#engsschat Archive | Participate

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:00 PM EDT

Remember, tonight we’ll be using the combined #engsschat. #engchat #sschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:00 PM EDT

Welcome to #engsschat "How to Tackle Tough Topics in the ELA/SS Classroom"! Please take a moment to introduce yourself, what you teach, etc.

participatechat Jul 31 @ 7:00 PM EDT

Participate in the upcoming #engsschat by sharing resources and collaborating at https://t.co/4u2c9PFI7m

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:01 PM EDT

We’ll be following the Q1/A1, A2, A3 format. Don’t forget to use the combined #engsschat! #sschat #engchat #edchat

MsHolmesTeach Jul 31 @ 7:01 PM EDT

Mary-Owen from TN. 7th world history. Will be in/out - prepping for 1st day of school in AM & finishing EdS final project! #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:01 PM EDT

Thanks for joining in tonight, Mary-Owen! Welcome to #engsschat

In reply to @MsHolmesTeach

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:02 PM EDT

Hi #engsschat, this is Bill Chapman, a retired secondary social studies teacher, checking in from Berkeley, CA.

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:02 PM EDT

Good luck with the busy evening and prepping for school starting up! Sounds like a busy night. #engsschat

In reply to @MsHolmesTeach

GeoJo22 Jul 31 @ 7:02 PM EDT

Joanne from Missouri. 7th grade world history and 11th grade modern global issues. #engsschat

HashTagKCMO Jul 31 @ 7:03 PM EDT

RT GeoJo22 : Joanne from Missouri. 7th grade world history and 11th grade modern global issues. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:03 PM EDT

Bill - Thanks for joining in tonight! #YouRock #engsschat

In reply to @classroomtools

theASIDEblog Jul 31 @ 7:03 PM EDT

Looks like tough topics will be w/ us for awhile. The news each day changes rapidly, i.e. the White House. #engsschat #sschat #engchat

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:03 PM EDT

Hey all! MS SS Teacher here from Lancaster, PA. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:03 PM EDT

Nice to see you tonight, Joanne! Thanks for joining us. #engsschat

In reply to @GeoJo22

BetsyyoBetsy Jul 31 @ 7:03 PM EDT

Hi, I'm Betsy. I teach high school English, mostly 9th and 11th grade. AP Language is my favorite. #engsschat #engchat #sschatt

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:04 PM EDT

Glad to have you with us tonight! Welcome to #engsschat

In reply to @mr_middle_2

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:04 PM EDT

So glad to have you with us Betsy! I also teach 11th grade English. Welcome to #engsschat.

In reply to @BetsyyoBetsy

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:05 PM EDT

Welcome Joanne, fellow SS T! #engsschat

In reply to @HashTagKCMO

Nicolemens Jul 31 @ 7:05 PM EDT

Nicole from midMO. I teach a combined AP Lang/APUSH course and AP Lit. #Engsschat

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:06 PM EDT

Louie tweeting from Sea Isle City tonight on vacation. May or may not be on the whole time! #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:06 PM EDT

With social media, the news, and all that's going on in the world - glad to talk about handling tough topics with you all. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:06 PM EDT

Welcome to tonight's chat, Nicole! #engsschat

In reply to @Nicolemens

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:06 PM EDT

Q1: Let’s dive in! When a controversial current event enters into the classroom, what strategies do you use to unpack it? #engsschat

johnsonmaryj Jul 31 @ 7:07 PM EDT

Hi to #engsschat tonight from Colorado! At last, I have replaced my 2009 computer, so I should be able to keep up.

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:07 PM EDT

That's commitment, Louie! Thanks for chiming in from Sea Isle City! #engsschat

In reply to @mr_middle_2

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:07 PM EDT

So glad to have you with us, Mary! Welcome to #engsschat

In reply to @johnsonmaryj

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:07 PM EDT

A1. I try my best to unpack the student's own thinking without sharing any personal opinions or bias. Easier said than done. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:06 PM EDT

Q1: Let’s dive in! When a controversial current event enters into the classroom, what strategies do you use to unpack it? #engsschat

SterneTeach Jul 31 @ 7:08 PM EDT

Anna from Atlanta here. I teach 8th grade English and collaborate on a humanities team with 8th grade civics teachers. #engsschat

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:08 PM EDT

a1 1st we looked for facts, then after attempting to verify them, we moved on to what they might mean, & explore controversies. #engsschat

pmccarthy722 Jul 31 @ 7:08 PM EDT

Hi. Paula from Kansas City area. 9th and 10th grade English. #engsschat

MsLehmanLSHS Jul 31 @ 7:09 PM EDT

I'm Diana and I teach 9th & 11th grade language arts in the Kansas City, MO area. #engsschat #sschat #engchat

GeoJo22 Jul 31 @ 7:09 PM EDT

A1 First step is to find out if they wish to talk about it. Then assess what they know and how they know it. #engsschat

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:09 PM EDT

So important to look for facts. How do you verify facts in context of class discussion? #engsschat

In reply to @classroomtools

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:09 PM EDT

Yes, I like to let Ss do most of the talking. It can be hard to be biased. Pulling up articles can help guide conversations. #engsschat

In reply to @mr_middle_2

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:09 PM EDT

Thanks for joining us tonight, Diana! #engsschat

In reply to @MsLehmanLSHS

massignmenthelp Jul 31 @ 7:10 PM EDT

Tips for Living with Roommate in College Life https://t.co/hcwv4xiJ7l #engchat #engsschat #plearnchat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:10 PM EDT

Glad to have you with us tonight, Paula! #engsschat

In reply to @pmccarthy722

AssignmentHelpN Jul 31 @ 7:10 PM EDT

A Writer’s Guide to Difference Between Editing and Proofreading https://t.co/wq0uN2NDPQ #engchat #engsschat #plearnchat

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:10 PM EDT

What evidence can we find to support the asserted facts? How good is that evidence? #engsschat

In reply to @mr_middle_2

MrSilva Jul 31 @ 7:10 PM EDT

Hi #engsschat I'm the Virtual Classroom Coordinator for @TheNewsLP and a former Social Studies teacher in Chicago Public Schools (13 yrs)

johnsonmaryj Jul 31 @ 7:10 PM EDT

A1 Whenever news breaks, we have an opportunity to teach media literacy by looking at multiple sources. #engsschat

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:10 PM EDT

Nothing is more controversial than race/ethnicity. Teaching Tolerance can help. https://t.co/xV3fvzrbCj #engsschat

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:10 PM EDT

Sarah from Texas! I used to teach 8 - 10 History! Now I help from outside the classroom! #edt5335 #engsschat

SterneTeach Jul 31 @ 7:10 PM EDT

A1: Listen. Create a safe environment for students to share their thoughts and opinions. #engsschat

theASIDEblog Jul 31 @ 7:10 PM EDT

Middle schoolers have lots of questions. They get news feeds on Snapchat; unpacking is necessary to get the facts right. #engsschat #sschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:10 PM EDT

Yes, with devices in hand, it is easier to encourage Ss to engage in inquiry and search for credible sources/facts! #engsschat

In reply to @classroomtools

HolyTXHistory Jul 31 @ 7:10 PM EDT

Good evening. I'm Carolyn from Houston,m. I teach 7th grade Texas History and SS dept chair #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:10 PM EDT

Thanks for joining us tonight, Anna! #engsschat

In reply to @SterneTeach

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:11 PM EDT

In a Catholic school, I usually try to look through the lens of "love of neighbor" and love of all. #engsschat

In reply to @kwillmann

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:11 PM EDT

Mary, such a great point about #MediaLiteracy. Ss need to understand how to critical analyze what they consume & what is credible #engsschat

In reply to @johnsonmaryj

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:11 PM EDT

I am Kate and I am a Literacy Specialist and ELD coordinator in LA, California. #engsschat #engchat #sschat #edchatie

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:12 PM EDT

Thanks for joining us tonight, John! Welcome to #engsschat

In reply to @MrSilva, @TheNewsLP

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:12 PM EDT

A1 What a great opportunity to teach students how to critically evaluate sources of information! #edt5335 #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:12 PM EDT

Glad to have you with us tonight, Sarah! #engsschat

In reply to @Deller924

theASIDEblog Jul 31 @ 7:12 PM EDT

Most important job for us is to make sure we unpack w/out our point of view. Kids need to see all sides. #engsschat #sschat

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:12 PM EDT

just wondering....do any schools/principals disallow discussing issues? #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:13 PM EDT

Yes! https://t.co/kIBaM2nIvR is a fantastic resources for encouraging Ss to think about this issue & many others. #engsschat

In reply to @kwillmann

jcaseydesign Jul 31 @ 7:13 PM EDT

Hi! Jennifer from FL. MS social studies and ELA. #engsschat

pmccarthy722 Jul 31 @ 7:13 PM EDT

@GeoJo22 Such a good point! HOW do they know it. #engsschat

GeoJo22 Jul 31 @ 7:09 PM EDT

A1 First step is to find out if they wish to talk about it. Then assess what they know and how they know it. #engsschat

theASIDEblog Jul 31 @ 7:13 PM EDT

We have a strong media literacy program, and our students are used to our prompts to bring out all sides. #engsschat #sschat

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:13 PM EDT

Hi Jennifer, welcome! #engsschat

In reply to @jcaseydesign

Nicolemens Jul 31 @ 7:13 PM EDT

Breaking news is an ongoing discussion of evolution of what we know to be fact and our understanding of it #engsschat

HolyTXHistory Jul 31 @ 7:13 PM EDT

A1 Ask for S opinions, reactions. They usually need help deciphering credible info about what they hear #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:14 PM EDT

Yes! I love using websites like https://t.co/zSZDghW3zl to help guide Ss to examine all sides of tough issues! #engsschat

In reply to @theASIDEblog

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:14 PM EDT

A1: We need to teach students to look at all sides of an argument...not just the one they agree with! #edt5335 #engsschat

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:14 PM EDT

Hopefully not! Need to create authentic lrning envir'ment. Ss are growing up in real world - not sheltered filtered pc world. #engsschat

In reply to @kwillmann

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:14 PM EDT

Q2 is coming up shortly! #engsschat

MrsMartinesd Jul 31 @ 7:14 PM EDT

At a conference speaker said that research says its good to say our personal POV, but tell kids its our OPINION #sschat #engsschat

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:14 PM EDT

I act as a moderator. The students drive the conversation (while staying respectful). #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:15 PM EDT

Yes, and when we can access news from our social media feeds, Ss and people are exposed to more issues than ever. #engsschat

In reply to @Nicolemens

theASIDEblog Jul 31 @ 7:15 PM EDT

If they do, they deny student voice and open dialog to hash out the information based on "real" facts. #engsschat #sschat

In reply to @kwillmann

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:15 PM EDT

honoring all kinds of view points - even those that make our blood boil is important. #engsschat

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:15 PM EDT

Facilitating respect is an important role! #engsschat

In reply to @lipsticknlit, @Steph_Sukow

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:15 PM EDT

Q2: How do you challenge Ss to look at all sides of an issue? Why should we encourage Ss to understanding different perspectives? #engsschat

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:15 PM EDT

Also, when students make a claim or share an opinion, I always ask them to support their opinion with facts or explain "why". #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

jcaseydesign Jul 31 @ 7:15 PM EDT

A1 Finding out what Ss actually know about the issues they've brought up without disregarding their strong emotions. #engsschat

SterneTeach Jul 31 @ 7:16 PM EDT

I find that middle school Ss often form opinions before learning the facts. So important to do the research. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:16 PM EDT

This is such an important role! Ss need to understand that different POVs can help us to see all sides of tough issues. #engsschat

In reply to @lipsticknlit

JulianaTDotson Jul 31 @ 7:16 PM EDT

Juliana from Texas. I teach ELA II; this is my first time joining. #engsschat #edt5335

theASIDEblog Jul 31 @ 7:16 PM EDT

This is what we do. We want students to develop questions, disagree, and look for factual evidence to support their claims. #engsschat

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:14 PM EDT

I act as a moderator. The students drive the conversation (while staying respectful). #engsschat
In reply to @Steph_Sukow

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:17 PM EDT

A2. SAC structured academic controversy is a terrific method. https://t.co/qoPt2zRDmm #engsschat

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:17 PM EDT

A2: Make them debate from both sides of the argument! In order to know what you believe you need to know all sides! #edt5335 #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:17 PM EDT

Yes! Teaching them to access and seek out credible sources to back what they hear can help. Inquiry helps so much! #engsschat #inquiry

In reply to @SterneTeach

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:17 PM EDT

A2. This is tough to look at all issues w/o bias. Understanding diff persp's helps to better formulate better arguments. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:15 PM EDT

Q2: How do you challenge Ss to look at all sides of an issue? Why should we encourage Ss to understanding different perspectives? #engsschat

johnsonmaryj Jul 31 @ 7:17 PM EDT

A1 Identifying points of view is a learned skill, improved with practice. Circle of Viewpoints routine https://t.co/1d9iqxGohy #engsschat

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:17 PM EDT

A2 Asking questions like -- What do we know? What do we think? What do we wonder about? helps #engsschat

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:17 PM EDT

A2 I liked to discuss "The Blind Men & the Elephant". #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:18 PM EDT

I like having Ss debate the opposite of what they really believe. It makes them walk in the shoes of others & seek research. #engsschat

In reply to @Deller924

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:18 PM EDT

This is where I ask students to share their "why" of their opinion. Look at evidence and facts to support their claim! #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

jcaseydesign Jul 31 @ 7:18 PM EDT

A2 Asking Qs is a start. A teacher doesn't need to have all the answers. Allowing space for discussion w/out choosing sides. #engsschat

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:18 PM EDT

There is no such thing as unbiased. See https://t.co/P6chijo5FA #engsschat

In reply to @mr_middle_2

JulianaTDotson Jul 31 @ 7:19 PM EDT

Very true. This teaches them to be objective, open minded and also comes across in their writing. #engsschat #edt5335

In reply to @Deller924

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:19 PM EDT

Yes, & the "why" encourages critical thinking & synthesis! We want our Ss to be able to analyze what they see/hear #engsschat #medialiteracy

In reply to @lipsticknlit

GeoJo22 Jul 31 @ 7:19 PM EDT

A2 It's important to expose Ss to all sides. Opinions evolve over time as new information informs. #engsschat

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:19 PM EDT

Sharing the evidence to support their opinion is what all assessments ask them to do, so why not practice it in conversation?! #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:20 PM EDT

I'm so encouraged by all of you right now! Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Q3 is coming up! #engsschat #MyPLNRocks

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:20 PM EDT

YES! They must think of what education knowledge they have that supports their thinking! #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

theASIDEblog Jul 31 @ 7:20 PM EDT

We've done a lot to talk about looking at the opposing POV, even one you "hate." Gotta know how to question/dispute an argument. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:20 PM EDT

Q3: With misinformation, inaccurate texts, and fake news, how do you teach Ss to determine credible and accuracy of information? #engsschat

HolyTXHistory Jul 31 @ 7:21 PM EDT

A2 Ask Ss to look at issues wo emotion and give their POV then the opposite w/o the emotion there is respect #engsschat

johnsonmaryj Jul 31 @ 7:21 PM EDT

A2 Teacher also doesn't have to ask all the questions. Check out the QFT protocol @RightQuestion. Excellent for current events. #engsschat

In reply to @jcaseydesign, @RightQuestion

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:21 PM EDT

A3. Tbh, I look forward to learning from you all regarding this! #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:20 PM EDT

Q3: With misinformation, inaccurate texts, and fake news, how do you teach Ss to determine credible and accuracy of information? #engsschat

42ThinkDeep Jul 31 @ 7:22 PM EDT

There are more than two sides to any single issue! #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:22 PM EDT

Absolutely! Definitely so important to remind Ss of a spectrum of perspectives. #engsschat

In reply to @42ThinkDeep

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:23 PM EDT

If students are doing it everyday, then it will be a natural practice when they come to a test question that asks for evidence! #engsschat

In reply to @kwillmann

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:23 PM EDT

A3: Showing Ss credible databases, Google Scholar, & reliable news outlets helps to expose them to going beyond the random search #engsschat

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:23 PM EDT

A3: Cross-reference what they are claiming and check the facts! Don't believe everything you read! Be a critical reader! #edt5335 #engsschat

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:24 PM EDT

This is where it is our job as teachers to point them in the direction of credible sources with extensive research to back it up. #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:24 PM EDT

Possibly, but is taking a flat earther seriously really looking at a valid side? #engsschat

In reply to @42ThinkDeep

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:24 PM EDT

Great point. Ss needs to be taught to engage in inquiry and need frequent practice. It's a process. #engsschat

In reply to @lipsticknlit, @kwillmann

SterneTeach Jul 31 @ 7:24 PM EDT

A3: We are planning an assignment this fall where we give Ss 4 sources, one of which is clearly biased. See if Ss can tell. 😳#engsschat

theASIDEblog Jul 31 @ 7:24 PM EDT

A3: Gotta check facts. We constantly reinforce looking at multiple sources to avoid the "echo chamber" of social media. #engsschat #sschat

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:24 PM EDT

With that, teachers MUST do their own research and learning so that we do not rely on misinformation. #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

pmccarthy722 Jul 31 @ 7:25 PM EDT

A3: I require students to use Library Databases as much as possible. They always want to just "Google" it. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:20 PM EDT

Q3: With misinformation, inaccurate texts, and fake news, how do you teach Ss to determine credible and accuracy of information? #engsschat

HolyTXHistory Jul 31 @ 7:25 PM EDT

A3 Difficult- find multiple sources to support info. Teach how to recognize bias. Teach how to recognize facts. #engsschat

johnsonmaryj Jul 31 @ 7:25 PM EDT

Especially those perspectives that might not come to mind first. Give students time to stretch beyond the usual suspects. #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow, @42ThinkDeep

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:25 PM EDT

What sort of bias, political, commercial, religious, etc? #engsschat

In reply to @SterneTeach

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:25 PM EDT

Who is to decide who is a "flat earther?" S or T? Need to present facts to let Ss decide. #engsschat

In reply to @classroomtools, @42ThinkDeep

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:25 PM EDT

Absolutely! Modeling is key. Even at the college level this summer, my Ss & I practiced research & reviewing credibility together #engsschat

In reply to @lipsticknlit

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:26 PM EDT

Totally, we cannot expect that our students come to us KNOWING how to support their claims. It must be explicit teaching. #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow, @kwillmann

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:26 PM EDT

Take a look at https://t.co/P6chijo5FA #engsschat

In reply to @SterneTeach

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:27 PM EDT

It seems to me that flat earthers define themselves. #engsschat

In reply to @mr_middle_2, @42ThinkDeep

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:27 PM EDT

Q3B: How does social media impact our Ss understanding of tough topics? How do we encourage Ss to reflect on what they read? #engsschat

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:28 PM EDT

Hm. This is relative. It seems that any side could delegitimize their argument or be seen as illegitimate. Again... bias. #engsschat

In reply to @classroomtools, @42ThinkDeep

MsLehmanLSHS Jul 31 @ 7:28 PM EDT

A1: After some ground rules, let the Ss begin with their thoughts. I try to be honest about my own feelings too. #engsschat #sschat #engchat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:06 PM EDT

Q1: Let’s dive in! When a controversial current event enters into the classroom, what strategies do you use to unpack it? #engsschat

JulianaTDotson Jul 31 @ 7:28 PM EDT

Especially since they are exposed to so much information on social media. #engsschat #edt5335

In reply to @Steph_Sukow, @lipsticknlit

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:28 PM EDT

I agree, telling a person s/he is wrong is not a good approach. Maybe we first need to explore the Q, what is truth? #engsschat

In reply to @kwillmann

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:28 PM EDT

HA! I could write an entire blog post on this. I mean, think about how it affects ADULTS! ....(continued in another tweet) #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:29 PM EDT

google search confirms out own bias https://t.co/MbUnhJa3QP #engsschat

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:29 PM EDT

A3B: I use socratic circles to get Ss to talk about what they read, then an independent reflective response afterwards #edt5335 #engsschat

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:29 PM EDT

Bottom line is that we CANNOT define "flat earthers" for our Ss. That is unfair and taking advantage of their naivety and youth. #engsschat

In reply to @classroomtools, @42ThinkDeep

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:29 PM EDT

While I love social media, it's so easy to read/accept misinformation. This is my concern for Ss - discerning credibility. #engsschat

In reply to @JulianaTDotson, @lipsticknlit

theASIDEblog Jul 31 @ 7:29 PM EDT

We use The NYTimes Upfront & Junior Scholastic magazines. They're perfect for teacher guided lessons in news literacy. #engsschat #sschat

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:30 PM EDT

I think it is important to teach students to look at WHO is sharing the information and what kind of credibility that source has.#engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

Waxler81 Jul 31 @ 7:30 PM EDT

I usually ask them to defend the opposing side and have them use CRAAP test to validate sources. #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:30 PM EDT

What is relative about a person saying, "I believe the Earth is flat." ? #engsschat

In reply to @mr_middle_2, @42ThinkDeep

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:30 PM EDT

A3B: I think social media gives our Ss a bias on tough topics...they see information based on who they already follow #edt5335 #engsschat

johnsonmaryj Jul 31 @ 7:31 PM EDT

A3 Generously shared by @hrheingold, categorized tools for "crap detection." https://t.co/YH9oYeoOtF #engsschat

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:31 PM EDT

My understanding is that "flat-earthers" represent another present day constituency. #engsschat

In reply to @classroomtools, @42ThinkDeep

theASIDEblog Jul 31 @ 7:31 PM EDT

There were some excellent lessons from @KQED on news literacy this past year. #engsschat

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:31 PM EDT

Me too! I think as adults AND students, we have to take things we see on social media (most of the time) with a grain of salt. #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow, @JulianaTDotson

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:31 PM EDT

This video is great for the on the CRAAP test. It's walks Ss through the process of understanding sources #engsschat https://t.co/jUJWE3mpWU

In reply to @Waxler81

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:32 PM EDT

Wow, this hour is going by so quickly! Q4 is coming up. Keep sharing your ideas. #engsschat

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:32 PM EDT

There are apparently an increasing number of people in the US today who assert the Earth is flat. What constituency are they? #engsschat

In reply to @mr_middle_2, @42ThinkDeep

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:32 PM EDT

Saving this! Thanks. :) #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow, @Waxler81

theASIDEblog Jul 31 @ 7:33 PM EDT

Our job is to constantly make current events part of the daily conversation. We want kids to think/question everything. #engsschat #sschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:33 PM EDT

Even unintentionally networks are biased because we tend to friend like-minded people. It's important to teach Ss to go beyond SM #engsschat

In reply to @Deller924

pmccarthy722 Jul 31 @ 7:33 PM EDT

@kwillmann This article is blowing my mind!! I will read more thoroughly later. #engsschat So sad if true. I need to check the source.😬

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:29 PM EDT

google search confirms out own bias https://t.co/MbUnhJa3QP #engsschat

johnsonmaryj Jul 31 @ 7:33 PM EDT

Librarians are your best ally in teaching source analysis, evidence, media literacy (including social media). #engsschat

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:33 PM EDT

A4 Huck Finn is terrific for tough conversations #engsschat #sschat

GeoJo22 Jul 31 @ 7:34 PM EDT

A3 I think you just have to ask Ss how they judge those things, start there.Pizzagate story is a good one to use as an example. #engsschat

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:34 PM EDT

My apologies. Thought you were using this as a metaphor for others. #engsschat

In reply to @classroomtools, @42ThinkDeep

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:34 PM EDT

Yes! Such a great point. Our networks can be biased even unintentionally. #engsschat

pmccarthy722 Jul 31 @ 7:33 PM EDT
@kwillmann This article is blowing my mind!! I will read more thoroughly later. #engsschat So sad if true. I need to check the source.😬
- kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:29 PM EDT
  
  google search confirms out own bias https://t.co/MbUnhJa3QP #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:34 PM EDT

Yes, To Kill a Mockingbird, too! #engsschat

In reply to @kwillmann

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:35 PM EDT

Q4: What texts or readings have you encountered that lead to tough talks? How do you build background knowledge and context? #engsschat

MsLehmanLSHS Jul 31 @ 7:36 PM EDT

A2: I'll often play devil's advocate & bring up another side. Then we'll talk about why that side might think that way. #engsschat

designmj_mark Jul 31 @ 7:36 PM EDT

A4: Oddly enough, Animal Farm became very timely this year. #engsschat

theASIDEblog Jul 31 @ 7:36 PM EDT

We firmly believe all schools should allow social media in class to deconstruct media. It's gotta be real or it's worthless. #engsschat

mr_middle_2 Jul 31 @ 7:37 PM EDT

A4. Oohhh. Would love to hear what types of MS SS relevant texts I can bring into the classroom. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:35 PM EDT

Q4: What texts or readings have you encountered that lead to tough talks? How do you build background knowledge and context? #engsschat

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:37 PM EDT

A4 What would Huck or Jim or ??? say about "Black Lives Matter?" Would their answers change during the novel? #sschat #engsschat

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:38 PM EDT

A4 I often wrote my own. https://t.co/JcsA3wMV6I #engsschat

MsLehmanLSHS Jul 31 @ 7:39 PM EDT

A3: Check mult. sources & cross-ref information. Move beyond Twitter/Snapchat feed. Watch whole speeches, not just the snippets. #engsschat

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:40 PM EDT

A4: The newspaper seems to be a good source of information these days...This gives us time to look for credible sources! #edt5335 #engsschat

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:41 PM EDT

A 4 this image works #sschat #engsschat

pmccarthy722 Jul 31 @ 7:41 PM EDT

A4: @KellyGToGo posts articles each week that are wonderful for debates, writing prompts, current topics .https://t.co/bN4jsjNdpo #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:41 PM EDT

There are some great titles listed in this middle school blogpost. Wonder is a favorite of mine! https://t.co/deVYdjmyHq #engsschat

In reply to @mr_middle_2

SterneTeach Jul 31 @ 7:41 PM EDT

A4: Great YA fiction dealing with current issues. Example: The Hate U Give #engsschat

readheaducate Jul 31 @ 7:42 PM EDT

#engsschat I love @ClintSmithIII poems for this, David Foster Wallace, Adichie (Single Story), Junior Diaz, arg texts, speeches, poems.

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:42 PM EDT

Young adult literature is going a great job taking on tougher issues. Love: Monster, I am Malala, Elenor and Park to name a few. #engsschat

GeoJo22 Jul 31 @ 7:43 PM EDT

A4 @flocabulary 's The Week in Rap raises the question on controversial CE. Then we dig for more background through links. #engsschat

BetsyyoBetsy Jul 31 @ 7:43 PM EDT

Q1. I try to give students time to process individually. Quiet quick writes prevent group think. #engsschat #engchat #sschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:43 PM EDT

Q5 is coming up soon! Keep sharing any titles of texts that have helped you in the classroom with tough issues. #engsschat

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:43 PM EDT

A4: Fahrenheit 451, Brave New World, 1984...Teach about the historical context in which they were written! #edt5335 #engsschat

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:44 PM EDT

a4 Greenhaven Press' Opposing Viewpoints series is a terrific resource. https://t.co/3KOciGuDQC #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:44 PM EDT

Q5: How do you guide tough conversations without showing bias? How do you ensure that Ss are seeing multiple sides/perspectives? #engsschat

JulianaTDotson Jul 31 @ 7:44 PM EDT

My kids love Socratic seminars as well. The best ones are the ones THEY ask for/initiate. #engsschat #edt5335

In reply to @Deller924

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:44 PM EDT

A5 making a human issue continuum works - especially if you articulate positions at various points #sschat #engsschat

readheaducate Jul 31 @ 7:45 PM EDT

#engsschat I always start with David Foster Wallace "This is Water" to really analyze perspective, scope and bias. That's the center text.

JulianaTDotson Jul 31 @ 7:45 PM EDT

I'm not familiar with this. #engsschat #edt5335

In reply to @readheaducate, @ClintSmithIII

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:46 PM EDT

Great point! Socratic seminars are powerful experiences that let Ss drive well-researched, meaningful discussions! #engsschat

In reply to @JulianaTDotson, @Deller924

readheaducate Jul 31 @ 7:46 PM EDT

#engsschat A5. I love circles in restorative justice, love chalk talks, and four corners debates, silent debates too. Seminars are great.

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:46 PM EDT

A5 admitting that one of my biases is for seeing multiple viewpoints helps, plus being able to support positions I don't endorse #engsschat

SterneTeach Jul 31 @ 7:47 PM EDT

A5: give Ss time to reflect (in writing hopefully) on their own thoughts before engaging in whole class discussion. #engsschat

lipsticknlit Jul 31 @ 7:47 PM EDT

When students share their opinion, ask if anyone agrees/disagrees, then have them share "why". NEVER give your own opinion. #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

GeoJo22 Jul 31 @ 7:47 PM EDT

A5 I use the dialog lessons from @Gen_Global_ to practice respectful discussion. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:48 PM EDT

A5 @MrFritz8 uses inquiry-based lessons to have Ss to research viewpoints opposite to their beliefs! Powerful experiences for Ss #engsschat

readheaducate Jul 31 @ 7:48 PM EDT

#engsschat A5 always finding ways we connect and empathize as well. Not just where we divide. Build that trust through finding bridges.

MsLehmanLSHS Jul 31 @ 7:48 PM EDT

A4: Not a class read, but recommended Native Son to a S this year - still relevant to minorities experiences in today's society. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:35 PM EDT

Q4: What texts or readings have you encountered that lead to tough talks? How do you build background knowledge and context? #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:48 PM EDT

A5: Mini debates and choosing sides for Ss asks them to consider POV and opposing viewpoints. #engsschat

HolyTXHistory Jul 31 @ 7:48 PM EDT

A5 Set ground rules. Take the minority opinion, ask Ss to describe a different POV, Ss must back up their POV #engsschat

BetsyyoBetsy Jul 31 @ 7:48 PM EDT

This is also a great habit to instill. Students sometimes need reminding of the lines that exist between fact and opinion.#engsschat

In reply to @lipsticknlit, @Steph_Sukow

readheaducate Jul 31 @ 7:49 PM EDT

#engsschat A5. Literature can help be that window, mirror, and sliding glass doors.

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:49 PM EDT

Q6: How do you use debate or argumentation in your classroom? How they allow you to facilitate tough topics? #engsschat

readheaducate Jul 31 @ 7:49 PM EDT

Amen to this. Reflection matters so much in the learning process. #engsschat

In reply to @SterneTeach

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:49 PM EDT

A5: Make sure students have an opportunity to voice their opinion and defend it, no matter what side they are on! #edt5335 #engsschat

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:50 PM EDT

A5: In order to see all sides they have to be able to argue from a side they disagree with! This is hard, but necessary! #edt5335 #engsschat

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:50 PM EDT

If I assert that evolution (or global climate change) is a fact, is that a fact or my opinion? #engsschat

In reply to @BetsyyoBetsy, @lipsticknlit, @Steph_Sukow

readheaducate Jul 31 @ 7:50 PM EDT

Sorry guys. That grammar was atrocious. Typing on my phone and doing a lot at once. #engsschat

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:51 PM EDT

A6: Structured at first! Then hopefully progressing to more of an informed discussion over issues they disagree about! #edt5335 #engsschat

JulianaTDotson Jul 31 @ 7:51 PM EDT

Q4: Enrique's Journey, The Other Wes Moore, Between the World & Me and A Long Way Gone are all titles we've added. #engsschat #edt5335

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:51 PM EDT

A6 role played simulations of issues helps. Here is one on building a reservoir. https://t.co/q7yGG77ZKh #sschat #engsschat

readheaducate Jul 31 @ 7:51 PM EDT

#engsschat Q6 I use a TON of Critical Friends Protocols. The constraints of the protocols help Foster that discussion so students feel safe.

HolyTXHistory Jul 31 @ 7:52 PM EDT

Justification is important. I don't want repetition of what is said at home if Ss can't explain their POV #engsschat

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:52 PM EDT

A6: Students have to be able to give and GET critical feedback! I love the Critical Friends Protocol for starting out! #edt5335 #engsschat

JulianaTDotson Jul 31 @ 7:53 PM EDT

As well as Cry the Beloved Country... still relevant. #engsschat #edt5335

In reply to @MsLehmanLSHS

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:53 PM EDT

A6: Challenging Ss to watch the same news story from different networks helps to show that biases exist everywhere. #engsschat

readheaducate Jul 31 @ 7:54 PM EDT

#engsschat Q6. I love ALWAYS having that reflection period afterwards. Usually a quick write that they can choose to share.

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:55 PM EDT

Such a great and important part of a lesson! Reflection allows Ss to share a gained sense of understanding of a topic. #engsschat

In reply to @readheaducate

MsLehmanLSHS Jul 31 @ 7:55 PM EDT

A1: As in all good debate, Ss must be able to defend their positions. They can't just spew opinions. Helps others understand. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:49 PM EDT

Q6: How do you use debate or argumentation in your classroom? How they allow you to facilitate tough topics? #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:55 PM EDT

Wow, the hour is almost over. I'm going to skip to the last question of the night! #engsschat

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:55 PM EDT

Students LOVE reflections! A great learning tool too! #engsschat

In reply to @readheaducate

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:55 PM EDT

Q8: What advice do you have for a newer T when the tough topics arise? What can Ts do to help Ss make meaning of these topics? #engsschat

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:56 PM EDT

A6 political cartoons are great for that. They you ask student to draw a cartoon with the opposite viewpoint. #sschat #engsschat

readheaducate Jul 31 @ 7:56 PM EDT

It also helps me to see patterns! Was there anything that stuck out most to them or that they're still lingering on #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

jcaseydesign Jul 31 @ 7:56 PM EDT

A4 Stories that use darkness as a literary device can sometimes be problematic depending on the context. #engsschat

JulianaTDotson Jul 31 @ 7:56 PM EDT

#engsschat

MsLehmanLSHS Jul 31 @ 7:56 PM EDT

A6: As in all good debate, Ss must be able to defend their positions. They can't just spew opinions. Helps others understand. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:49 PM EDT

Q6: How do you use debate or argumentation in your classroom? How they allow you to facilitate tough topics? #engsschat

jcaseydesign Jul 31 @ 7:57 PM EDT

A6 Online discussions can help ensure everyone's voice is heard and not just the loudest voices. #engsschat

designmj_mark Jul 31 @ 7:57 PM EDT

A8: Let the kids be honest about how they feel, but understand that sharing an opinion is not the same as destroying someone else.#engsschat

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:57 PM EDT

A8 Advice. it is your job to create citizens who can talk about topics with each other.It is what makes our system work! #sschat #engsschat

readheaducate Jul 31 @ 7:58 PM EDT

A8. Having very real discussions about conflict resolution and how people resolve conflict differenly, and what works for peers #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:58 PM EDT

I agree. Both are facts. To see my reasoning about evolution, look at https://t.co/1NYQs8OF9L #engsschat

In reply to @pmccarthy722, @BetsyyoBetsy, @lipsticknlit, @Steph_Sukow

MsLehmanLSHS Jul 31 @ 7:58 PM EDT

A8: Don't be afraid to let Ss talk about tough topics. Lay ground rules and def moderate. Model honest and respectful behavior. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:55 PM EDT

Q8: What advice do you have for a newer T when the tough topics arise? What can Ts do to help Ss make meaning of these topics? #engsschat

jcaseydesign Jul 31 @ 7:58 PM EDT

A8 Advice? I'm still learning. We are all still learning. Maybe that's the advice. #engsschat

JulianaTDotson Jul 31 @ 7:58 PM EDT

A8: Talk to them honestly and maturely. Recognize that they have opinions and questions that deserve to be heard. #engsschat #edt5335

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:58 PM EDT

A8: Know your students! Help them realize meaning and whats going on in the world around them by tying it back to them! #edt5335 #engsschat

GeoJo22 Jul 31 @ 7:58 PM EDT

A6 That's hard with 7th graders. A debate determines winners and losers. Not sure I want that kind of outcome w/controversy. #engsschat

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 7:59 PM EDT

Wow, that hour flew by! Thanks so much for a great chat. #MyPLNRocks #engsschat #sschat #engchat

readheaducate Jul 31 @ 7:59 PM EDT

Flexibility and growth, right?! #engsschat

In reply to @jcaseydesign

Deller924 Jul 31 @ 7:59 PM EDT

A8: Respect! It goes both ways! #edt5335 #engsschat

kwillmann Jul 31 @ 7:59 PM EDT

A8 - always ask students to share the best point made by someone who disagrees with you. #sschat #engsschat

classroomtools Jul 31 @ 7:59 PM EDT

Thanks for the great questions, Steph! And thanks also to all you tweeted responses to them. #engsschat

In reply to @Steph_Sukow

Steph_Sukow - Moderator Jul 31 @ 8:00 PM EDT

Thanks for joining us tonight! Join us next month with @DrPleau1 to discuss literacy in the classroom. (08-28 at 6PM CST) #engsschat #sschat