#scitlap Archive


Wednesday November 7, 2018
9:00 PM EST

  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:04 PM EST
    Hello Everyone. Anyone ready to talk about SEPs. Please introduce yourself and share what you love about seasons changing. #scitlap
  • daleyscience - Moderator Nov 7 @ 9:06 PM EST
    Hey #scitlap. I am literally just getting home from conferences. I will jump in after I say hi to my family!!
  • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:06 PM EST
    I am sooo happy to talk about SEPs! #scitlap
  • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:09 PM EST
    I am Tracey, a HS Bio teacher in Illinois. I love how the light changes when seasons change. Each season has its own light. #scitlap
  • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:09 PM EST
    Really not much to love about seasons changing. My allergies act up and I have chores to look forward to: shoveling, mowing, raking.. I do like the new food choices that become available tho! #scitlap
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:10 PM EST
    Q1 Science & Engineering practically are 1 ribbon of the NGSS. The first one is Asking Questions & Defining Problems. What are labs or activities practice this SEP?#scitlap
  • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:11 PM EST
    A1 If you have not tried the Question Formulation Technique you need to. Works great with phenomena as a prompt. @RightQuestion #scitlap
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:12 PM EST
    I am Karla from NAS Lemoore CA. I teach 7th grade NGSS Integrated and a Gaming elective. I love not having to use my AC and only ceiling fans. I can sit outside and read. #scitlap
  • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:14 PM EST
    Lol, in the north we hibernate inside till May. Unless you ski or something like that. #scitlap
    In reply to @karlacalbear
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:14 PM EST
    A1 I do lots of little engineering challenges, teach a unit on understanding science misinformation and sometimes have students do paper towel testing. Just figuring out how to do a controlled experiment bends their brains. #scitlap
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:16 PM EST
    Q2) I find developing and using models challenging. Ss are confused on what it means. What do you do for this SEP? #scitlap
  • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:17 PM EST
    Google around a bit on it. I attended a session at a conference. Simple yet effective. Ss write as many Qs as they can about a prompt, then rate as open or closed. Could also do testable/not testable for science. #scitlap
    In reply to @TraceyKast, @RightQuestion
  • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:19 PM EST
    A1: One thing I do is have my freshman manipulate growth of a garlic clove eleven we are investigating cell division. They are totally charge. It is a relatively simple experiment but some really struggle. A good experience for them. #scitlap
  • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:19 PM EST
    A2 Yep, student models, like their questioning, needs teaching. I do whiteboarding and chart paper (gallery walk). I comment on what is good and what can be improved. Like models need labels/captions. #scitlap
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:20 PM EST
    A2) I do use simulations that students can manipulate to show their learning in some units. I would like to spend more time creating & building in class but takes so much time. Ss really enjoy designing water filters then compare to a larger system. #scitlap
  • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:21 PM EST
    Pumpkin spice everything? #scitlap
    In reply to @pentaclethra
  • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:22 PM EST
    #scitlap
    • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:21 PM EST
      The power in modeling I feel comes from the prediction and then reflection. Showing Ss their conceptual understanding before and after can be powerful (so I've been told). #scitap
      In reply to @karlacalbear
  • daleyscience - Moderator Nov 7 @ 9:22 PM EST
    Okay, I said hi to the husband, kids, dog, and guinea pig. I'm ready to chat!! #scitlap
  • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:23 PM EST
    Jeez, we come after the guinea pig. Insulted. lol. #scitlap
    In reply to @daleyscience
  • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:23 PM EST
    Ok. I do this. I didn’t realize the technique had a name! Learn something new . . . #scitlap
    In reply to @pentaclethra, @RightQuestion
  • daleyscience - Moderator Nov 7 @ 9:24 PM EST
    Girl, I love your Bitmoji! How'd you get your dog in there? #scitlap
    In reply to @TraceyKast
  • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:26 PM EST
    A2: I use the word “model” constantly and at the beginning of the year we talk about what a model is/can be. I terry to incorporate as many different kinds of models into my units as I can. #scitlap
  • daleyscience - Moderator Nov 7 @ 9:27 PM EST
    Haha! I rushed to get here, to my #scitlap family. Plenty of love to go around!! P.S. My guinea pig is pretty darn cute! #scitlap
    In reply to @pentaclethra
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:28 PM EST
    Q3) next is engaging in arguments from evidence. AKA Claims, Evidence & Reasoning. Here is a portfolio entry from one @amplify unit. #scitlap
  • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:31 PM EST
    A3 Not sure if there was a question there but I'll just chat about CER. I like the word "justification" instead of reasoning. Students don't seem to get reasoning. They just restate their evidence. #scitlap
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:32 PM EST
    A3) my entire grade level team is using claim, evidence, reasoning. I find Ss get claim & evidence but reasoning is harder. My curriculum does a good job of spiraling this through a unit and creating a new problem at the end for ss to apply knowledge #scitlap
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:33 PM EST
    I did forget question. I like that! #scitlap
    In reply to @pentaclethra
  • daleyscience - Moderator Nov 7 @ 9:33 PM EST
    A3 I agree about reasoning, it is tough for students. I asked my team to use the same language and asked ELA teacher to help with reasoning. - #scitlap
  • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:33 PM EST
    A3: I try to have my students formally write arguments at least once a week but every day during class discussions. #scitlap
  • daleyscience - Moderator Nov 7 @ 9:35 PM EST
    I have really been focusing on CER over the past few years. I really like it, and you can apply it over and over again. I found a great lesson on "What is a sandwich"? I will see if I can find it! #scitlap
  • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:37 PM EST
    I agree that they struggle with reasoning. But I actually find with my students that they struggle more with providing and citing evidence. They just don’t understand (read “haven’t had practice”) reporting numbers/data in their writing. #scitlap
    In reply to @pentaclethra
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:37 PM EST
    Q4) I’m combining 2 SEPs here: Analyzing & Interpreting Data and Using Mathematical & Computational thinking. How do you practice these. Do you work with math partners? #scitlap
  • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:38 PM EST
    Agree, I often get "look at my graph" or "the data supports my claim". I teach 8th grade and have sentence starters to try and get them in the right direction. #scitlap
    In reply to @TraceyKast
  • daleyscience - Moderator Nov 7 @ 9:39 PM EST
    Tracey, what grade level did you say that you taught? Just curious. #scitlap
    In reply to @TraceyKast, @pentaclethra
  • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:40 PM EST
    A4 For me analysis is mostly reading and interpreting graphs. Students still struggle. If we can graph data and use it as evidence we are doing good. #scitlap
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:41 PM EST
    A4) Math is my first love. However, I’ve yet to bring in more data interpretation in my labs. Future Focus. I do spend time teaching Ss how to graph on iPads in different apps. I do have them crest graphs without iPads at least once. #scitlap
  • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:42 PM EST
    A4: At the HS level teaming up with math is difficult because Ss have different levels of math and different teachers. To meet this SEP I really just try to have students working with all kinds of data—data they collected and graphs and tables from other sources. #scitlap
  • daleyscience - Moderator Nov 7 @ 9:42 PM EST
    A4 I'm not sure if I officially use the Math and Computational Thinking SEP, but I know I've had some great science/math conversations with my math team-mate this year. #scitlap
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:43 PM EST
    Do any of you work with infographics to practice this SEP or even create infographics? #scitlap
  • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:44 PM EST
    Nope. Not me. #scitlap
    In reply to @karlacalbear
  • daleyscience - Moderator Nov 7 @ 9:45 PM EST
    I am spending a lot of time practicing graph skills this year. Students are pretty weak at interpreting them, as well as making them. Hope to grow this skill over the year! #scitlap
  • daleyscience - Moderator Nov 7 @ 9:46 PM EST
    Nope - but I do love me some infographics! #scitlap
    In reply to @karlacalbear
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:48 PM EST
    Q5) last 2 SEPS: planning & carrying out investigations and Constructing Explanations & Designing Solutions. Do you see as only as a hands-on lesson or do you do other lessons. #scitlap
  • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:49 PM EST
    Oops #scitlap
    • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:48 PM EST
      Me either, but also like infographics! My wheels are turning. I like this idea. I am trying to think what that would look like. Graphs and tables they make and research on a topic . . .
      In reply to @karlacalbear
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:49 PM EST
    Maybe we can all collaborate on a series of lessons to support this. #scitlap
    In reply to @daleyscience
  • daleyscience - Moderator Nov 7 @ 9:51 PM EST
    Collaboration is one of my favorite words! #scitlap
    In reply to @karlacalbear
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:52 PM EST
    Here are some infographics creator apps and tips https://t.co/48LWGKnrka I really want to try https://t.co/Bp9sam9tEE #scitlap
    • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:49 PM EST
      Oops #scitlap
      • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:48 PM EST
        Me either, but also like infographics! My wheels are turning. I like this idea. I am trying to think what that would look like. Graphs and tables they make and research on a topic . . .
        In reply to @karlacalbear
  • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:53 PM EST
    A5: I do usually think of these as hands on. At least that is how I mostly meet these SEPs in my classroom but I would think PBL and case studies would work for this as well. #scitlap
  • pentaclethra Nov 7 @ 9:54 PM EST
    A5 I eliminated my scientific method unit this year. Going to try including this SEP with other labs I already do. Still not sure how this will work out. #scitlap
  • daleyscience - Moderator Nov 7 @ 9:55 PM EST
    A5 I'm not really answering the question here, but we had conferences tonight and my room was check full of a big design project....so many parents were impressed at how non-textbook/notes we are focused. Hands-on with a reflection piece is the way to go #scitlap
  • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:57 PM EST
    I have tried Piktochart. Just dabbled when I was trying to figure infographics out. I found that my students like Canva. I give them a choice. #scitlap
    In reply to @karlacalbear
  • daleyscience - Moderator Nov 7 @ 9:58 PM EST
    @canva is my jam! #scitlap
    In reply to @TraceyKast, @karlacalbear, @canva
  • TraceyKast Nov 7 @ 9:59 PM EST
    I ditched that unit over five years ago. I would rather have students spend that time doing the science and learning about the process in situ. That is how I learned it best. #scitlap
    In reply to @pentaclethra
  • karlacalbear Nov 7 @ 9:59 PM EST
    Thanks for joining in. I am actually in the hospital keeping my elderly uncle company. Luckily I had this idea ready. Let’s all follow Tracy. Keep sharing lessons you find at our hashtags. #scitlap. Ps I’m tired of spell check changing this to Scotland. Lol!