 PM EST
https://t.co/ddHp2ZYUd7
S w/family to restraunt orders meal in Spanish gets a badge and family get 10% bill
#iolchat
In reply to @jshamsy
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:46 PM EST
How do they tie it all together and make something meaningful?
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:46 PM EST
Example;
https://t.co/sc0n9x1hn0
#IOLchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:47 PM EST
I'm working on one right now..and it is one of the hardest things I have had to do academically =(
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd, @philosophypaul
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:48 PM EST
Sounds like a good writing topic ... ;)
#iolchat
In reply to @jshamsy, @philosophypaul
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:48 PM EST
Yes. Have taught. And now taking my own medicine w a portfolio.
#IOLchat
In reply to @jshamsy, @CenterOnlineEd
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:48 PM EST
Badgemap Vlog
https://t.co/cna3sH8ikh
#iolchat
In reply to @jshamsy
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:48 PM EST
Thanks for sharing this link! Really like the description. Would be nice to get employers on board, too.
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:49 PM EST
Ditto. Knowing what is important and how to represent learning can be challenging!
#iolchat
In reply to @jshamsy, @CenterOnlineEd, @philosophypaul
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:50 PM EST
Exactly - there's a whole skill set in creating an effective presentation, I think.
#iolchat
In reply to @smrtang, @jshamsy, @philosophypaul
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:50 PM EST
That's good..more Ts need to be Ss...I think important lessons to turn back around to help Ss
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul, @CenterOnlineEd
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:51 PM EST
instead of eport & transcripts since I start in Primary I'm thinking badges like boys scout's
#iolchat
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:52 PM EST
Effective presentation and critical thinking elements.
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd, @jshamsy, @philosophypaul
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:52 PM EST
Badges definitely have a place in this conversation about assessment and demonstration of learning!
#iolchat
In reply to @clowningar
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:52 PM EST
Badging has to be appropriate for audience - some adults may not be able to get over the gamification aspect - buy-in
#iolchat
In reply to @clowningar
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:53 PM EST
Time for our last Q .... coming up ...
#iolchat
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:53 PM EST
Badges can complement grade process and in some instances hold industry validation. Check w
@Melissa_Venable
on badges
#iolchat
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:51 PM EST
instead of eport & transcripts since I start in Primary I'm thinking badges like boys scout's
#iolchat
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:53 PM EST
Military Generals might take a issue of that LOL
#iolchat
In reply to @jshamsy
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:54 PM EST
Audience is an important consideration for all the formats we've discussed from grades and transcripts to portfolios and badges.
#iolchat
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:54 PM EST
Make be some importance in the design of the badge and presentation?
#iolchat
In reply to @clowningar
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:54 PM EST
Q3) What if we eliminated grades in highered - Is that a good idea? What would it look like?
#iolchat
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:55 PM EST
Agreed! How do they translate to the workforce?
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:55 PM EST
LIke badges not be 2 juvenile but fun
#iolchat
In reply to @jshamsy
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:56 PM EST
A skill set difficult to measure using grds. I see the value in reimaging the transcript!
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd, @jshamsy, @philosophypaul
clowningar
Feb 1 @ 12:57 PM EST
A3 CompSci use github activity, Com Ss could use what work has been published? etc
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:57 PM EST
A3 W/o grades employers or admission boards for grad. school would scramble for credentials, validation. What form?
#IOLchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:57 PM EST
chaos? =)
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd
CenterOnlineEd
- Moderator
Feb 1 @ 12:58 PM EST
Likely! Kind of fun to think about though. Maybe just eliminate in some courses - more performance based as mentioned.
#iolchat
In reply to @jshamsy
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:58 PM EST
Grades = worth and value...Most Ss don't know how to measure themselves without that
#iolchat
In reply to @philosophypaul, @CenterOnlineEd
philosophypaul
Feb 1 @ 12:58 PM EST
Reply: transcripts may not track skills. Perhaps apprentice, mastery, journeyman/ journeywoman
#IOLchat
smrtang
Feb 1 @ 12:56 PM EST
A skill set difficult to measure using grds. I see the value in reimaging the transcript!
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd, @jshamsy, @philosophypaul
jshamsy
Feb 1 @ 12:59 PM EST
It would be life altering for both faculty and students -- totally Control>Alt>Delete.... =)
#iolchat
In reply to @CenterOnlineEd