#BmoreEdchat Archive
#BmoreEdchat is a weekly chat from Baltimore, MD that inspires educators to #Bmore for their students and school communities.
Wednesday October 4, 2017
9:00 PM EDT
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:00 PM EDT
Welcome to
#BmoreEdchat
this evening! Please intro yourself with your name, role, & location.
Owl_b_TorresEdu
Oct 4 @ 9:02 PM EDT
Jessica, Elem AP at
@BrookAveElem
in Waco, TX...mostly lurking tonight as I study for comps
#BmoreEdchat
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:02 PM EDT
Tiffany Ott, Gifted Intervention Specialist, Northeast Ohio! Excited to be here!
#BmoreEdchat
R_CILR
Oct 4 @ 9:03 PM EDT
Hello,
#bmoreedchat
! Rebecca from Nevada. Hope you all had a good Tuesday.
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:03 PM EDT
Marcia, middle school Media Specialist, Eastern Shore of MD
#BmoreEdchat
Moderating for
@justincholbrook
tonight.
R_CILR
Oct 4 @ 9:04 PM EDT
Hi, Marcia.
#BmoreEdChat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog, @justincholbrook
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:04 PM EDT
First question in about a minute
#BmoreEdchat
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:06 PM EDT
Q1: Does your district have a homework policy? If so, please describe it.
#BmoreEdchat
DrBrianCook
Oct 4 @ 9:08 PM EDT
#BmoreEdchat
Brian, middle school ELA teacher, Eastern Shore
Owl_b_TorresEdu
Oct 4 @ 9:08 PM EDT
A1: No, decisions are at the discretion of the campuses...we leave decision up to Ts w/input based on our philosophies
#BmoreEdchat
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:09 PM EDT
A1 Not specifically, but bc I am a gifted intervention specialist ina pull out program, Ohio doesn't allow me to assign hmwk
#BmoreEdchat
DrBrianCook
Oct 4 @ 9:09 PM EDT
A1: No official policy here..
#BmoreEdchat
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:10 PM EDT
Nice that it is a building-level decision. Addresses unique qualities of each school.
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @Owl_b_TorresEdu
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:10 PM EDT
Frankie, LDT M.Ed. Student, Atlanta
#BMoreEdChat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:10 PM EDT
Interesting. So your lessons must be completely self-contained?
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @TechieTeachOtt
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:11 PM EDT
Are there unoffical policies? Guidelines or common understandings?
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @DrBrianCook
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:11 PM EDT
A1: My former school did not. However, reading at home was highly encouraged.
#BMoreEdChat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:11 PM EDT
Q2: Do you think districts or schools should have homework policies? Why or why not?
#BmoreEdchat
jazzmeister2013
Oct 4 @ 9:12 PM EDT
Hey
#BmoreEdchat
leaders! Greg- K,
#TeamFelegy
. Hope all are well. On mobile tonight looking forward to engaging.
DrBrianCook
Oct 4 @ 9:12 PM EDT
It’s a school by school decision. It really depends on the administrator. Mine is great and leaves it to T discretion.
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @TechieTeachOtt
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:13 PM EDT
Yes, I can give Ss opportunities for work outside of class and can advice to Ts on differentiated hmwk, but cannot require it.
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog
Owl_b_TorresEdu
Oct 4 @ 9:14 PM EDT
A2: Really should be campus decision...campus all have unique needs & personalities
#BmoreEdchat
myassignment
Oct 4 @ 9:15 PM EDT
The Complete Guide to UK Car Driving Theory Test
https://t.co/Z8TN4t4GK0
#1to1techat
#BmoreEdchat
#DTK12chat
jazzmeister2013
Oct 4 @ 9:15 PM EDT
A1- HW certainly part of the grading policy but left to individual T. HW has many variables that can influence effectiveness.
#BmoreEdchat
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:15 PM EDT
A2 if they do, should be more of a flipped learning model. Stop sending Ss home to practice work they may not understand!
#BmoreEdchat
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:15 PM EDT
A2: There R many misconceptions about the necessity of hwk b/w Ts & esp Ps. A research-supported policy could help address it.
#BMoreEdChat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:16 PM EDT
And, I would argue, the vast majority of homework ends up being ineffective!
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @jazzmeister2013
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:16 PM EDT
Q3 coming. A quick poll...
#BmoreEdchat
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:16 PM EDT
I get MUCH more pushback from Ps about no homework than any other stakeholder.
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @FrancesChizuko, @BooksBytesBlog
DrBrianCook
Oct 4 @ 9:17 PM EDT
I agree..the variables are sometimes a great obstacle and it can be different for each student...
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @jazzmeister2013
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:17 PM EDT
Q3: Do you assign homework? Why or why not?
#BmoreEdchat
jazzmeister2013
Oct 4 @ 9:17 PM EDT
I agree, which is why my most common HW for my K Ss is to read w/ family each night, in whatever language spoke at home.
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @TechieTeachOtt
BaltoESOL
Oct 4 @ 9:18 PM EDT
Natalia, ESOL teacher in Baltimore
#BmoreEdchat
DrBrianCook
Oct 4 @ 9:18 PM EDT
A2: I am for autonomy and T choice, but one needs to know the purpose and value of HW being assigned.
#BmoreEdchat
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:18 PM EDT
Interesting. Would love to have some of them explain.
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @TechieTeachOtt, @FrancesChizuko
jazzmeister2013
Oct 4 @ 9:18 PM EDT
Absolutely! Can vary widely from S to S.
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @DrBrianCook
R_CILR
Oct 4 @ 9:19 PM EDT
A3: With my K and 1st Ss, I asked them to read books at home. I sent home copy paper books during the year.
#bmoreedchat
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:19 PM EDT
Same here! At the start of school, the team would share an article that supported our decision to nix it with the parents.
#BMoreEdChat
In reply to @TechieTeachOtt, @BooksBytesBlog
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:19 PM EDT
I love your emphasis on the language! Do you have a lot of ELL students?
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @jazzmeister2013
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:19 PM EDT
Love the addendum of "whatever language spoken at home". Acknowledges parental participation and culture.
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @jazzmeister2013, @TechieTeachOtt
Jill_Snell81
Oct 4 @ 9:19 PM EDT
Lurking and learning with
#BmoreEdchat
tonight
#msetlearns
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:00 PM EDT
Welcome to
#BmoreEdchat
this evening! Please intro yourself with your name, role, & location.
DrBrianCook
Oct 4 @ 9:20 PM EDT
A3: Minimally..when I do, I try to allow it to expand and stretch the learning target. HW cannot be punitive tasks
#bmoreedchat
massignmenthelp
Oct 4 @ 9:20 PM EDT
The Complete Guide to UK Car Driving Theory Test
https://t.co/skWVo4OBdl
#1to1techat
#BmoreEdchat
#DTK12chat
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:20 PM EDT
A3 Nope! Not allowed. :)
#BmoreEdchat
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:20 PM EDT
I think most Ps want to help their child as much as they can. And hmwk is what they know best.
#BmoreEdChat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog, @TechieTeachOtt
Sayers_ELA
Oct 4 @ 9:21 PM EDT
A3: I’m late! Alison from St. Mary’s County. HW is reading 20 min each night. I provide novels to choose from.
#BmoreEdchat
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:21 PM EDT
Excellent point.
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @FrancesChizuko, @TechieTeachOtt
BaltoESOL
Oct 4 @ 9:21 PM EDT
A3 I assign homework starting in 2nd grade. I work with ELLs who have a strong homework culture. They actually ask for more 🤔
#BmoreEdchat
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:21 PM EDT
Do you mind sharing the article here?
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @FrancesChizuko, @BooksBytesBlog
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:21 PM EDT
Flipping the classroom really helped with this in a more productive way.
#BMoreEdChat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog, @TechieTeachOtt
jazzmeister2013
Oct 4 @ 9:21 PM EDT
Yes, I have a number of ELL Ss each year. Ps feel better when language barrier is removed. Ss benefit greatly!
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @TechieTeachOtt
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:22 PM EDT
Yes! That would be great! Would like to read it.
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @TechieTeachOtt, @FrancesChizuko
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:22 PM EDT
True. I always point them in the direction of some great, free resources they can use at home. My favorite is
@khanacademy
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @FrancesChizuko, @BooksBytesBlog, @khanacademy
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:23 PM EDT
Q4 dropping soon...
#BmoreEdchat
DrBrianCook
Oct 4 @ 9:23 PM EDT
Love having student choice of novels; let students read what their attracted too.
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @Sayers_ELA
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:23 PM EDT
I LOVE flipped classroom model! When I taught middle schl math, everything was flipped and I had so much more time with Ss
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @FrancesChizuko, @BooksBytesBlog
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:24 PM EDT
How do you make the homework you do assign most effective? Any particular methods you use?
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @BaltoESOL
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:24 PM EDT
Q4: Should homework be something student can complete independently?
#BmoreEdchat
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:24 PM EDT
Sure! Let me find a couple, and I'll share them.
#BMoreEdChat
In reply to @TechieTeachOtt, @BooksBytesBlog
jazzmeister2013
Oct 4 @ 9:25 PM EDT
Yes indeed! A skill is a skill is a skill.
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @BaltoESOL, @TechieTeachOtt
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:25 PM EDT
My Ps loved it, too! I did it for only one unit in math (2nd). Ps loved being able to help their Ss if they wanted to.
#BMoreEdChat
In reply to @TechieTeachOtt, @BooksBytesBlog
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:26 PM EDT
A4 100% yes, absolutely, definitely. If it is not, we are setting Ss for failure & increasing the divide btw haves & have nots.
#BmoreEdchat
R_CILR
Oct 4 @ 9:26 PM EDT
A4: My thought when I read that was (and I've seen this posted by someone on Twitter), if given, HW should be the choice of Ss.
#bmoreedchat
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:26 PM EDT
A4: I believe this depends highly on the content and instructional objectives.
#BMoreEdChat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog
jazzmeister2013
Oct 4 @ 9:26 PM EDT
Sharing is caring!
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @TechieTeachOtt, @FrancesChizuko, @BooksBytesBlog, @khanacademy
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:27 PM EDT
I love how much it let me differentiate in class. I could give a quick check assessment and then group daily based on need!
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @FrancesChizuko, @BooksBytesBlog
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:27 PM EDT
Do you mean choice as to completing it or not?
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @R_CILR
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:27 PM EDT
Thanks!
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @FrancesChizuko, @BooksBytesBlog
R_CILR
Oct 4 @ 9:29 PM EDT
S choice as to what it is that they want to work on and how they decided to represent their learning.
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:29 PM EDT
I've hrd many Ts question the possibility that Ss actually will do it. Then the debate of credit comes into play. what do u do?
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @R_CILR
DrBrianCook
Oct 4 @ 9:30 PM EDT
A4: Yes, but it cannot hurt to reach out to an adult. It's great when adults help!
#BmoreEdChat
LaRueKMurphy
Oct 4 @ 9:31 PM EDT
A4: I’m late. Yes, hawk should be completed independently. A reinforced skill or practice from a lesson taught in class.
#BmoreEdchat
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:31 PM EDT
It took me a bit of time to get into a routine. I did learn to keep the process of recording simple.
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog, @TechieTeachOtt
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:32 PM EDT
Q5: How do you deal with students who do not complete homework?
#BmoreEdchat
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:32 PM EDT
Definitely! I love when adults work w/ Ss on hmwk- talking and thinking together. I just don't want them to NEED an adult.
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @DrBrianCook
phhscience
Oct 4 @ 9:32 PM EDT
A3 If Ss don't understand the material why give it for homework and if the Ss understands the material why give it for homework
#BmoreEdchat
R_CILR
Oct 4 @ 9:32 PM EDT
I would expect them to bring proof (a representation) of their learning, so that would show they did it.
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @FrancesChizuko
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:33 PM EDT
Sounds almost like it could be project (or problem) based learning!
#BMoreEdChat
In reply to @R_CILR
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:33 PM EDT
I don't give any credit for homework. Ss only get "credit" in my class for mastering content.
#masterylearning
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @FrancesChizuko, @R_CILR
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:33 PM EDT
Yes!!!
#BmoreEdChat
phhscience
Oct 4 @ 9:32 PM EDT
A3 If Ss don't understand the material why give it for homework and if the Ss understands the material why give it for homework
#BmoreEdchat
LaRueKMurphy
Oct 4 @ 9:34 PM EDT
A5: When I gave hmwk, I would allow Ss 10 mins before class to complete it.
#BmoreEdchat
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:34 PM EDT
This! It doesn't make much sense when you think about it this way!
#bmoreedchat
phhscience
Oct 4 @ 9:32 PM EDT
A3 If Ss don't understand the material why give it for homework and if the Ss understands the material why give it for homework
#BmoreEdchat
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:35 PM EDT
I agree! And this is also why I never graded hwk for the gradebook. It got checked tho.
#BMoreEdChat
But a 100% doesn't mean they got it.
In reply to @TechieTeachOtt, @DrBrianCook
BaltoESOL
Oct 4 @ 9:35 PM EDT
A4 I think Ss should be able to do it independently. Otherwise students who have less support available are at a disadvantage.
#BmoreEdchat
DrBrianCook
Oct 4 @ 9:36 PM EDT
A5: Love 'em and their situation - Work w/ them through it and make it an awesome learning opportunity to support their growth
#BmoreEdChat
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:37 PM EDT
Q6: In your opinion, what impact does homework have on student achievement?
#BmoreEdchat
phhscience
Oct 4 @ 9:37 PM EDT
I never assign homework Ss may complete an assignment at home if they did not complete it in class
#bmoreedchat
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:39 PM EDT
A6 Totally depends on how it is assigned & used. Too often, it doesn't or negatively impact- by lowering grades & Ss confidence
#BmoreEdchat
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:39 PM EDT
A5I've only given hwk when it was required. If the S got it, I didn't stress. If they didn't, we wrkd on the concepts in class.
#BMoreEdChat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog
phhscience
Oct 4 @ 9:40 PM EDT
#bmoreedchat
LaRueKMurphy
Oct 4 @ 9:41 PM EDT
A6: It depends on what kind of homework is assigned.
#BmoreEdchat
AssignmentHelpN
Oct 4 @ 9:41 PM EDT
The SAMR Model: Effective Technology Integration in Classrooms
https://t.co/N8NF3byMeG
#1to1techat
#BmoreEdchat
#DTK12chat
Sayers_ELA
Oct 4 @ 9:41 PM EDT
A6 Ss reading outside of school impacts reading skills greatly. Just need enough time & resources to get great books to kids.
#BmoreEdchat
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:42 PM EDT
Did you allow them to work together?
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @LaRueKMurphy
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:43 PM EDT
Me too. Even had a student bring in a self-assigned project. A diagram of her thoughts about the Flint water crisis. (Gov unit)
#BmoreEdChat
In reply to @phhscience
R_CILR
Oct 4 @ 9:43 PM EDT
Getting the books is important. Have you heard of the rain gutter books some schools have in the hallway for Ss to take home?
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @Sayers_ELA
phhscience
Oct 4 @ 9:43 PM EDT
If homework was optional how many Ss would do it?
#bmoreedchat
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:44 PM EDT
What a great idea!
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @R_CILR, @Sayers_ELA
MrMcGrain
Oct 4 @ 9:44 PM EDT
#bmoreedchat
Side question, honest question: What counts as homework? Is asking a student to read in advance of lit class homework?
R_CILR
Oct 4 @ 9:44 PM EDT
My 1st and K Ss loved getting books from the rain gutters!
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @Sayers_ELA
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:45 PM EDT
Q7: How can we help shape homework policy to be fair to all students?
#BmoreEdchat
R_CILR
Oct 4 @ 9:45 PM EDT
Thanks. Not my idea, but I have worked at schools that used it.
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog, @Sayers_ELA
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:46 PM EDT
This is such a cute idea!
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @R_CILR, @Sayers_ELA
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:46 PM EDT
What was the student response? Did they keep the books, return or replace with already read books?
#curious
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @R_CILR, @Sayers_ELA
R_CILR
Oct 4 @ 9:46 PM EDT
Thanks! As I mentioned, I learned about it from schools I worked at.
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @FrancesChizuko, @Sayers_ELA
Sayers_ELA
Oct 4 @ 9:46 PM EDT
A7 By not assuming resources required for completion are in each home. Ex: I provide books, kids just have to read.
#BmoreEdchat
BaltoESOL
Oct 4 @ 9:48 PM EDT
A7 Have conversations with parents. HW was a topic at our School/family council. The result is a school-wide HW policy.
#bmoreedchat
LaRueKMurphy
Oct 4 @ 9:49 PM EDT
A7: I used a tic-tac-toe grid when using homework. They chose 3 squares they wanted to complete.
#BmoreEdchat
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:49 PM EDT
That sounds powerful. What is your school policy?
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @BaltoESOL
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:49 PM EDT
When we stop defining learning by hmwk, grades, & time in class, Ss see time outside of class as learning 2. More engagement!
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @phhscience
R_CILR
Oct 4 @ 9:49 PM EDT
Idea was if a book didn't come back it had a good home and was wanted. :-) Books gathered from grant funds & donations.
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog, @Sayers_ELA
phhscience
Oct 4 @ 9:50 PM EDT
A7 Use open ended questions no wrong answer
#bmoreedchat
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:50 PM EDT
A7: Not require it? Or reframe it w/ smtn like
#flippedlearning
(with access to tech). Practice at home can build bad habits.
#BMoreEdChat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:51 PM EDT
I'd like to hear it too!
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog, @BaltoESOL
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:51 PM EDT
So many amazing ideas from the
#BmoreEdchat
discussion.
#humbled
to be a learner in this PLN.
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:51 PM EDT
"Students see time outside of class as learning"
#PureGold
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @TechieTeachOtt, @phhscience
EduGladiators
Oct 4 @ 9:52 PM EDT
🔬{NEW}
#EduGladiators
series: Student Engagement w/expert
@STEMigo
leading STEM convo SATURDAY!
#BmoreEdChat
#EduCoach
#OhEdChat
#scitlap
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:54 PM EDT
Awesome chat,
@BooksBytesBlog
! I am looking forward to moderating next week's
#bmoreedchat
about
#masterylearning
! Hope 2 see you all there!
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:54 PM EDT
Q8: What is your big takeaway from tonight's discussion?
#BmoreEdchat
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:55 PM EDT
Thanks
@TechieTeachOtt
Looking forward to learning with you next week!
#BmoreEdchat
In reply to @TechieTeachOtt, @TechieTeachOtt
BaltoESOL
Oct 4 @ 9:56 PM EDT
There are many points. One point is time it takes to do it - no more than 10 min in gr.1, 20 min in grade 2, etc.
#BmoreEdChat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:56 PM EDT
Anytime! Feel free to reach out if you need any help!
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog, @FrancesChizuko
R_CILR
Oct 4 @ 9:56 PM EDT
Thank you
@BooksBytesBlog
and
#bmoreedchat
for a great chat! Have a great Wednesday!
Sayers_ELA
Oct 4 @ 9:57 PM EDT
A8 already feeling in a rut this school year, & takeaway is that w new curr I haven’t been focused on ind rdg like I need to.
#BmoreEdchat
FrancesChizuko
Oct 4 @ 9:58 PM EDT
Great chat
@BooksBytesBlog
Chat with everyone next time!
#BmoreEdchat
BooksBytesBlog
Oct 4 @ 9:58 PM EDT
A8: So many ideas, but my big takeaway is that homework should be purposeful, have student choice, provide materials, no grade.
#BmoreEdchat
TechieTeachOtt
Oct 4 @ 9:58 PM EDT
Especially students without adult help. It sets them up for struggle, frustration, fatigue, and a dislike of the subject!
#bmoreedchat
In reply to @BooksBytesBlog
phhscience
Oct 4 @ 9:58 PM EDT
Many Ss have sports, jobs and family obligations after school. Hard to fit in homework.
#bmoreedchat