#ISEDchat Archive
Independent School EdChat.
Thursday October 13, 2016
9:00 PM EDT
MrsMurat
Oct 13 @ 9:00 PM EDT
https://t.co/vrXgja8KBD
#aphgchat
#atplc
#byotchat
#christianeducators
#edtherapy
#ibookschat
#INeLearn
#inquirychat
#isedchat
#paedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:00 PM EDT
Welcome to
#ISEDchat
. I’m guest moderator Peter Gow, executive director of the Independent Curriculum Group
@indycurriculum
in Boston-ish
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:00 PM EDT
Tonight’s
#ISEDchat
topic: Does accreditation drive school improvement & innovation?
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:01 PM EDT
It’s visiting committee season. Tonight’s
#ISEDchat
will explore our experiences & expectations re 10-yr re-accreditation process.
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:01 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
uses a Q1/A1 format
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:01 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
Q1: Please introduce yourself and tell us where you’re from and what you do.
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:03 PM EDT
Enjoyed
https://t.co/2Qay4FuwY6
, as well as
@MLTSfilm
#indyschools
&
@cwra_beat
schools
@BCDSchool
@ALAcademy
@RiverdaleCS
#ISEDchat
props
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:03 PM EDT
Rob from St. John's Episcopal School in Dallas
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:04 PM EDT
Hi,
@pgow
and
#isedchat
folk. Been a while. Mark Crotty, head of St. John's Episcopal in Dallas. Strong opinions on this topic.
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:04 PM EDT
Hi, Rob, Lee, and Mark Welcome to
#ISEDchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:04 PM EDT
A1 Basil from Ridgefield Academy in Ridgefield, CT. Hi, everyone.
#ISEDchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:04 PM EDT
@crottymark
Can hardly wait to hear more on
#ISEDchat
tonight
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:05 PM EDT
Greetings. Lee from
https://t.co/Np1W4KbAJW
&
@cwra_beat
in Philly tonight - performance assessment 4 learning.
#ISEDchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:05 PM EDT
@bkolani
Hi Basil--welcome to
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:05 PM EDT
@pgow
Hope to deliver. Tweeting while in recovery from achilles surgery, so may no tmake it through.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:05 PM EDT
So:
#ISEDchat
Q2: What has been your experience/role in school accreditation? Visited? Self-study leader? Innocent bystander?
patrickfhansen
Oct 13 @ 9:06 PM EDT
Patrick Hansen, STEM teacher and director of after school programs at Rosarian Academy in West Palm Beach.
#ISEDchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:07 PM EDT
@patrickfhansen
Hi and welcome to
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:07 PM EDT
A2 All of above and on
@ISASouthwest
standards committee. Will lead a team in April.
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:07 PM EDT
A2: I’ve been a part of 2 visiting committees and been visited once. Have also done several curriculum-focused visits for the IB.
#ISEDchat
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:07 PM EDT
A2: took part as faculty member at previous school. Seemed like tons of paperwork!
#isedchat
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:07 PM EDT
@crottymark
@pgow
Topics you don't have strong opinions? Was thinking abt you re creativity. Will dig out article at some point.
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:08 PM EDT
@leefink
@pgow
Maybe some stronger than others?
#isedchat
gen_learn
Oct 13 @ 9:08 PM EDT
A2 Served on three visiting teams and worked on self-studies and two different schools
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:09 PM EDT
@crottymark
Done all those things myself, though not a team leader
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:09 PM EDT
@skeeTX
It is...but not all of it bad.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:10 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
Q3: What is your understanding of the purpose of the 10-year school accreditation cycle and the evaluation process?
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:10 PM EDT
@pgow
Have found every role a great learning experience.
#isedchat
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:10 PM EDT
@crottymark
@pgow
best for a speedy recovery
#ISEDchat
Heel better. sorry couldn't resist.
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:11 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
A3: I like to think it's about "improving the breed"--fostering better programs & policies. But sometimes maybe too light a touch
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:12 PM EDT
A3: generally, I would think accreditation holds schools accountable. Are they moving in right direction.
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:12 PM EDT
A3 Twofold: Making sure basic standards are met, but more about helping schools become better versions of themselves.
#isedchat
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:13 PM EDT
A2 Tangential, only through eyes of
@SAISnews
schools in various phases of process. Can be extraordinary & inclusive process.
#ISEDchat
lcarroll94
- Moderator
Oct 13 @ 9:14 PM EDT
@pgow
I have been on a visiting committee and chaired my school's accreditation.
#ISEDchat
gen_learn
Oct 13 @ 9:14 PM EDT
A3: to provide external validation to stakeholders that a school's practices align with its stated mission
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:14 PM EDT
A3: I think a part of it is to evaluate how well the school is doing what it says/thinks it does. Also a chance to address issues.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:14 PM EDT
@lcarroll94
Hi, Lorri!
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:14 PM EDT
@leefink
Can be fantastic if school embraces with right spirit.
#isedchat
massignmenthelp
Oct 13 @ 9:15 PM EDT
5 tips to save money on college books
https://t.co/6r7cUVijrt
#EduAfterHours
#sstlap
#isedchat
#TBookC
#SciStuChat
#atplc
#ICEilchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:15 PM EDT
@crottymark
@leefink
We're gonna be exploring that "right spirit" in a few on
#ISEDchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:16 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
Q4: In general, do you feel that accreditation process is effective in improving schools or driving innovation? Why or why not?
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:16 PM EDT
@pgow
@leefink
Figured you were leading us there!
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:17 PM EDT
A4: Doesn’t “effective in improving schools or driving innovation” assume that those are reasons for accred? Are they necessarily?
#isedchat
gen_learn
Oct 13 @ 9:17 PM EDT
Q4 completely depends on leadership on both sides of the process. Can be great or a series of hoops to jump through
#isedchat
patrickfhansen
Oct 13 @ 9:18 PM EDT
@gen_learn
Well put! Mission and vision
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:18 PM EDT
A4: But I’ve seen that they can help solidify improvements but also be a place for schools to overstate what they are doing.
#isedchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:18 PM EDT
@pgow
#ISEDchat
yes, it allows reflection but only when the organization actually wants progress or forward motion.
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:18 PM EDT
@bkolani
Great point! I am not sure that it IS always the intent. It's that "right spirit"--engaging to improve
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:18 PM EDT
Sorry, meant A4. In general yes...but could be much better.
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:19 PM EDT
@bkolani
Only certain standards. Otherwise plenty of room for variation.
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:19 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
@pgow
what purpose is accreditation for a school that doesn’t want forward motion?
#isedchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:20 PM EDT
@skeeTX
how do we define direction?
#ISEDchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:20 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
A4: I worry that system as it it allows schls to kind of crystallize & celebrate their own status quo if that is inclination
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:20 PM EDT
@pgow
study leader!
#ISEDchat
gen_learn
Oct 13 @ 9:21 PM EDT
I like it when a protocol provides rank and file teachers opportunity to give direct feedback to a team in small groups.
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:21 PM EDT
@bkolani
@jgregorymartin
@pgow
A seal of approval (even if most don't really understand).
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:21 PM EDT
@bkolani
@jgregorymartin
Pat on the head and a modicum of market validation only
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:22 PM EDT
@pgow
Big part of why we need new models.
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:22 PM EDT
@pgow
totally agree! lots of paperwork, but no push to improve. thankfully i don’t think that's most schools, but it’s possible.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:22 PM EDT
A "right spirit" Q
#ISEDchat
Q5: Have you/yr school found the self-study process illuminating, helpful, inspiring? How? If not, how so?
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:22 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
I'd say fulfilling our mission to prepare whole child to be lifelong learners and kind/empathetic people
#isedchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:22 PM EDT
@pgow
@bkolani
it must tie to the mission. Does the selfstudy allow the mission 2 come through? If not, is it time 2 address miss
#isedchat
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:23 PM EDT
A4 Not when check-box approach used w/
@cla_beat
or
@cwra_beat
as a tool for process, esp in
#highered
#ISEDchat
https://t.co/wbv5sYrkgP
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:23 PM EDT
@pgow
@jgregorymartin
i suppose the question to ask is how many schools you’ve seen NOT get re/accredited.
#isedchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:23 PM EDT
@bkolani
@pgow
for some it is a credential
#ISEDchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:24 PM EDT
@bkolani
@jgregorymartin
Tis rare to not be reaccredited in the absence of some pretty big, obvious problem
#ISEDchat
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:24 PM EDT
A4 Conversely, have seen tremendous innovation and ahas as well. Helps schools look where maybe they don't want to look.
#ISEDchat
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:24 PM EDT
A5: self study should affirm our why OR assist in realization that mission is not being reached
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:24 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
@pgow
sure, and that’s a legitimate reason. but does the process “direct” improvement?
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:25 PM EDT
@skeeTX
Have you experienced the latter at all?
#ISEDchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:25 PM EDT
@bkolani
@pgow
not many. Maybe just a pointing out of an area "to improve"
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:25 PM EDT
A5 I think so, mainly because we made it inclusive, many voices heard. Honest in our reflecting, and we took recs seriously.
#isedchat
gen_learn
Oct 13 @ 9:25 PM EDT
should be noted there is a VAST difference in the process between public and independent schools.
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:25 PM EDT
@gen_learn
@pgow
@jgregorymartin
sure. but that’s not the same thing. and hopefully that’s a sign that most are doing well by Ss.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:26 PM EDT
@gen_learn
Good point, that
#ISEDchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:26 PM EDT
@leefink
unless you have a case of the "emp new clothes"
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:27 PM EDT
a5 We did ours soon after I became head, so was able to use it as valuable tool in learning about school and advancing my vision.
#isedchat
patrickfhansen
Oct 13 @ 9:27 PM EDT
@bkolani
@jgregorymartin
@pgow
I would agree that there's little value in the process itself if the schools lacks a growth mindset
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:27 PM EDT
@gen_learn
even better are systems that would never identify anyone as a “rank and file teacher”.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:27 PM EDT
@crottymark
How does a school find/create that spirit, that desire to make the best use of the process to drive improvement?
#ISEDchat
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:27 PM EDT
@pgow
No, but we discussed our Why as a school last year and it's an important Q to always keep in mind!
#isedchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:27 PM EDT
@bkolani
@pgow
when guided and viewed as a tool for improvement.
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:27 PM EDT
A5 It also set tone for how I wanted us operating as community.
#isedchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:28 PM EDT
@crottymark
we are along those lines and frankly it is going well!
#ISEDchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:28 PM EDT
@crottymark
the timing of that visit must have been a great “welcome present” of sorts.
#isedchat
patrickfhansen
Oct 13 @ 9:29 PM EDT
@bkolani
@gen_learn
@pgow
@jgregorymartin
Similar to pd plans for Ts - only going to truly improve teaching with the right mindset
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:29 PM EDT
@pgow
Like anything else, endless work of creating the right culture. Set expectations; celebrate publically; chastise privately.
#isedchat
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:30 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
true, very diverse politics at work, as an outsider. stakeholders for status quo, capital plans, admissions,Ts
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:30 PM EDT
@bkolani
I loved it. Great opportunity, as indicated in other tweets.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:31 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
Q6: If you’ve been on a visiting committee, did you feel as though your work was helping the school?
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:31 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
It can set you up for several good years when done right and aligned with other priorities.
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:32 PM EDT
A6 Has varied. BEst was wehn school used a different model and we were brought in as experts in certain areas.
#isedchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:32 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
https://t.co/1QhAu1VEFg
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:32 PM EDT
@crottymark
part of me feels a self-study should be mandatory in year 2 of a new headship.
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:32 PM EDT
A6: Definitely. It was all in service to the school, though at times the visit felt checkist-y. “Are they doing this? Yes.”
#isedchat
ksivick
Oct 13 @ 9:32 PM EDT
#isedchat
hello all, schools do get placed on provisional accreditation and it is a call to action but you wouldn't hear about it
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:32 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
A6: Only once when a school was teetering & we on cte felt we made a real difference w/ perspective. A little bit other times.
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:33 PM EDT
@pgow
yes, but only if the school valued the visit as a positive event.
#ISEDchat
lcarroll94
- Moderator
Oct 13 @ 9:33 PM EDT
@pgow
Q6. I feel that a lot of it was validating what they wrote in their self study. In that way, yes.
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:33 PM EDT
A6 Another time not so much because I felt school was saying "right" things but didn't really believe them.
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:33 PM EDT
A6: I definitely think a committee I was on shed light on an improvement to be made. Felt like we did our job.
#isedchat
ksivick
Oct 13 @ 9:33 PM EDT
#ISedchat
at the very least accreditation demands self reflection, that's always a good thing
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:34 PM EDT
@ksivick
Hi, Kim--good point abt "You wouldn't hear abt it." Seems like those schls might be great case studies
#ISEDchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:34 PM EDT
@crottymark
that is our hope/plan here!
#ISEDchat
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:34 PM EDT
I wish my kids could have attended your school!
#ISEDchat
public school parent here, character/integrity/respect pr…
https://t.co/ATloq3o1Fc
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:22 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
I'd say fulfilling our mission to prepare whole child to be lifelong learners and kind/empathetic people
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:34 PM EDT
@crottymark
is that a problem with the process if that’s allowed to happen per the rules?
#isedchat
lcarroll94
- Moderator
Oct 13 @ 9:34 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
My self study was before GAFE was mainstream. Organization, communication, and documentation was so important.
#ISEDchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:35 PM EDT
@lcarroll94
@jgregorymartin
GAFE has sure changed the process
#ISEDchat
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:35 PM EDT
@bkolani
@pgow
@jgregorymartin
Great question/point.
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:36 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
Interesting. Of course, in way de facto one occurring. Depending on situation, could be onerous and distracting.
#isedchat
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:36 PM EDT
@leefink
To me, content is secondary. We need to produce good kids full of respect and confidence. Academics will work out too.
#ISEDchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:36 PM EDT
@crottymark
isn't that the key? Saying what you do and doing what you say
#ISEDchat
ConsultJodi
Oct 13 @ 9:36 PM EDT
@leefink
It depends on what is modeled in the school.
#ISEDchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:36 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
@crottymark
It's the key to "passing," but is it enough?
#ISEDchat
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:37 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
@crottymark
Ps should demand that for their kids!
#ISEDchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:37 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
Q7: Have you experienced or heard of “accreditation fail”—an unhelpful process or a dud of a visiting committee? What happened?
gen_learn
Oct 13 @ 9:37 PM EDT
#isedchat
Q6 the q assumes that they want to. I think there are lots of independent schools whose mission is grounded in tradnl methods.
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:38 PM EDT
@bkolani
Sure. But it's more a feel than anything. Hard to really deal with intent.
#isedchat
lcarroll94
- Moderator
Oct 13 @ 9:38 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
@crottymark
I felt like our school grew during the self study process... the visit/report, not as much.
#ISEDchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:38 PM EDT
@pgow
@crottymark
my feeling is the value is in what happens after the visit.
#ISEDchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:38 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
@crottymark
Amen to that--the response is key
#ISEDchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:39 PM EDT
@pgow
what’s the alternative? a self study that asks for specific plans to innovate/change/improve?
#isedchat
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:39 PM EDT
@ConsultJodi
Its all about the grades & scores - affluent public, pressure cooker for kids. point of pride is bond rating
#ISEDchat
ksivick
Oct 13 @ 9:39 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
A7 If it's a strong organization, they step in and support or replace the committee, selecting a good visiting team is crucial
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:39 PM EDT
@pgow
yes, when one vcom member had no idea how a boarding school worked
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:39 PM EDT
@bkolani
@pgow
@jgregorymartin
Think about how drastic doing that is. Not an easy deal on either end.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:40 PM EDT
@bkolani
In theory it kind of does, but it's not weighted to really inspire innovation/change
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:40 PM EDT
@pgow
@jgregorymartin
Yes!!!!
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:40 PM EDT
@crottymark
@pgow
@jgregorymartin
absolutely. even with room to improve, it would be a heck of a rec and/or something to deal with
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:41 PM EDT
@bkolani
@pgow
Yes, which is the model I advocate. Right now it's too cookie-cutterish. Could be much more school specific.
#isedchat
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:41 PM EDT
@leefink
For many it's a/b the grades but that's detrimental to whole child. Life is more than grades.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:41 PM EDT
@ksivick
#ISEDchat
A7: Once had a cte completely not "get" what schl doing--passed, but cte was just going through motions--not helpful
ksivick
Oct 13 @ 9:41 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
A7 also if a school has a history or a potential issue, the team is selected to evaluate and make appropriate suggestions to help
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:42 PM EDT
@crottymark
@pgow
it’s sort of like a school grappling with traditional assessments vs. portfolio. current models are the former.
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:42 PM EDT
@pgow
@jgregorymartin
In most agencies follow-u[ reports are major part of the process.
#isedchat
gen_learn
Oct 13 @ 9:42 PM EDT
A7 - Have not experienced it, but pretty sure it happens. I think a lot hinges on the quality of the v-team chair.
#isedchat
Mr_DeLucia_XC
Oct 13 @ 9:42 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
A6: the visit can help prioritize known issues, and maybe ID a gap that was unrecognized. Experienced team head helps.
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:42 PM EDT
@crottymark
@pgow
would love an accred process that essentially says, “Show us what you’ve done in ten years.
#isedchat
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:42 PM EDT
Any conflicts ever arise between committee and school???
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:43 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
Q8: What would you add or change to make the current accreditation process a more effective driver of improvement & innovation?
ConsultJodi
Oct 13 @ 9:43 PM EDT
@leefink
Yes. That's public school until high school.
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:43 PM EDT
Easy to forget the process is ongoing. It's not just a once-every-ten-year deal.
#isedchat
kevinjruth
Oct 13 @ 9:43 PM EDT
#isedchat
Hi there, just coming in now, late to this chat. Interesting topic.
ksivick
Oct 13 @ 9:43 PM EDT
@pgow
#ISEDchat
A7 a solid accreditation director makes sure the process is a growth experience, it is a specialized and difficult job
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:43 PM EDT
@bkolani
@pgow
Great analogy! And it should be formative rather than summative.
#isedchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:43 PM EDT
@bkolani
@crottymark
@pgow
for some schools that would be horrific. Others it would be a showcase. Neat idea though!
#ISEDchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:44 PM EDT
@gen_learn
can’t be overstated how important the visiting committee chair role is. i’ve had the priv of working w two great chairs
#isedchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:44 PM EDT
@skeeTX
yes. Grudges and misinformation.
#ISEDchat
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:44 PM EDT
A8: simplify process to more efficient. And prevent schools from doing what we've always done mindsets
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:44 PM EDT
@crottymark
@pgow
absolutely. the work is never done.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:44 PM EDT
Q8 is the grand finale of
#ISEDchat
tonight. Would love to make a list of great recommendations.
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:45 PM EDT
@bkolani
@pgow
Good ones already do that. In fact, some assoc such as
@ISASouthwest
ask for annual progress report.
#isedchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:45 PM EDT
@pgow
a full year review but the accreditation body. Multiple visits. More dialog. Not very practical though.
#ISEDchat
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:45 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
I could see personalities clashing if schools feel vulnerable in front of committee
#isedchat
lcarroll94
- Moderator
Oct 13 @ 9:46 PM EDT
A8.
@pgow
rec 1. Self study- choose sub committee chairs who are organized and communicate well.
#ISEDchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:46 PM EDT
A8: Ensure that all faculty and staff are a part of accreditation visit in some way. Everyone has to play some part.
#isedchat
jgregorymartin
Oct 13 @ 9:46 PM EDT
@skeeTX
always a risk. Can it be buffered?
#ISEDchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:46 PM EDT
@lcarroll94
@pgow
if that doesn’t happen, doesn’t it say something about the school? could be a good indicator.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:46 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
A8: I'd like a std that asks schools to be collaborative with one another in substantive ways--the
@indycurriculum
in me talking
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:46 PM EDT
a8. Variety of models. Teams chosen per school's stated desires/needs.
#isedchat
gen_learn
Oct 13 @ 9:46 PM EDT
@bkolani
Wonder if the talent pool is small and some heads suffer from burn-out because they are the ones getting tapped.
#ISEDchat
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:47 PM EDT
@bkolani
And hold Ts accountable before, during, and after process!
#isedchat
kevinjruth
Oct 13 @ 9:47 PM EDT
#isedchat
Do take a look (video) at a fresh approach to accreditation at
https://t.co/5vaH4WbjIb
ConsultJodi
Oct 13 @ 9:47 PM EDT
@lcarroll94
@pgow
I would say find someone outside the school body (broad community) to give your school feedback.
#isedchat
lcarroll94
- Moderator
Oct 13 @ 9:47 PM EDT
A8. rec 2. set a reasonable timeframe for self study sub committee report revisions. Build in as much time in school as possible.
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:48 PM EDT
a8 Make it less about meeting a check list of standards and more about teaching and learning.
#isedchat
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:48 PM EDT
@jgregorymartin
maybe not, but if leadership keeps big picture in mind and aims for growth, may lessen the feeling
#isedchat
gen_learn
Oct 13 @ 9:48 PM EDT
A8 - eliminate as much boilerplate protocol as you can. focus on real goals to meaningful issues / challenges
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:48 PM EDT
@gen_learn
But the pool isn’t that small as long as all member schools are involved. Aren’t more accreds than viable team members.
#isedchat
ConsultJodi
Oct 13 @ 9:49 PM EDT
@gen_learn
@bkolani
There is a huge lack of knowledge about indy schools among public. The former head of NAIS came from charters
#ISEDchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:49 PM EDT
@gen_learn
You mean focus less on the fireproof file cabinets? :-)
#ISEDchat
lcarroll94
- Moderator
Oct 13 @ 9:49 PM EDT
@gen_learn
A8. Yes. Need time for those great, in depth discussions. If under time crunch, the boilerplate takes over.
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:49 PM EDT
A8 Yes, other stuff like business, safety, etc all matters, but often it becomes the emphasis.
#isedchat
lcarroll94
- Moderator
Oct 13 @ 9:50 PM EDT
@pgow
@gen_learn
Yes... and the size of toilets in Early Childhood... !
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:50 PM EDT
@ConsultJodi
@gen_learn
sure, but i’d bet there’s just as much of a knowledge gap of pub school process by indies. is that a prob?
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:50 PM EDT
@lcarroll94
@gen_learn
Agree, but I think the models help foster that.
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:51 PM EDT
@gen_learn
oh, i agree, but that’s also why every school should have candidates for accreditations. that’s not the case.
#isedchat
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:51 PM EDT
@gen_learn
We call it diamonds in diamonds out. So long as Ss get 2 highly selective colleges, not much impetus to change/grow
#ISEDchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:52 PM EDT
@leefink
@gen_learn
Too true! As long as kids don't regress school thinks it's great!
#ISEDchat
ConsultJodi
Oct 13 @ 9:52 PM EDT
@bkolani
@gen_learn
Maybe. Public schools have plenty of applicants.
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:52 PM EDT
@lcarroll94
@pgow
@gen_learn
the thing is, stuff like this (and fireproof cabs) are important. just not "critical-important".
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:52 PM EDT
One thing visiting teams have to remember, too, is that it's about school's dreams, not team's sense of what they should do.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:53 PM EDT
#ISEDchat
Q8 corollary: What would you/your school most want from an accreditation process?
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:54 PM EDT
@lcarroll94
That's a great chair!
#ISEDchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:54 PM EDT
@gen_learn
yep, because they’re best equipped to deal with the “every bucket” focus of a visit.
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:54 PM EDT
A8 That they got our school, fell in love with it, and delivered their recommendations in that spirit.
#isedchat
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:55 PM EDT
@pgow
@gen_learn
Data from
@cwra_beat
would say plenty of room for improvement - not sure where fit is w/accreditation
#ISEDchat
action
kevinjruth
Oct 13 @ 9:55 PM EDT
@crottymark
It should be about where the school is on a continuum of “becoming.”
#isedchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:55 PM EDT
@pgow
i often thought a peek at accred body’s exemplar best practices, but it’s always about the indiv school, not a comparison.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:55 PM EDT
@crottymark
+1 zillion to that!
#ISEDchat
skeeTX
Oct 13 @ 9:55 PM EDT
A8: affirmation that we are serving our Ss in the best way possible
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:56 PM EDT
@kevinjruth
Love that way of putting it.
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:56 PM EDT
@bkolani
They can seem to steer away from "best practices" as a scary or oppressive notion
#ISEDchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:57 PM EDT
@kevinjruth
@crottymark
I like this, but what, then, is the endpoint? How do you define the “this is ideal” side of the continuum?
#isedchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:57 PM EDT
@kevinjruth
Yes! Thank you for that
#ISEDchat
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:57 PM EDT
@pgow
and rightfully so. but every now and then a school could use a “have you heard about what x school is doing with y?”
#isedchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:57 PM EDT
Great conv tonite. Now I'm even more excited for
@ISASouthwest
heads mtgs in month, when one topic is redesigning self study.
#isedchat
gen_learn
Oct 13 @ 9:58 PM EDT
Oh, hey, almost forgot. Monday is first
#isedchat
webinar on designing 21sc C. learning spaces check it out
https://t.co/W8ycwiUdCQ
leefink
Oct 13 @ 9:58 PM EDT
A8 Equal or flexible weighting of qualitative & quantitative measures so underlying mission not shortchanged
#ISEDchat
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:58 PM EDT
@bkolani
Hence my wish for a collaboration std so that that sharing becomes part of the fabric of schools' lives and cultures
#ISEDchat
crottymark
Oct 13 @ 9:59 PM EDT
Thank you
@pgow
Always a great pleasure. Good night
#isedchat
and thanks much.
gen_learn
Oct 13 @ 9:59 PM EDT
Oh, hey, almost forgot. Monday is first
#isedchat
webinar on designing 21sc C. learning spaces check it out
bkolani
Oct 13 @ 9:59 PM EDT
@pgow
yes, absolutely, definitely.
#isedchat
gen_learn
Oct 13 @ 9:59 PM EDT
here is the link to
#isedchat
webinar info
https://t.co/W8ycwiUdCQ
kevinjruth
Oct 13 @ 9:59 PM EDT
@bkolani
@crottymark
#isedchat
I’d suggest removing the notion there is somehow a defined end point. All schools are evolving, constantly.
lcarroll94
- Moderator
Oct 13 @ 9:59 PM EDT
Thanks to
@pgow
for a fantastic
#Isedchat
tonight! :)
pgow
Oct 13 @ 9:59 PM EDT
Our hour is up, and so we bring this week’s
#ISEDchat
to a close.