#UTedChat Archive
#UTedChat happens every Wed. @ 9pm MDT. We discuss educational topics relevant to Utah and the general education landscape.
Wednesday January 20, 2016
11:00 PM EST
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:00 PM EST
Welcome to
#utedchat
. Tonight I’ll lead the disc on Asking Great ?s. What is your name, school, and favorite question for icebreakers.
bobjackman
Jan 20 @ 11:00 PM EST
#utedchat
Checking in, but will be in and out.
RoysGil
Jan 20 @ 11:01 PM EST
#utedchat
Checking in, but will be in and out.
https://t.co/kT0awZ3OB4
kiingkaaylee
Jan 20 @ 11:00 PM EST
so excited for our first friendly (: come support your soccer girls @ sharpstown tomorrow, 4:30 it's bout to be litttt!!!
DaniKSloan
Jan 20 @ 11:01 PM EST
Dani from
@UENpd
| What was your first aol screen name?
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:02 PM EST
Share your thoughts about tonight’s topic in a Google Form -
https://t.co/WnILWi2mow
#utedchat
segolilylife
Jan 20 @ 11:02 PM EST
#UTedChat
Courtney Johnson checking in.
#segolilylife
bobjackman
Jan 20 @ 11:02 PM EST
#utedchat
@covili
great question! I rarely do icebreaker a because I never know what to do. Can't wait to get some ideas.
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:03 PM EST
Jared from
@UENpd
- love asking people about the first concert they ever attended.
#johndenver
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:05 PM EST
Q1 Self-reflection time: Why do you typically ask questions to students in class? What is your purpose?
#utedchat
ksteedtech
Jan 20 @ 11:05 PM EST
#UtedChat
Hey! Kareena Steed Vance here. Technology Specialist for Granite District and ready to learn about great questions!
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:05 PM EST
Any lurkers out there in
#utedchat
tonight? Say hi if you’re out there in cyberland.
bobjackman
Jan 20 @ 11:06 PM EST
#utedchat
A1: To check for understanding. But transitioning to discussion.
pamturley55
Jan 20 @ 11:06 PM EST
Pam from Nebo checking in
#utedchat
DaniKSloan
Jan 20 @ 11:07 PM EST
A1: I like to check for understanding and hopefully spark conversations that can lead to deeper learning.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:07 PM EST
#utedchat
https://t.co/ggX7KVpjfR
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:08 PM EST
#utedchat
https://t.co/jk8LFSosuT
segolilylife
Jan 20 @ 11:08 PM EST
#UTedChat
A1 to get a pulse if what I'm teaching is engaging. Kids let you know pretty fast.
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:09 PM EST
A1 I know I typically ask questions to get Ss engaged and participating. Helps for assessment, but prefer projects.
#utedchat
ksteedtech
Jan 20 @ 11:10 PM EST
A1: My main job is to train tools. Qs I ask have to do with facts in understanding the system and why the program is importatnt.
#UtedChat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:11 PM EST
@segolilylife
I agree that kids will let you know if content is catching their interest.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:12 PM EST
Q2 - What are your frustrations with student responses to your questions? How do you deal with the situation?
#utedchat
RJLoweut
Jan 20 @ 11:12 PM EST
A1: Mainly to check for understanding, or to spark discussion
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:12 PM EST
Love that this just popped up from my PLN.
#utedchat
https://t.co/ve0pm9O5a7
JanetChowMSc
Jan 20 @ 11:11 PM EST
The world is about questions. Questions that inspire, questions that lead to others. They spin and connect.
profbutcher
Jan 20 @ 11:12 PM EST
Late to the party, but better late than never! Kirsten Butcher from
@IDETProgram
Now for a furious review of what I missed so far
#utedchat
MaryTouchet
Jan 20 @ 11:12 PM EST
Mary Touchet joining
#UTedchat
from AMES High School Fav Ice Breaker Question… What are are your coolest scars from childhood?
segolilylife
Jan 20 @ 11:12 PM EST
#UTedChat
A1 cont. Its all about the right questions to ignite excitement about the "why" we need to learn.
bobjackman
Jan 20 @ 11:12 PM EST
#utedchat
Q2: the shallowness of their answers.
pamturley55
Jan 20 @ 11:13 PM EST
A2 The same students answering questions. Tech backchannels, discussion boards,etc help.
#utedchat
profbutcher
Jan 20 @ 11:14 PM EST
A1: I use questions to prompt students to engage in deep learning processes: prediction, analysis, inference, transfer, etc.
#utedchat
MaryTouchet
Jan 20 @ 11:15 PM EST
A1 When I question Ss I am typically encouraging discussion which leads to checking for understanding. Talking math is important
#UTedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:15 PM EST
#utedchat
https://t.co/jxytMFVP8F
DaniKSloan
Jan 20 @ 11:15 PM EST
A2: When students aren't prepared to participate. It's one thing to not understand & have questions, but another to not be ready.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:16 PM EST
#utedchat
https://t.co/lxLzViYr9v
profbutcher
Jan 20 @ 11:16 PM EST
A2: Students sometimes are afraid to be wrong. I try to break them of that early. I want them reasoning & making educated guesses
#utedchat
segolilylife
Jan 20 @ 11:16 PM EST
#UTedChat
A2 if students give that deer staring at the headlights look. You're not articulating the clarity of what you're asking.
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:17 PM EST
A2 I love it when questions and answers lead us into a good discussion. Hate it when Ss are trying to get me off task.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:17 PM EST
@segolilylife
I think the deer in the headlights has way more to do with me than it does with my Ss. Usually a bad question.
#utedchat
EdTecHakk
Jan 20 @ 11:18 PM EST
A1: Typically I ask students questions to start discussion about what they want / need to know and check for understanding.
#utedchat
DaniKSloan
Jan 20 @ 11:18 PM EST
@covili
Mr. Covili do you have any theories on Making a Murderer?
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:18 PM EST
@JanetChowMSc
Yes - we’re talking about asking better questions in
#utedchat
tonight.
segolilylife
Jan 20 @ 11:19 PM EST
#UTedChat
true that's how you know if you're on or off as a teacher.
MaryTouchet
Jan 20 @ 11:19 PM EST
A2 If I don’t get a desired response from the Ss, the majority of the time it was my fault-bad question. So, I rephrase or clarify
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:19 PM EST
@DaniKSloan
Now that you mention it I do…Hey, wait a minute!
#utedchat
EdTecHakk
Jan 20 @ 11:19 PM EST
A2: Not so much frustrated with responses to ?'s as frustrated with ?'s about what I just said by students who don’t listen.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:20 PM EST
Q3 - Essential questions are at the heart of education. How do you help your students ask essential questions in their learning?
#utedchat
ksteedtech
Jan 20 @ 11:20 PM EST
A2: Get frustrated w/Ss playing w/their screen. I control their computers remotely, bring Ss to the carpet, or use positive cueing
#UtedChat
segolilylife
Jan 20 @ 11:21 PM EST
#UTedChat
A3 Start with the "Why" Ss are naturally curious.
DaniKSloan
Jan 20 @ 11:21 PM EST
A3: I feel like essential questions help teachers and students see the bigger picture of WHY we're doing what we're doing.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:21 PM EST
A3 I think essential questions are more about curiosity than anything else. I feel successful when Ss are allowed to be curious.
#utedchat
segolilylife
Jan 20 @ 11:22 PM EST
#UTedChat
A3 the why leads to analysis and ultimately to syntheses.
EdTecHakk
Jan 20 @ 11:22 PM EST
A3: For students to question their solutions and look for alternatives to their methods is essential in order to spark ingenuity.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:23 PM EST
A3
#utedchat
https://t.co/C6OQ6UFOIn
DaniKSloan
Jan 20 @ 11:23 PM EST
A3 p2: It helps if students can relate what they're doing in class to what they want to do in real life.
#utedchat
NormanEmerson7
Jan 20 @ 11:23 PM EST
A3 If students are presented with very clear objectives at the start of the lesson, they will be able to formulate essential q's
#utedchat
pamturley55
Jan 20 @ 11:24 PM EST
A3 Too often ts identify the essential questions. Ss posing questions ignites curiousity and learning.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:25 PM EST
@NormanEmerson7
Completely agree Norman. When I establish clear expectations it helps Ss think on a deeper level.
#utedchat
profbutcher
Jan 20 @ 11:25 PM EST
A3. I see essential questions as focusing on how key concepts apply to authentic, concrete examples from students' lives.
#utedchat
segolilylife
Jan 20 @ 11:25 PM EST
#UTedChat
it's all about being the lead learner. Getting Ss excited about the content.
pamturley55
Jan 20 @ 11:25 PM EST
If ss can google the answer to our questions, we are asking the wrong questions.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:27 PM EST
Q4 - What are your strategies to get more students involved in class discussion? What role can technology play?
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:27 PM EST
@pamturley55
Agreed, but I think there is a place for lower level questions in class.
#utedchat
profbutcher
Jan 20 @ 11:28 PM EST
@pamturley55
I absolutely agree! Good questions go beyond presented information, require deep thinking, synthesis, & application!
#utedchat
pamturley55
Jan 20 @ 11:28 PM EST
@NormanEmerson7
Let me google that
#utedchat
DaniKSloan
Jan 20 @ 11:29 PM EST
A4: If Ss are nervous to participate I usually use humor to break the ice. Tech can help by letting everyone respond anonymously.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:29 PM EST
A4 Interesting that as Ss get older they answer fewer questions in class. What changed?
#utedchat
segolilylife
Jan 20 @ 11:29 PM EST
#UTedChat
A4 I watched how a school used GD to collaborate with one another today. Ss created rubrics and used the right academic language
MaryTouchet
Jan 20 @ 11:29 PM EST
A3 Luckily my curriculum has the Q’s for Ss to be discussing in their learning teams in every lesson!
#Utedchat
https://t.co/qmjE3APrAl
ksteedtech
Jan 20 @ 11:30 PM EST
A3: Authenticating student learning helps them to improve on asking essential questions.
#UtedChat
profbutcher
Jan 20 @ 11:30 PM EST
@covili
@pamturley55
True, if building to high level thinking. But need to guard against stopping w/ easy to ask recall questions
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:30 PM EST
My new favorite anonymous discussion board is Padlet. Easy to set up and a great way to encourage all Ss to participate.
#utedchat
NormanEmerson7
Jan 20 @ 11:30 PM EST
A4 Perhaps through using a twitter backchannel?
#utedchat
DaniKSloan
Jan 20 @ 11:30 PM EST
@covili
Unfortunately they were probably made feel uncomfortable or dumb by a teacher or classmate.
#utedchat
segolilylife
Jan 20 @ 11:31 PM EST
#UTedChat
True, lower level questions give Ss a base for understanding.
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:31 PM EST
@profbutcher
@pamturley55
Agreed - can’t stop with comprehension questions and feel successful as teacher or learner.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:32 PM EST
#utedchat
https://t.co/eq4xX3oOa5
profbutcher
Jan 20 @ 11:32 PM EST
A4. Wait time! Also, giving prediction options and making EVERYONE vote on an option. That leads to good discussion.
#utedchat
MaryTouchet
Jan 20 @ 11:32 PM EST
A4 To get more Ss engaged in a class discussion, Q’s that begin with “What do you think about…” are great! No right/wrong answer
#UTedchat
pamturley55
Jan 20 @ 11:32 PM EST
A4 AnswerGarden. Ask a question and responses create word cloud in real time.
#utedchat
EdTecHakk
Jan 20 @ 11:33 PM EST
A4: Using a tool like
@CanvasLMS
allows you to ask questions and get kids thinking asynchronously.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:33 PM EST
#utedchat
https://t.co/0tbqPQ9RSH
Kidsmathtalk
Jan 20 @ 11:35 PM EST
@MaryTouchet
shows that you value ss thinking as well
#utedchat
pamturley55
Jan 20 @ 11:35 PM EST
A4
@CanvasLMS
discussion bds are valuable, but find that ss need some guidance on how to use effectively.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:36 PM EST
Q5 A key part of students responding to questions is trust with the teacher. How do you build trust with your students?
#utedchat
Kidsmathtalk
Jan 20 @ 11:37 PM EST
Joining a little late but glad I could catch this great convo
#utedchat
https://t.co/ixBxeHsEkP
Kidsmathtalk
Jan 20 @ 11:37 PM EST
A5: listening to them, valuing their experience and the knowledge they come with
#utedchat
NormanEmerson7
Jan 20 @ 11:38 PM EST
A5 First of all, respect must be earned and maintained
#utedchat
DaniKSloan
Jan 20 @ 11:38 PM EST
A5: By getting to know your Ss, treating them with respect, helping them work through a wrong answer, validate their thinking.
#utedchat
michelle_zey
Jan 20 @ 11:38 PM EST
A5: Build trust by sharing honest experiences, asking Qs that show real interest & listening with intent. Ss need to know you.
#utedchat
EdTecHakk
Jan 20 @ 11:38 PM EST
A5: Best method of building trust with students is to model failure with modesty along with how to accept help graciously.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:38 PM EST
@Kidsmathtalk
Trust comes down to relationships. Tough to trust if we don’t know one another.
#utedchat
EdTecHakk
Jan 20 @ 11:39 PM EST
So… I can’t help but notice that
@lars3eb
is missing from this
#utedchat
. Is it the apocolypse?
Kidsmathtalk
Jan 20 @ 11:39 PM EST
@covili
is this a poll you ran or from an article somewhere?
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:40 PM EST
@Kidsmathtalk
We used a Google Form earlier to get some discussion going.
#utedchat
ksteedtech
Jan 20 @ 11:40 PM EST
A4: Think-Pair-Share, Jigsaw, Collaborative Google Documents, Edmodo comments/discussions
#UtedChat
profbutcher
Jan 20 @ 11:40 PM EST
A5. During discussion, helps to pick out good parts of every answer even if not "right" Helps Ss see learning as thinking process
#utedchat
EdTecHakk
Jan 20 @ 11:40 PM EST
Anyone know what time it is in London right now? Is it tea time
@lars3eb
????
#utedchat
#mormonscantdrinktea
#eveninengland
#thatsfunny
MaryTouchet
Jan 20 @ 11:40 PM EST
A5 Right away Ss know that I value their different strategies & when I openly validate the new ideas they share- they feel safe
#Utedchat
Kidsmathtalk
Jan 20 @ 11:41 PM EST
@covili
smart idea!
#utedchat
I teach my ss about F.A.I.L which has helped a few with the anxiety
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:41 PM EST
@EdTecHakk
We need to model what it’s like to explore issues we don’t understand. Show it’s ok to NOT have the answer
#utedchat
profbutcher
Jan 20 @ 11:42 PM EST
A5. Also, I explicitly address that we are a learning community, and that means we respect each other and work together to learn.
#utedchat
segolilylife
Jan 20 @ 11:42 PM EST
#UTedChat
A5 I agree with all of you. Trust. Be the change that you wish to see in the world. Mahatma Gandhi
Kidsmathtalk
Jan 20 @ 11:43 PM EST
@covili
@EdTecHakk
I am still wanted to try "my favorite no" that I have heard about on twitter. I need to write it in my plans
#utedchat
EdTecHakk
Jan 20 @ 11:43 PM EST
@covili
Right on! Especially with tech. I often tell t’s “you have 30 Canvas experts sitting in your room, ask them for help.”
#utedchat
pamturley55
Jan 20 @ 11:43 PM EST
Be trustworthy.
#utedchat
profbutcher
Jan 20 @ 11:45 PM EST
@EdTecHakk
Definitely! I love to discuss my incorrect predictions in class. Working through my mistakes makes it safe to be wrong.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:45 PM EST
Q6 How do you encourage students to self-reflect? What are some ways to have students ask themselves great questions?
#utedchat
MaryTouchet
Jan 20 @ 11:45 PM EST
@Kidsmathtalk
“Mistakes are expected, respected and inspected.”
@joboaler
#growthmindset
#Utedchat
@covili
@EdTecHakk
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:46 PM EST
@pamturley55
Great comment Pam. That is one thing we can all control.
#utedchat
EdTecHakk
Jan 20 @ 11:46 PM EST
A6: Journalling/blogging is my fav form of reflection. A lot of writing 2 get 2 the big essential question, then breakthrough.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:47 PM EST
A6
#utedchat
https://t.co/yHHGRnlJVT
Kidsmathtalk
Jan 20 @ 11:47 PM EST
@MaryTouchet
@joboaler
@covili
@EdTecHakk
love it! That should the the class theme, motto, inspiration!
#utedchat
michelle_zey
Jan 20 @ 11:48 PM EST
A6: Model your own reflection. In writing so they can see it, live and out-loud. Talk through your own process & lead by example.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:48 PM EST
A6 Really like the reflective question of the day in class. Could be an exit ticket or a self-starter?
#utedchat
myles8383
Jan 20 @ 11:49 PM EST
A6: Journaling at the end of each day. Ss write a celebration, 1 thing learned, goal for next day. Weekly reflection too.
#utedchat
ksteedtech
Jan 20 @ 11:50 PM EST
A5: Build trust with Ss by validating their opinions; community circle where Ss practice being open and being good listeners
#UtedChat
pamturley55
Jan 20 @ 11:50 PM EST
@Flipgrid
is a new tool to quickly collect video reflections
#utedchat
Kidsmathtalk
Jan 20 @ 11:51 PM EST
A6: I have been getting more into scales bc of district and it is research based. Not sure this is leading to specific q asking +
#utedchat
EdTecHakk
Jan 20 @ 11:51 PM EST
A6: Twitter! Or better yet, Instagram! Have kids reflect by posting their discovery online. End of year = collection of ideas.
#utedchat
MaryTouchet
Jan 20 @ 11:51 PM EST
A6 My HS Ss have a math journal that they write 1 question they still have at the end of the lesson (or want to explore more)
#Utedchat
myles8383
Jan 20 @ 11:51 PM EST
A6: Also Ss write reflection about their
#geniushour
weekly on their blog.
#utedchat
Kidsmathtalk
Jan 20 @ 11:52 PM EST
A6:+beyond "how do I get to 3,4,etc." unless T models think alouds to help ss ask deeper q beyond numbers
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:52 PM EST
@MaryTouchet
OK - that’s the coolest thing I heard today. Love the math journal
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:53 PM EST
Q7 Share your best/worst strategy for asking questions to the whole class. What works or doesn’t work for you?
#utedchat
Kidsmathtalk
Jan 20 @ 11:54 PM EST
off to bed now... Thanks for letting me join in tonight! have a great end of the week!
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:54 PM EST
A7 Questions don’t work when they are used to mask being unprepared.
#didiadmittothat
#utedchat
ksteedtech
Jan 20 @ 11:55 PM EST
A7: Worst strategy. Ask a question that has one answer, and ask one student.
#UtedChat
pamturley55
Jan 20 @ 11:55 PM EST
A7 Not giving enough wait time for answers doesn't work. Bueller?... Bueller?... Bueller?
#utedchat
michelle_zey
Jan 20 @ 11:55 PM EST
A7: Worst: asking questions to try to trip up unprepared students. Kids don't forget who you embarrass even if its not them.
#utedchat
EdTecHakk
Jan 20 @ 11:55 PM EST
A7: Worst strategy - yelling at an entire class “What are you people... On dope?” see -
https://t.co/PkrdMrLrbe
#utedchat
profbutcher
Jan 20 @ 11:56 PM EST
A7. I like to have a process of thinking in mind as the purpose of my question, rather than a specific answer.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:57 PM EST
@michelle_zey
True for adults as well. Sometimes it better to let it go.
#utedchat
myles8383
Jan 20 @ 11:58 PM EST
A7: best str. to involve all ss is padlet. Also like having ss run our class meetings where they ask all the questions to peers.
#utedchat
covili
- Moderator
Jan 20 @ 11:59 PM EST
Thanks for joining us for
#utedchat
tonight. Next week
@DaniKSloan
leads the BYOD charge!
segolilylife
Jan 20 @ 11:59 PM EST
#utedchat
A7 Have Ss use the language of their self created rubric to answer Q's. Worst answer on a worksheet.
MaryTouchet
Jan 20 @ 11:59 PM EST
Please join me Tomorrow
#UTmathchat
Thurs 1/21 9-10pmMST Using Standards of Math Practice
https://t.co/GDmgx3IdYq
#mathSMP
#MTBoS
#utedchat