#iteachphysics Archive
Bi-weekly professional development Twitter chat for physics teachers
Saturday March 18, 2017
10:00 AM EDT
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:00 AM EDT
Good morning and welcome to this week's
#iteachphysics
chat.
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:00 AM EDT
Good morning and welcome to this week's
#iteachphysics
chat.
participatechat
Mar 18 @ 10:00 AM EDT
Participate in the upcoming
#iteachphysics
by sharing resources and collaborating at
https://t.co/VkEwl4yKm4
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:00 AM EDT
Today our
#iteachphysics
friend and colleague
@nuclear94
will lead us through a discussion of ways to expose students to nuclear energy
In reply to @nuclear94
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:00 AM EDT
Today our
#iteachphysics
friend and colleague
@nuclear94
will lead us through a discussion of ways to expose students to nuclear energy
In reply to @nuclear94
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:00 AM EDT
Nuclear energy and radioactivity are natural curiousities for many students. How do we as professionals accommodate this?
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:00 AM EDT
Nuclear energy and radioactivity are natural curiousities for many students. How do we as professionals accommodate this?
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:00 AM EDT
I’m Jeff Terry. I teach UG & Grad Physics at
@IIT_Science
. I’m going to discuss teaching nuclear energy in the classroom
#iteachphysics
In reply to @IIT_Science
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:00 AM EDT
Before
@nuclear94
gets going, let's do an
#iteachphysics
roll call. Please tell what level Ss you teach and where
In reply to @nuclear94
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:00 AM EDT
Before
@nuclear94
gets going, let's do an
#iteachphysics
roll call. Please tell what level Ss you teach and where
In reply to @nuclear94
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:01 AM EDT
And please remember to include the hashtag
#iteachphysics
in all your tweets
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:01 AM EDT
And please remember to include the hashtag
#iteachphysics
in all your tweets
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:01 AM EDT
Energy isn’t the most well covered concept in either high school or college physics.
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:02 AM EDT
Also what is your ans to Q1: How many of you currently teach Energy production (nuclear or otherwise) in physics courses?
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:02 AM EDT
Also what is your ans to Q1: How many of you currently teach Energy production (nuclear or otherwise) in physics courses?
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:03 AM EDT
Energy allows one to introduce the equations of quantum mechanics
#Iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:03 AM EDT
I really like to teach general physics from the standpoint of energy
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:04 AM EDT
But energy is far more important to the general public than just equations of classical or quantum physics
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:04 AM EDT
At
@illinoisTech
, our general physics classes have far more non-majors than majors
#iteachphysics
In reply to @illinoistech
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:04 AM EDT
It is important to cover things beyond traditional physics. Things that will affect them in their careers
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:04 AM EDT
Because of this, I cover topics like energy production, generation, transmission, storage, heat flow
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:05 AM EDT
There are resources for teaching these topics in elementary, high school, and college physics.
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:05 AM EDT
In Gen Phys I, of course the conservation of energy comes up. In Gen Phys 2, maybe the principles of generators come up
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:05 AM EDT
In Gen Phys I, of course the conservation of energy comes up. In Gen Phys 2, maybe the principles of generators come up
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:05 AM EDT
It is necessary to cover these topics as there is a tremendous amount of confusion and misinformation
#iteachphysics
EduGladiators
Mar 18 @ 10:05 AM EDT
☎️TODAY
#EduGladiators
joins forces w/
#EdCampWake
&
@BrendanFetters
leads the convo!
#edcampyork
#HIVEChicago
#edcampphirst
#iteachphysics
wslaton
Mar 18 @ 10:06 AM EDT
I teach physics for life science majors as well as physics majors courses at a predominately undergrad institution.
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:00 AM EDT
Before
@nuclear94
gets going, let's do an
#iteachphysics
roll call. Please tell what level Ss you teach and where
In reply to @nuclear94
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:06 AM EDT
If we look at the teaching energy production, we tend to focus on the mechanics and not the system
@BlackPhysicists
#iteachphysics
In reply to @BlackPhysicists
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:07 AM EDT
sounds good
#iteachphysics
In reply to @Abcharya22
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:07 AM EDT
Also in gen physics 2, the very basics of distribution , i.e., IV of production and I^2R of losses + induction transformers
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:07 AM EDT
Also in gen physics 2, the very basics of distribution , i.e., IV of production and I^2R of losses + induction transformers
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:07 AM EDT
Over the years, I’ve gone into 100s if not 1000s of high schools to discuss the problems of converting and storing energy
#Iteachphysics
AlexVKluge
Mar 18 @ 10:07 AM EDT
Alex, taught physics while grad S at UT Austin, worked in nuclear fusion at
@Livermore_Lab
current work includes physics
#OER
#iTeachPhysics
In reply to @Livermore_Lab
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:07 AM EDT
I think the nuclear energy community needs many more people going out into high schools to do this
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:08 AM EDT
Q2: Why do few state physics standards include electricity generation, transportation fuels?
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:08 AM EDT
Q2: Why do few state physics standards include electricity generation, transportation fuels?
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:08 AM EDT
If nuclear energy is ever going to have a renaissance, it has to win over hearts and minds.
#Iteachphysics
wslaton
Mar 18 @ 10:08 AM EDT
As in powerplant energy production? If teaching Thermal Physics then yes but generally no except for very basic stuff.
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:02 AM EDT
Also what is your ans to Q1: How many of you currently teach Energy production (nuclear or otherwise) in physics courses?
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:08 AM EDT
To do so, it has to build a pipeline of students who are not susceptible to misinformation or “alternate facts”
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:08 AM EDT
I've concluded, the best way to accomplish this is to familiarize students with nuclear concepts through lecture & experiment
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:08 AM EDT
Q: Why do few state physics standards include electricity generation, transportation fuels?
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:09 AM EDT
#iteachphysics
A2: I think 1st we have to ask if there are physics state standards at all. In Virginia I think there are not.
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:09 AM EDT
#iteachphysics
A2: I think 1st we have to ask if there are physics state standards at all. In Virginia I think there are not.
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:10 AM EDT
Given the importance of energy to modern society, it seems odd that standards bodies don't require it to be taught
#iteachphysics
massignmenthelp
Mar 18 @ 10:10 AM EDT
#iteachphysics
#nt2v
5 Daily Habits that will Boost your GPA
https://t.co/P32ItfDV0A
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:10 AM EDT
One would think that given the importance of energy to our society that teaching it to students would be mandatory
#Iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:10 AM EDT
This is not the case, When mentioned in the standards, it is often not in physics but in environmental science.
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:11 AM EDT
Q: What are the best ways to rectify this oversight of energy generation in HS education standards?
#Iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:12 AM EDT
Q3: What are the best ways to rectify this, if it should be rectified?
#Iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:12 AM EDT
Q3: What are the best ways to rectify this, if it should be rectified?
#Iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:12 AM EDT
#iteachphysics
@nuclear94
Is nuclear pwr production covered in HS environmental science curriculum?
In reply to @nuclear94
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:12 AM EDT
Contact your local school board. Contact state education standard bodies. Tell them energy production must be taught
#Iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:13 AM EDT
This is a good question. For example, it is in the Indiana standards for environmental science
@BlackPhysicists
#iteachphysics
In reply to @BlackPhysicists
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:14 AM EDT
I am just not sure how many high schools teach classes in environmental science.
@BlackPhysicists
#iteachphysics
In reply to @BlackPhysicists
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:14 AM EDT
#iteachphysics
@nuclear94
Well in
#physics
a lot of teachers are doing so out of area. How many have had a nuclear physics course?
In reply to @nuclear94
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:15 AM EDT
Tell these education groups to make sure that energy production must be covered in the standards
https://t.co/z9F2oYXnl3
#iteachphysics
AssignmentHelpN
Mar 18 @ 10:15 AM EDT
#iteachphysics
#nt2v
Top 10 Books for Studying Macroeconomics
https://t.co/KoxqyfE0AZ
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:16 AM EDT
Training is always nice. The University of Missouri has a nice summer program for high school teachers.
@BlackPhysicists
#iteachphysics
In reply to @BlackPhysicists
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:17 AM EDT
The easiest path is to introduce Nuclear Energy through lectures.
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:17 AM EDT
The easiest path is to introduce Nuclear Energy through lectures.
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:17 AM EDT
Q: What resources are available to help teachers or public introduce Energy topics
#iteachphysics
?
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:17 AM EDT
Q: What resources are available to help teachers or public introduce Energy topics
#iteachphysics
?
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:18 AM EDT
It is often helpful to contact and discuss energy policy and energy education with local politicians
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:18 AM EDT
Explain to all of these stakeholders why it is necessary to cover all the effects of electricity generation and transmission
#iteachphysics
AlexVKluge
Mar 18 @ 10:18 AM EDT
Halliday and Resnick, the book we for AP physics, touches, briefly, on nuclear energy.
https://t.co/SXsTKh2gto
#iTeachPhysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:19 AM EDT
For reasons that I will discuss later, there are often problems doing experiments with radioactive materials in high schools
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:19 AM EDT
This makes lectures on the topic far easier to do. There are many resources from which one can pull information
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:19 AM EDT
We have chatted about teaching energy literacy in the past
https://t.co/uXnAmct2C5
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:19 AM EDT
We have chatted about teaching energy literacy in the past
https://t.co/pW0qgB3G0B
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:20 AM EDT
In high school, I tend to pull information from a variety of sources
#iteachphysics
AlexVKluge
Mar 18 @ 10:20 AM EDT
A look at the table of contents shows part of the problem - with so much material, nuclear power can't occupy much time.
#iTeachPhysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:20 AM EDT
One of my favorite sources is the
@EIAgov
’s Energy Explained site
https://t.co/1jlXSwPgrq
#iteachphysics
In reply to @EIAgov
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:20 AM EDT
Here is an archive of the site, just in case it goes away.
https://t.co/UiFcBpybDG
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:21 AM EDT
The
@Livermore_Lab
Energy Flow diagrams allow the introduction of waste heat.
https://t.co/FdKgb0SJ1x
#iteachphysics
In reply to @Livermore_Lab
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:21 AM EDT
.
@livermore_lab
has a nice video explaining how to use their energy flow diagrams.
https://t.co/G2NU2tHJha
#iteachphysics
In reply to @Livermore_Lab
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:21 AM EDT
The amount of energy lost as waste heat is really staggering.
@Livermore_Lab
#iteachphysics
In reply to @Livermore_Lab
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:22 AM EDT
#Iteachphysics
That was a link to a bunch of resources. Here's the chat itself
https://t.co/b4U9YVakLY
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:22 AM EDT
#Iteachphysics
That was a link to a bunch of resources. Here's the chat itself
https://t.co/L1W9BfE7h0
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:22 AM EDT
It is one of the big drivers of trying to recover this lost energy for process heat. Move factories near power plants
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:23 AM EDT
The American Nuclear Society
@ans_org
has many good resources available for teachers.
https://t.co/1vxHdPNO64
#iteachphysics
In reply to @ans_org
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:23 AM EDT
The
@nuclearmuseum
and it's
@nuclearsciweek
program has a number of resources
https://t.co/T8n4xddEma
#iteachphysics
In reply to @nuclearmuseum, @nuclearsciweek
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:23 AM EDT
Q: How many people contact or have been contacted by teachers to explain energy in the classroom?
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:23 AM EDT
Q: How many people contact or have been contacted by teachers to explain energy in the classroom?
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:23 AM EDT
Nuclear medicine is another benefit that came about through nuclear energy
#iteachphysics
https://t.co/EfNbIvnK0e
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:23 AM EDT
Neutron activation analysis is also an import use of neutrons from reactors
https://t.co/YjNm34BDJn
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:24 AM EDT
I imagine the local power companies have people whose whole job it is to support teachers
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:24 AM EDT
I imagine the local power companies have people whose whole job it is to support teachers
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:24 AM EDT
Q: How many students have raised Qs in class about energy production and distribution in class?
#iteachphysics
@BlackPhysicists
In reply to @BlackPhysicists
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:25 AM EDT
Q: How do you answer these questions about energy production in general?
@BlackPhysicists
#iteachphysics
In reply to @BlackPhysicists
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:25 AM EDT
Do students recognize that Naturally occurring radioactive materials (NORM) exist?
#iteachphysics
MrLeNadj
Mar 18 @ 10:25 AM EDT
Good morning 2 you too & 2 all
#iteachphysics
colleagues. Sorry 4 not being as active as I would like; shuttling son.
In reply to @BlackPhysicists
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:26 AM EDT
Do students know that they are naturally radioactive?
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:26 AM EDT
Do they know that coal plants release radioactivity?
https://t.co/UT0kKMUpmH
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:27 AM EDT
Q: What should be covered when talking to students about energy conversion? (Energy, Intermittancy, Ecological Effects, Grid)
#Iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:28 AM EDT
I know orgs like
@NavyLeagueUS
&
@PacificSubs
can always scare up bodies to work w/ physics teachers & speak at schools
#iteachphysics
In reply to @NavyLeagueUS, @PacificSubs
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:28 AM EDT
I know orgs like
@NavyLeagueUS
&
@PacificSubs
can always scare up bodies to work w/ physics teachers & speak at schools
#iteachphysics
In reply to @NavyLeagueUS, @PacificSubs
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:28 AM EDT
I tend to start by covering energy poverty and the human development index
https://t.co/a00eSZ7meX
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 8:18 AM EDT
The human development index shows the importance of energy use to modern society.
https://t.co/OtqfIcr5BB
MrLeNadj
Mar 18 @ 10:28 AM EDT
Kinematics is over covered, which takes precious time from
#energy
coverage in
#physicsed
.
#iteachphysics
In reply to @nuclear94
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:29 AM EDT
To me, if we aren't going to use energy to perform work and make people's lives better, then what is the point?
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:30 AM EDT
#iteachphysics
@nuclear94
I'd like to see an integrated crse covering S&T of production, business & economics, env discharges, risks etc
In reply to @nuclear94
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:30 AM EDT
I move on to the use of fossil fuels, how their use has benefited society but now is damaging environment
#iteachphysics
MrLeNadj
Mar 18 @ 10:30 AM EDT
I agree with this 101%!
#iteachphysics
In reply to @nuclear94
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:31 AM EDT
Next I cover the problems of all the potential replacements. There is no perfection in energy conversion
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:31 AM EDT
Explain that no matter what we chose to do to use energy to do work, we will have an effect on the environment.
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:32 AM EDT
This can be a great segue into entropy. Entropy gets us all.
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:33 AM EDT
Show Baotou
https://t.co/5KuSEyOSBt
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:33 AM EDT
Show Bat kills
https://t.co/aLpooqNAkM
#iteachphysics
@BatConIntl
In reply to @BatConIntl
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:34 AM EDT
Germany is reportedly giving up on nuclear energy after Fukashima. That so unfortunate
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:34 AM EDT
Germany is reportedly giving up on nuclear energy after Fukashima. That so unfortunate
#iteachphysics
MrLeNadj
Mar 18 @ 10:35 AM EDT
Mention of nuclear waste generates immediate bad reactions. So, how shall this b addressed in an objective manner?
#iteachphysics
In reply to @nuclear94
AlexVKluge
Mar 18 @ 10:35 AM EDT
A2 In HS the focus is on fundamentals such as Faraday's Law, with an aside that this is related to electricity production.
#iTeachPhysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:35 AM EDT
Show Fukushima
#iteachphysics
https://t.co/yhxAkBYomN
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:35 AM EDT
Q: How many high schools have radioactive materials and radiation detectors?
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:35 AM EDT
Q: How many high schools have radioactive materials and radiation detectors?
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:36 AM EDT
I could see a lot of parents, administrators & school boards freaking out over the idea of radioactive materials in schools
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:36 AM EDT
I could see a lot of parents, administrators & school boards freaking out over the idea of radioactive materials in schools
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:37 AM EDT
There are reactor designs that will burn nuclear waste
https://t.co/8PhIw4zgi9
@MrLeNadj
#iteachphysics
In reply to @MrLeNadj
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:37 AM EDT
We should probably build a few of those new designs to see how well they work.
@MrLeNadj
#iteachphysics
In reply to @MrLeNadj
AlexVKluge
Mar 18 @ 10:38 AM EDT
I remember building a Wilson cloud chamber, definitely doable at the HS level.
#iTeachPhysics
In reply to @BlackPhysicists
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:38 AM EDT
Speaking to students about energy is great but experiments with them is even better.
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:38 AM EDT
Q: How many schools have policies that allow or forbid demonstrations using radioactive materials?
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:38 AM EDT
Q: How many schools have policies that allow or forbid demonstrations using radioactive materials?
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:39 AM EDT
Q: How many high schools have radioactive materials and radiation detectors?
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:39 AM EDT
Q: How many schools have policies that allow or forbid demonstrations using radioactive materials?
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:40 AM EDT
If schools have radioactive materials and detectors on site already, then great. Experiments & demos are easy
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:40 AM EDT
My high school had Geiger counters and radioactive sources. Allowed for simple shielding experiments
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:40 AM EDT
Other schools I have gone into have required me to bring equipment from the university
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:41 AM EDT
Make sure that you follow all property rules when you are checking equipment out
#paperwork
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:42 AM EDT
Some schools that I have gone into have required the teacher to send home permission slips to get parents permission
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:42 AM EDT
The key is training. Chemistry is having a huge problem with lab safety in HS and college settings
#iteachphysics
https://t.co/qQDOrJRee5
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:42 AM EDT
The key is training. Chemistry is having a huge problem with lab safety in HS and college settings
#iteachphysics
https://t.co/Izs4WJR45v
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:43 AM EDT
Don't be afraid to go through these processes. In my opinion, it is worth the effort to show students new opportunities
#iteachphysics
arclight
Mar 18 @ 10:44 AM EDT
Touch on generational equity. Land scarring & tails from mining, decimation of whales, nuclear waste, AGW
#iteachphysics
In reply to @nuclear94
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:44 AM EDT
That is a big problem in my opinion. There are some reactors that will do high school tours.
@DuncLuciak
#iteachphysics
In reply to @DuncLuciak
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:45 AM EDT
AJP: Collaborative exams: Cheating? Or learning?
https://t.co/YwomRjjvjs
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:45 AM EDT
The security theater that has overtaken modern society is detrimental, IMO.
@DuncLuciak
#iteachphysics
In reply to @DuncLuciak
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:46 AM EDT
infinitely safer than the burning methanol demonstrations
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:45 AM EDT
#iteachphysic
@nuclear94
And I would argue much safer than the most common methanol chemistry demo
In reply to @nuclear94
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:46 AM EDT
Instead of going to the HS, you can also utilize this as an opportunity to bring students to your campus for field trips.
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:46 AM EDT
.
@IllinoisTech
we have hosted field trips for high schools. They come to campus in groups. We set up experiment stations
#iteachphysics
In reply to @illinoistech
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:46 AM EDT
We let the students perform experiments in groups. Involve admissions and recruiting office
#iteachphysics
arclight
Mar 18 @ 10:46 AM EDT
Point is that costs of activity are passed on to later generations for benefits enjoyed now
#iteachphysics
In reply to @nuclear94
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:47 AM EDT
There are a number of ways to get nuclear experiments in front of high school students
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:47 AM EDT
Q: Can schools use NORM (Uranium, potassium) for demonstrations?
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:47 AM EDT
Even if radioactive materials are banned on a high school campus, they may have exceptions for NORM
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:48 AM EDT
You can do a number of experiments with salt substitute. That stuff is more than radioactive enough
https://t.co/QPdHWo3jVQ
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:48 AM EDT
A few years ago I had the hardest time convincing a student that a nuclear reactor could not blow up like a nuclear bomb
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:48 AM EDT
A few years ago I had the hardest time convincing a student that a nuclear reactor could not blow up like a nuclear bomb
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:49 AM EDT
When I said one good indicator is that it's never happened, he just responded, "yet"
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:49 AM EDT
When I said one good indicator is that it's never happened, he just responded, "yet"
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:49 AM EDT
Mixing it with sand allows one to do a simple separations experiment. Salt dissolves in water and removes the radioactivity
#iteachphysics
AlexVKluge
Mar 18 @ 10:49 AM EDT
It's not just our reactions, but those of parents, peers, and politicians.
#iTeachPhysics
In reply to @nuclear94
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:50 AM EDT
Q: What experiments can be done to simulate nuclear energy concepts if radioactive materials are banned?
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:50 AM EDT
Fortunately,
@ans_org
has a number of nuclear experiments that can be done without radioactive materials
#iteachphysics
In reply to @ans_org
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:51 AM EDT
The mouse trap reactor is a favorite.
https://t.co/yqS1gxRhuX
.
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:51 AM EDT
Mouse trap reactor video
https://t.co/i9OoNMxCUl
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:53 AM EDT
Often need too many bananas
@rjallain
#iteachphysics
In reply to @rjallain
AlexVKluge
Mar 18 @ 10:53 AM EDT
Don't forget about simulations, some of which are free,
#OER
,
https://t.co/97Io9NG6VZ
#iTeachPhysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:54 AM EDT
measuring cosmic rays.
#iteachphysics
https://t.co/0aBnRfgduu
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:54 AM EDT
Q: What experiments can be done when radioactive materials can be used?
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:54 AM EDT
If you can bring in radioactive materials, this opens up a host of opportunities.
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:54 AM EDT
I'd like to do a scenario based exercise just to explore how/why uranium based reactors were chosen over thorium based ones
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:54 AM EDT
I'd like to do a scenario based exercise just to explore how/why uranium based reactors were chosen over thorium based ones
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:54 AM EDT
Spectrum techniques sells a number of exempt sources that can be used for a variety of experiments.
https://t.co/2gTyplQuWC
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:55 AM EDT
My favorite experiment involves having students build their own detector by taking apart a cheap webcam.
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:55 AM EDT
By carefully removing the glass cover over a ccd chip in a cheap ($9.99) web cam, you can make a 2D radiation detector
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:55 AM EDT
Each flash is due to energy lost from a beta particle from a Sr-90 source.
https://t.co/80FK9abRTg
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:55 AM EDT
Alpha particles interact much more strongly and deposit all of their energy in a pixel
https://t.co/TOttlRl5Fk
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:56 AM EDT
Cloud chambers are also easy to build in a classroom.
https://t.co/V6gIoxLRGO
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:56 AM EDT
Physics teachers can also work with biology teachers re applications of nuclear science in general. That would be fun
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:56 AM EDT
Physics teachers can also work with biology teachers re applications of nuclear science in general. That would be fun
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:56 AM EDT
Q: How can research reactors support education on the high school level?
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:56 AM EDT
The Purdue research reactor hosts visits from a number of school groups each year.
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:56 AM EDT
Did You Know?: Purdue Reactor No. 1 - Purdue University
https://t.co/xOeZTX5ccc
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:57 AM EDT
MIT reactor has a beam line that can be remotely controlled to perform neutron absorption experiments
https://t.co/lbcT1UwNyM
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:57 AM EDT
On my last visit to the MIT reactor, I stood an watched students at a college remotely manipulating filters.
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:57 AM EDT
The Penn State reactor sells irradiated salt. This salt can be used to experiment with radiation damage.
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:57 AM EDT
Defects in salt created by irradiation can explain dosimetry and semiconductor failure.
#iteachphysics
https://t.co/hMzcupam1n
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:57 AM EDT
I would really like to see all university research reactors develop remote experiments for HS students
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:57 AM EDT
Many of the coolest experiments that I’ve done have involved a nuclear reactor. Great way to get students excited.
#iteachphysics
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:58 AM EDT
A lot of univ nuke engr depts are that + 'radiological sciences' now So applications other than pwr production are fair game
#iteachphysics
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:58 AM EDT
A lot of univ nuke engr depts are that + 'radiological sciences' now So applications other than pwr production are fair game
#iteachphysics
nuclear94
Mar 18 @ 10:58 AM EDT
As we come to the end of the
#iteachphysics
chat hour, I hope that I have given you some resources that you can utilize in the future.
BlackPhysicists
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:59 AM EDT
We are coming up on the end of our
#iteachphysics
hour
@nuclear94
what are more resources of colleagues that want to cover nuclear science?
In reply to @nuclear94
iteachphysics
- Moderator
Mar 18 @ 10:59 AM EDT
We are coming up on the end of our
#iteachphysics
hour
@nuclear94
what are more resources of colleagues that want to cover nuclear science?
In reply to @nuclear94