#txeduchat Archive

An informal learning community for educators worldwide. Our passion for learning and connected learning experiences help us to improve our teaching practices. #txeduchat features guest moderators every week.

Tuesday November 27, 2018
9:00 PM EST

  • txeduchat - Moderator Nov 27 @ 9:00 PM EST
    Great to have you here tonight for #txeduchat
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:02 PM EST
    Hi friends! So excited to be chatting with you tonight. I'm Caty logging on from Keller, TX. Currently serving as the Secondary Literacy Instructional Coach for Region 11. Sidenote: I'm drinking Topo Chico water and I feel super sophisticated right now. #txeduchat
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:04 PM EST
    #txeduchat Join us! Right now!
  • txeduchat - Moderator Nov 27 @ 9:05 PM EST
    Here's question #1. #txeduchat
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:05 PM EST
    #txeduchat ❤️ Topo Chico. Walmart has it in plastic 6-packs! (Great for college care packages.)
    • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:02 PM EST
      Hi friends! So excited to be chatting with you tonight. I'm Caty logging on from Keller, TX. Currently serving as the Secondary Literacy Instructional Coach for Region 11. Sidenote: I'm drinking Topo Chico water and I feel super sophisticated right now. #txeduchat
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:06 PM EST
    #txeduchat Hi, friends! Tosh, literacy crusader, Secondary ELAR Coordinator.
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:07 PM EST
    #txeduchat A1: Discernment.
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:07 PM EST
    A1: Critical literacy is the ability to move beyond the self and examine other perspectives, biases, etc. I think it extends to examining ethical issues, social justice, etc. and understanding one's place in the world. #txeduchat
  • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:10 PM EST
    Nneka here coming in late #txeduchat
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:11 PM EST
    #txeduchat My cats are keeping me company while I chat tonight...
  • txeduchat - Moderator Nov 27 @ 9:12 PM EST
    Here's Question #2. #txeduchat
  • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:14 PM EST
    A2: One of our primary roles should be to provide safe spaces for students to discuss the issues of the day. #txeduchat
    In reply to @txeduchat
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:14 PM EST
    #txeduchat A2: It’s crucial, but many teachers are wary of perceived backlash from parents & community, so they shy away from these “crucial conversations.”
  • gtchatmod Nov 27 @ 9:15 PM EST
    Me, too! Join us for #giftED18 and meet @the_gifted_guy in Fort Worth. @TXGifted #TAGT #TAGT14 #txeduchat #txed
    • the_gifted_guy Nov 27 @ 2:46 PM EST
      Glad to be heading to warmer weather in Fort Worth, Texas for the TAGT Conference. Will be presenting a variety of topics including workshops on Project-Based Learning and Authentic Learning as well as the myths of gifted children and the value of 21st century skills @TXGifted
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:16 PM EST
    #txeduchat “Safe places.” Exactly. Creating a classroom & campus culture where students can explore, discuss, & learn about the tougher things that they will need to understand as adults. It’s almost a type of citizenship.
    • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:14 PM EST
      A2: One of our primary roles should be to provide safe spaces for students to discuss the issues of the day. #txeduchat
      In reply to @txeduchat
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:16 PM EST
    A2: I think it's so important to provide students a safe environment to grapple with tough issues in the world. Society won't be as nice as our classroom community can be while we figure out how to dialogue about religion, politics, and the issues of today. #txeduchat
  • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:16 PM EST
    Very true! It takes special people to possible be made an example of when trying to support "unpopular" topics in school #txeduchat
    In reply to @ToshMcGaughy
  • JeremyDBond Nov 27 @ 9:17 PM EST
    If not at school, where else? That's where you teach. That's where you make mistakes and grow from the experience, not hide from it. #TXEduChat
    • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:14 PM EST
      A2: One of our primary roles should be to provide safe spaces for students to discuss the issues of the day. #txeduchat
      In reply to @txeduchat
  • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:17 PM EST
    Love this! #txeduchat
    In reply to @ToshMcGaughy
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:17 PM EST
    I agree wholeheartedly. I think administrators are a big part of this conversation as well; it's important to let teachers know that they are supported when these big questions and conversations arise. #txeduchat
    In reply to @ToshMcGaughy
  • txeduchat - Moderator Nov 27 @ 9:19 PM EST
    Ready for Question #3? #txeduchat
  • JeremyDBond Nov 27 @ 9:19 PM EST
    From the parent standpoint, I think it helps for schools to provide a forum for kids to hear from others than from within the universe of their family. And they me be isolated otherwise. #TXEduChat A2
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:19 PM EST
    #txeduchat “Special” also means brave, vulnerable, and supported. All those things together. I wish all teachers felt like this.
    • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:16 PM EST
      Very true! It takes special people to possible be made an example of when trying to support "unpopular" topics in school #txeduchat
      In reply to @ToshMcGaughy
  • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:19 PM EST
    Yes! I've found that students thrive when they're able to express themselves more freely, particularly in an environment where safety and respect are embedded into the culture #txeduchat
    In reply to @JeremyDBond
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:21 PM EST
    #txeduchat Absolutely! Learning together & growing as learners is so much more than just about the curriculum. (I taught 7th, & the things we talked about and learned about were often essential life skills that might be more important than gerunds.)
    • JeremyDBond Nov 27 @ 9:17 PM EST
      If not at school, where else? That's where you teach. That's where you make mistakes and grow from the experience, not hide from it. #TXEduChat
      • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:14 PM EST
        A2: One of our primary roles should be to provide safe spaces for students to discuss the issues of the day. #txeduchat
        In reply to @txeduchat
  • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:22 PM EST
    It takes an entire school to create and promote this type of culture, as well as a central admin and tolerant communities. Very difficult combo to get #txeduchat
    In reply to @ToshMcGaughy
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:22 PM EST
    As someone who grew up in Small Town America, I agree. I desperately needed to see, hear, and talk about multiple perspectives to even have the wherewithall to understand what my life could be like outside of my tiny community. #txeduchat
    In reply to @JeremyDBond
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:24 PM EST
    #txeduchat Agreed. Sometimes parents are the isolated ones, too. Many kids are used to growing up with a diverse group of friends & schoolmates, & parents have to “process” what is normal for their children.
    • JeremyDBond Nov 27 @ 9:19 PM EST
      From the parent standpoint, I think it helps for schools to provide a forum for kids to hear from others than from within the universe of their family. And they me be isolated otherwise. #TXEduChat A2
  • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:24 PM EST
    Q3: If your job depends solely on how well your students score on one test, you are less likely to want to focus on multiple perspectives #txeduchat
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:24 PM EST
    A3: Fear. I think @ToshMcGaughy already referenced this, but many teachers are terrified of the potential fallout or backlash from parents/admin. I also think there's a fear of "getting it wrong" that keeps many people from speaking about varied perspectives. #txeduchat
  • DrHarrisonMcCoy Nov 27 @ 9:25 PM EST
    Congratulations on late. Was Christmas decorating. How y'all! #txeduchat
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:25 PM EST
    #txeduchat I agree. A perfect storm. 🌩
    • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:22 PM EST
      It takes an entire school to create and promote this type of culture, as well as a central admin and tolerant communities. Very difficult combo to get #txeduchat
      In reply to @ToshMcGaughy
  • txeduchat - Moderator Nov 27 @ 9:26 PM EST
    Here's Question #4. #txeduchat
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:26 PM EST
    This reality makes me sad. If jobs are dependent on test scores, how can anyone expect a teacher to break out of survival mode and get to the heart of teaching kids? #txeduchat
    In reply to @nnekamcgee
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:28 PM EST
    #txeduchat Nneka! This is sadly, emphatically true. I’m up to my elbows in textbook adoption materials for new ELAR TEKS, & you wouldn’t be shocked at how little texts have changed. (Even though our students have.) Testing drives many things...
    • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:24 PM EST
      Q3: If your job depends solely on how well your students score on one test, you are less likely to want to focus on multiple perspectives #txeduchat
  • DrHarrisonMcCoy Nov 27 @ 9:29 PM EST
    I was talking with a science teacher yesterday who couldn't show the Mars landing in class because it didn't fit benchmark teaching schedule. #txeduchat #sad
    In reply to @catydear, @nnekamcgee
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:29 PM EST
    A4: The Internet in and of itself connects this generation of students in ways most of us never experienced until adulthood. When I was in the classroom, we used to take Google Earth Lit Trips; students could see cultures/parts of the world they never would otherwise. #txeduchat
  • JeremyDBond Nov 27 @ 9:29 PM EST
    I hear you. How do you thread that needle, so parents don't begin to object? #TXEduChat
    • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:24 PM EST
      #txeduchat Agreed. Sometimes parents are the isolated ones, too. Many kids are used to growing up with a diverse group of friends & schoolmates, & parents have to “process” what is normal for their children.
      • JeremyDBond Nov 27 @ 9:19 PM EST
        From the parent standpoint, I think it helps for schools to provide a forum for kids to hear from others than from within the universe of their family. And they me be isolated otherwise. #TXEduChat A2
  • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:29 PM EST
    Right. I see this fear paralyze teachers more often than I care to admit. Would love to see a paradigm shift. #txeduchat
    In reply to @catydear
  • McCone_Literacy Nov 27 @ 9:29 PM EST
    Hello to everyone! Michelle McCone here from FWISD Sec Literacy joining late. #TXEduChat
  • JeremyDBond Nov 27 @ 9:30 PM EST
    And since K-12 schools may reflect that isolated community, sometimes it takes higher education to begin experiencing more of the world. #TXEduChat
    • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:22 PM EST
      As someone who grew up in Small Town America, I agree. I desperately needed to see, hear, and talk about multiple perspectives to even have the wherewithall to understand what my life could be like outside of my tiny community. #txeduchat
      In reply to @JeremyDBond
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:30 PM EST
    No worries, Michelle! Glad you're here! #txeduchat
    In reply to @McCone_Literacy
  • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:31 PM EST
    I. Just. Cannot. #txeduchat
    In reply to @DrHarrisonMcCoy, @catydear
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:32 PM EST
    This was always such a controversial convo I had with my 12th graders. On the one hand, community college helps them avoid so much debt. But I want those babies to get out of their town and experience something different. #txeduchat
    In reply to @JeremyDBond
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:32 PM EST
    and when I say "babies," it's with love and endearment. Sometimes Twitter tone gets lost. #txeduchat
    In reply to @JeremyDBond
  • txeduchat - Moderator Nov 27 @ 9:33 PM EST
    Time for Question #5. #txeduchat
  • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:33 PM EST
    I totally agree. I feel kind of lucky: I went to an awesome diverse public high school, but higher education allowed me to spread my wings. #txeduchat
    In reply to @JeremyDBond
  • Past2Present Nov 27 @ 9:34 PM EST
    Listen in on our discussion about how we approach teaching the Bill of Rights to students. #txed #sschat #txeduchat #sstlap https://t.co/KSx43zUXHZ
  • JeremyDBond Nov 27 @ 9:34 PM EST
    I got it! ;) And I know where you're coming from. #TXEduChat
    In reply to @catydear
  • JeremyDBond Nov 27 @ 9:35 PM EST
    That sounds great. (And yummy!) Was wondering how it'd go down in a largely monolithic school, though those are on the decline. #TXEduChat
    In reply to @ToshMcGaughy
  • McCone_Literacy Nov 27 @ 9:36 PM EST
    A3- I think the first step is an awareness through diversity training - to see issues do exist for our students -many don’t realize if they’ve only taught one type of literature/units for a long time without talking to your kids about what they want to read as well. #txeduchat
  • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:37 PM EST
    Q5: Would debating a topic with references to support arguments count? (kind of like Lincoln-Douglass) #txeduchat
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:37 PM EST
    A5: Socratic seminars, pinwheel discussions, any activity that can provide a safe platform for open and honest discussion. I also used to do research projects/presentations on polarizing viewpoints. So many incredible discussions stemmed from their questions. #Txeduchat
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:37 PM EST
    #txeduchat I graduated from La Vernia HS...87 kids in my class. Rural, conservative, traditional, close-knit. Even with my small horizons, I knew that education was my “golden ticket.” Went to UT & quickly learned sooo much about the world. Also learned to ❤️ where I was from.
    • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:22 PM EST
      As someone who grew up in Small Town America, I agree. I desperately needed to see, hear, and talk about multiple perspectives to even have the wherewithall to understand what my life could be like outside of my tiny community. #txeduchat
      In reply to @JeremyDBond
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:38 PM EST
    I love everything about this and want to attend that dinner party. #txeduchat
    In reply to @ToshMcGaughy, @JeremyDBond
  • DrHarrisonMcCoy Nov 27 @ 9:39 PM EST
    I graduated high school so long ago, I'm pretty sure the world really was a smaller place then. Our students have a much bigger world to explore. #txeduchat
    In reply to @ToshMcGaughy
  • txeduchat - Moderator Nov 27 @ 9:40 PM EST
    Question #6 is next. #txeduchat
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:40 PM EST
    I definitely think so! So many students only see one perspective as the "right" perspective. Forcing their hand a bit to support either side with research can open a door to A) understanding a new "side" and B) articulating an opinion intelligently. #txeduchat
    In reply to @nnekamcgee
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:40 PM EST
    #txeduchat Important trainings/ discussions for students and educators.
    • McCone_Literacy Nov 27 @ 9:36 PM EST
      A3- I think the first step is an awareness through diversity training - to see issues do exist for our students -many don’t realize if they’ve only taught one type of literature/units for a long time without talking to your kids about what they want to read as well. #txeduchat
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:43 PM EST
    #txeduchat My incredible but very opinionated & sensitive 18-year-old daughter loses it on me when I push back as a devil’s advocate. “There are no absolutes. There are people. Everyone has beliefs & respecting their right to believe is what we do.” She gets so made at me...
    • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:40 PM EST
      I definitely think so! So many students only see one perspective as the "right" perspective. Forcing their hand a bit to support either side with research can open a door to A) understanding a new "side" and B) articulating an opinion intelligently. #txeduchat
      In reply to @nnekamcgee
  • txeduchat - Moderator Nov 27 @ 9:47 PM EST
    Here's Question #7. #txeduchat
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:47 PM EST
    Curious to see everyone's responses to #6. Is this a current conversation happening in districts/campuses, or are many not ready to have it? #Txeduchat
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:48 PM EST
    #txeduchat A6: Student choice reading...every day. (Yep. You read that right.) And...I’m not quite sure what else yet. (3rd week on the job.)
  • DrHarrisonMcCoy Nov 27 @ 9:49 PM EST
    Timidly is a word that comes to mind -- at least in my experience. #txeduchat
    In reply to @catydear
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:49 PM EST
    A7: If I can help a student become a better human being, one that can process complex emotions, discuss multiple viewpoints, and develop their own opinion, it's more important than any lesson on summarization I can teach. #txeduchat
  • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:49 PM EST
    A7: I think it can, depending on the topic and the classroom environment. #txeduchat
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:51 PM EST
    If that's the case, what will it take to open the door to have this conversation? #txeduchat
    In reply to @nnekamcgee
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:51 PM EST
    #txeduchat A7: Definitely. Exploring how we should interact in the world, through inquiry & open discussion, teaches those socio-emotional/ empathy skills that are only going to become more necessary in our increasingly global society
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:53 PM EST
    #txeduchat Again. The importance of creating that inclusive environment. I wonder how much teachers get PD on how to do this? Well?
    • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:49 PM EST
      A7: I think it can, depending on the topic and the classroom environment. #txeduchat
  • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:53 PM EST
    Agreed. Empathy is a skill that must be taught! #txeduchat
    • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:51 PM EST
      #txeduchat A7: Definitely. Exploring how we should interact in the world, through inquiry & open discussion, teaches those socio-emotional/ empathy skills that are only going to become more necessary in our increasingly global society
  • nnekamcgee Nov 27 @ 9:55 PM EST
    I haven't seen much PD on creating inclusive environments. Anyone else? #txeduchat
    In reply to @ToshMcGaughy
  • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:55 PM EST
    #txeduchat My pal Dr. M might chime in on this as well, but the design process begins with Empathy. I think that’s very interesting...& powerful for teachers to tap into with students.
    • catydear Nov 27 @ 9:53 PM EST
      Agreed. Empathy is a skill that must be taught! #txeduchat
      • ToshMcGaughy Nov 27 @ 9:51 PM EST
        #txeduchat A7: Definitely. Exploring how we should interact in the world, through inquiry & open discussion, teaches those socio-emotional/ empathy skills that are only going to become more necessary in our increasingly global society
  • DrHarrisonMcCoy Nov 27 @ 9:55 PM EST
    A6: I find a lot of younger teachers are predisposed to feel positively about this but lack the courage to step out and go that direction. Admin needs to set the tone. #txeduchat
    In reply to @catydear, @nnekamcgee
  • DrHarrisonMcCoy Nov 27 @ 9:56 PM EST
    If only. #txeduchat
    In reply to @ToshMcGaughy
  • DrHarrisonMcCoy Nov 27 @ 9:58 PM EST
    You're so right. We could make such a difference by teaching and cultivating empathy. Design thinking is just a fun vehicle. #txeduchat
    In reply to @ToshMcGaughy