#RSDchat Archive
Wednesday November 2, 2016
9:30 PM EDT
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:33 PM EDT
Welcome.
@banniejanie
on Qs tonight w/ help from
@Mellyteaches
. Share name, school, subject and favorite movie involving politics.
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:35 PM EDT
@banniejanie
from RHS, teach media broadcasting. Favorite movie involving politics: The American President.
#RSDchat
In reply to @banniejanie
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:33 PM EDT
Welcome.
@banniejanie
on Qs tonight w/ help from
@Mellyteaches
. Share name, school, subject and favorite movie involving politics.
#RSDchat
gilliam_evelyn
Nov 2 @ 9:37 PM EDT
EGill PD and Hunger Games Trilogy (there are some political themes in the stories)
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:38 PM EDT
thanks for joining!!
#RSDchat
In reply to @gilliam_evelyn
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 9:39 PM EDT
Hallie, 4th grade at Marvin. I also love The American President, I also liked Dave.
#rsdchat
Mellyteaches
Nov 2 @ 9:39 PM EDT
Christina from
@Ritenour_HS
, ELA, and Mr. Smith Goes to Washington.
#rsdchat
In reply to @Ritenour_HS
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:33 PM EDT
Welcome.
@banniejanie
on Qs tonight w/ help from
@Mellyteaches
. Share name, school, subject and favorite movie involving politics.
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:39 PM EDT
#RSDchat
is talking Elections. Join us.
@TechieTcher
@dr_riina
@MrTimBurkard
@RSDlearning
@halliesmills
In reply to @TechieTcher, @dr_riina, @MrTimBurkard, @RSDlearning, @halliesmills
Mellyteaches
Nov 2 @ 9:40 PM EDT
Hunger Games are absolutely politically themed -- they count.
#rsdchat
In reply to @gilliam_evelyn
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:40 PM EDT
forgot about Dave! Great movie 👍
#RSDchat
In reply to @halliesmills
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:40 PM EDT
@banniejanie
it's the speech scene. Lol.
#RSDchat
In reply to @Mellyteaches, @Ritenour_HS, @banniejanie
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:42 PM EDT
Q1. Should we teach the election process to Ss? Why?
#RSDchat
gilliam_evelyn
Nov 2 @ 9:42 PM EDT
@Mellyteaches
I know. I used to teach with book one. I could have made a whole semester class out of the books :-)
#RSDchat
Mellyteaches
Nov 2 @ 9:40 PM EDT
Hunger Games are absolutely politically themed -- they count.
#rsdchat
In reply to @gilliam_evelyn
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:43 PM EDT
What do you think?
@dr_riina
@MrTimBurkard
@MrAllPurposeRHS
@MCrowley522
@MikeLaChance5
@pdemps45
#RSDchat
In reply to @dr_riina, @MrTimBurkard, @MrAllPurposeRHS, @MCrowley522, @MikeLaChance5, @pdemps45
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 9:44 PM EDT
A1: Yes, students need to be informed how elections work, well before they can officially vote.
#rsdchat
MikeLaChance5
Nov 2 @ 9:45 PM EDT
@RSDchat
LaChance C&I All the President's Men
#RSDchat
In reply to @RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:46 PM EDT
A1: I will never forget a professor teaching us that school are to make intelligent voting citizens. Teaching process is step 1.
#RSDchat
MrTimBurkard
Nov 2 @ 9:47 PM EDT
A1: It's our duty to prepare students for their future. Not teaching and preparing them for this basic right would be a failure!
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:50 PM EDT
Q2. What do we teach to help Ss critically think about an election?
#RSDchat
joyeuse212
Nov 2 @ 9:50 PM EDT
Bonjour! I'm Jennifer, French Tchr at RHS. Sorry to be late!
#RSDchat
gilliam_evelyn
Nov 2 @ 9:50 PM EDT
A: yes-share history, democratic process, and how our particular system works
#RSDchat
Mellyteaches
Nov 2 @ 9:51 PM EDT
A1 Only if we want them to practice the skills they will need as adults while they have guidance. Ts are models, mentors, sponsors.
#rsdchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:42 PM EDT
Q1. Should we teach the election process to Ss? Why?
#RSDchat
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 9:51 PM EDT
For many of our ELL Ss, when we teach them about the election process, those lessons will be taken home to family.
#rsdchat
MikeLaChance5
Nov 2 @ 9:52 PM EDT
@RSDchat
A1: Absolutely, learning the process is essential to democracy or at least our form of democracy.
#RSDchat
In reply to @RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:53 PM EDT
good point! No assumptions. We have a lot of families in the district who need info on process.
#RSDchat
In reply to @halliesmills
joyeuse212
Nov 2 @ 9:53 PM EDT
A1: Definitely! I have some students who are old enough to vote and are eager to do so.
#RSDchat
gilliam_evelyn
Nov 2 @ 9:54 PM EDT
Having some technical issues...I may have to back out tonight
#RSDchat
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 9:55 PM EDT
I've been trying to channel
@julnilsmith
to start teaching my 4th graders about
#medialiteracy
.
#rsdchat
In reply to @julnilsmith
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:50 PM EDT
Q2. What do we teach to help Ss critically think about an election?
#RSDchat
heinousj
Nov 2 @ 9:55 PM EDT
@RSDchat
it's important for students to not only know the process but how to find info on candidates that is reliable and factual.
#RSDchat
In reply to @RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:55 PM EDT
A2. Biggest thing we can do is to talk about being informed voter. Very hard to find truth in present day elections.
#MediaLitWk
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:50 PM EDT
Q2. What do we teach to help Ss critically think about an election?
#RSDchat
DrMayMalek
Nov 2 @ 9:55 PM EDT
What about we practice that as a class! Monthly voting for leaders. Practice for real.
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:56 PM EDT
she's my
#medialiteracy
hero!!
#RSDchat
#MediaLitWk
In reply to @halliesmills, @julnilsmith
Mellyteaches
Nov 2 @ 9:57 PM EDT
This has to come from habit of fact-checking, using evidence, making inferences, etc. -- great critical thinking skills!
#rsdchat
In reply to @RSDchat
heinousj
Nov 2 @ 9:57 PM EDT
A2: I try to encourage them to look at what is important to them and will effect them. Look less at party and more on stance
#RSDchat
DrMayMalek
Nov 2 @ 9:57 PM EDT
2) we have leaders in every class. We can support everyone to be a leader in his/ her way.
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 9:58 PM EDT
A2. Talk with Ss about social media postings, determine good and bad facts, info. Looking at author.
#RSDchat
#MediaLitWk
joyeuse212
Nov 2 @ 9:59 PM EDT
A2: Remind Ss that the info expressed via media sources about candidates is not always true. Look for "fact checker" info.
#RSDchat
Ritenour_HS
Nov 2 @ 10:00 PM EDT
Q3. Should we share personal political opinions, beliefs with Ss?
#RSDchat
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:00 PM EDT
A2: Examine sources, recognize bias, determine fact vs. opinion.
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:02 PM EDT
Q3. Should we share personal political opinions and beliefs with Ss?
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:02 PM EDT
miss that show!! 👍
#rsdchat
In reply to @mrs_ruggles
mrs_ruggles
Nov 2 @ 10:03 PM EDT
@RSDchat
A2 Teaching students about how to determine the credibility of various news sources/outlets.
#RSDchat
In reply to @RSDchat
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:03 PM EDT
A3: I don't think so. Ss need to be able to make up their own mind. Even my dad doesn't tell us who he is voting for.
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:02 PM EDT
Q3. Should we share personal political opinions and beliefs with Ss?
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:04 PM EDT
I get asked the Q a lot by HS Ss. When can it be appropriate/inappropriate?
#RSDchat
In reply to @halliesmills
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:04 PM EDT
that I might try!!
#RSDchat
In reply to @mrs_ruggles
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:05 PM EDT
A3: I'll admit this has been hard this year. With one candidate inspiring fear in many of my Ss, I want them to know I don't agree.
#rsdchat
DrMayMalek
Nov 2 @ 10:06 PM EDT
3) I don't think so. We need to show them how to read between the lines, not to be fooled by big words.
#RSDchat
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:06 PM EDT
That's a good question. Maybe after the election? I explain why I don't tell them my own opinion.
#rsdchat
In reply to @RSDchat
Mellyteaches
Nov 2 @ 10:06 PM EDT
A3, pt1 How Ts choose to disclose/not more important than whether Ss know specifics. Older Ss respect honesty, respectful sharing.
#rsdchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:02 PM EDT
Q3. Should we share personal political opinions and beliefs with Ss?
#RSDchat
mrs_ruggles
Nov 2 @ 10:07 PM EDT
A3: No. Ss need to be empowered to make their own decisions. I'm not sure it helps when we share ours in this situation.
#rsdchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:07 PM EDT
I found myself thinking I had no problem sharing my vote for Obama, but feel conflicted this year.
#RSDchat
In reply to @halliesmills
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:07 PM EDT
Hello! Glad you made it!
#RSDchat
In reply to @mrsdonaldsonm
heinousj
Nov 2 @ 10:08 PM EDT
A3: as someone who talks a lot about news and current events, any student who listens closely can tell where my views lie.
#RSDchat
Mellyteaches
Nov 2 @ 10:08 PM EDT
A3, pt 2: Some years I disclose, others I don't. Appropriate if "I am your T & support you first of all."
#rsdchat
In reply to @RSDchat, @halliesmills
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:08 PM EDT
good point. I actually had that discussion w Ss today about why I don't share.
#RSDchat
In reply to @halliesmills
DrMayMalek
Nov 2 @ 10:08 PM EDT
3) we have to teach politics 😂. It's critical for them to value their voice. One voice Can make a difference
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:09 PM EDT
reminds me about talking about religion in class
#RSDchat
In reply to @Mellyteaches, @halliesmills
heinousj
Nov 2 @ 10:09 PM EDT
A3: as long as I don't persuade them to think my way and just give facts it's all good
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:10 PM EDT
I think we have adults who are having that problem = reason to teach that skill!!
#RSDchat
In reply to @DrMayMalek
Mellyteaches
Nov 2 @ 10:11 PM EDT
In some ways, politics even more personal! Modeling respectful adult relationships the important part.
#rsdchat
In reply to @RSDchat, @halliesmills
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:11 PM EDT
It is hard...
#rsdchat
In reply to @RSDchat
pdemps45
Nov 2 @ 10:11 PM EDT
A3 no. we should play both sides and challenge students in their thinking. Students need an armor against doctrine of all types
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:11 PM EDT
Q4. How can we talk about this Elections negativity w/ Ss?
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:13 PM EDT
#RSDchat
: great resources for Ts on teaching Elections from
@edutopia
.
https://t.co/lx5SuanQYl
In reply to @edutopia
joyeuse212
Nov 2 @ 10:14 PM EDT
A3: If Ss ask it's a great opportunity to demonstrate how to be respectful in conversation, kindly agree to disagree, etc.
#RSDchat
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:14 PM EDT
A4: It's a lesson in how important word choice is, and how it can evoke strong feelings.
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:15 PM EDT
that is where my concern lies with sharing opinions. Don't want them to have my opinion but form their own.
#RSDchat
In reply to @pdemps45
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:16 PM EDT
great point!! Read article that pointed out that we can use this time to discuss arguments. How they can be positive.
#RSDchat
In reply to @joyeuse212
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:16 PM EDT
A4. How can we approach it with adults? 😂😂😂😂
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:11 PM EDT
Q4. How can we talk about this Elections negativity w/ Ss?
#RSDchat
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:17 PM EDT
A4: The negativity is hard to overcome. Even in elem. school Ss express strong emotions about this election.
#RSDchat
gilliam_evelyn
Nov 2 @ 10:17 PM EDT
I'm back :-). A:4 teaching civility is crucial when discussing topics with extreme differing opinions
#RSDchat
heinousj
Nov 2 @ 10:18 PM EDT
A4: this happens every election. Just address it by having them look at examples of pos and neg.
#RSDchat
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:18 PM EDT
My favorite political ad of the year - definitely not negative!
https://t.co/WUaDOUK9ah
#rsdchat
heinousj
Nov 2 @ 10:19 PM EDT
A4: cont. just cause a candidate says it doesn't make it right or acceptable
#RSDchat
gilliam_evelyn
Nov 2 @ 10:19 PM EDT
A:4 teach civility before political discussions so Ss have behavior structures to rely on when the topic gets heated
#RSDchat
pdemps45
Nov 2 @ 10:19 PM EDT
A4: Looking at the negativity as a way to reflect on self. Reflect on the affects of their actions and learn from their mistakes
#RSDchat
mrs_ruggles
Nov 2 @ 10:19 PM EDT
A4: Modeling respectful conversations with both Ss and Ts. Connect class discussion norms to social norms when debating issues.
#RSDchat
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:19 PM EDT
A4: You could also have Ss rewrite negative ads/statements. Revise, rephrase, analyze effectiveness.
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:19 PM EDT
A4.
#RSDchat
80% of kids talking about 2016 election. Better to address having constructive arguments.
https://t.co/l1Ijy2B1sS
pdemps45
Nov 2 @ 10:20 PM EDT
A4: also learn bias, what is negative to one candidate may not even make the news for another due to race, gender, and prejudice
#RSDchat
DrMayMalek
Nov 2 @ 10:20 PM EDT
4) by doing chat like this. Show them positivity and they will discover the -Vity in the election.
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:21 PM EDT
great ad!!!
#RSDchat
In reply to @halliesmills, @fox8news
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:22 PM EDT
Q5. What follow-up activities can we conduct following Nov 8th election?
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:23 PM EDT
my daughter wanted to know when Trump will send guards for the Hispanic kids if he wins.
#RSDchat
#floored
In reply to @halliesmills
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:24 PM EDT
A5: I'm thinking I may do something on their rights, perhaps even before election. Show them how hard it is to make/change a law.
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:22 PM EDT
Q5. What follow-up activities can we conduct following Nov 8th election?
#RSDchat
gilliam_evelyn
Nov 2 @ 10:24 PM EDT
A:5 analysis of who voted, how they voted, and what it implies about our citizens. Also see what the rest of the world thinks
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:25 PM EDT
I'm realizing that these discussions maybe necessary amongst all the information.
#RSDchat
#MedLitWeek
In reply to @DrMayMalek
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:25 PM EDT
A5 cont.: I want to try and re-assure them that no matter the outcome there is a process to protect all people.
#rsdchat
DrMayMalek
Nov 2 @ 10:26 PM EDT
5) going back to the constitution rights, definition of American citizens, how to be American. The basics.
#RSDchat
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:26 PM EDT
That breaks my heart. I had a student say if Trump wins she's "moving to California!"
#shemeantCanada
#workingongeography
#RSDchat
In reply to @RSDchat
pdemps45
Nov 2 @ 10:26 PM EDT
A5 hard to know, a lot more could happen. Look at voting data and asking why and predict how this election changed future elections
#RSDchat
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:27 PM EDT
hahaha😂😂😂
#RSDchat
In reply to @halliesmills
DrMayMalek
Nov 2 @ 10:29 PM EDT
5) I might chat with you from Canada 🤓
#RSDchat
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:29 PM EDT
So much data to dissect! I love the idea of looking at coverage from BBC or intern'l news as well.
#RSDchat
In reply to @gilliam_evelyn
RSDchat
- Moderator
Nov 2 @ 10:29 PM EDT
#RSDchat
- discussion of information key to election, consider how positive
#MedLitWeek
in schools can be to our world!
#RSDchat
#SOAPBOX
halliesmills
Nov 2 @ 10:29 PM EDT
May also need to do more explanation of popular vote vs. electoral college.
#RSDchat
In reply to @pdemps45