#TeachWriting Archive
#TeachWriting chat is where educators talk about writing instruction. Every other Tuesday @ 9pm ET/8pm CT.
Tuesday April 18, 2017
9:00 PM EDT
TeachWriting2
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:00 PM EDT
Welcome to
#TeachWriting
, our bi-weekly (usually) chat about writing instruction - guest mod tonight is
@Jeremybballer
- take it away!
participatechat
Apr 18 @ 9:00 PM EDT
Participate in the upcoming
#TeachWriting
by sharing resources and collaborating at
https://t.co/zIInYJmWQo
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:01 PM EDT
Evening everyone! Take a moment to introduce yourself, what you teach, where you are from and your favorite part of speech
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:02 PM EDT
Ben from the Chicago area, teach 7th grade science/social studies, originally from Cleveland, OH. Definitely love adjectives.
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:02 PM EDT
Jeremy from MI, 8th grade science/English, author, co-director for CRWP. Love adjectives.
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:02 PM EDT
Rob from Dallas. 8th grade English T and I'm partial to the preposition as I'm bothered when it is used to end a sentence!
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:02 PM EDT
I'm tempted to say verbs - those are supposed to be more important, right? But adjectives are like candy. Don't need them, but
#teachwriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:02 PM EDT
Hello all. Troy Hicks from Central Mich Univ. Teacher educator and director of
@chippewariverwp
Will chime in as I can to
#teachwriting
mrnewell83
Apr 18 @ 9:02 PM EDT
Jack from CA. MS ELA/SS. Grammar has always been tough, I look forward to learning a few good things tonight.
#Teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:03 PM EDT
Welcome!
#teachwriting
In reply to @mrnewell83
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:03 PM EDT
Hey, Troy! Great to see you here!
#teachwriting
In reply to @hickstro, @chippewariverwp
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:03 PM EDT
Welcome, Rob, glad you could join us this evening!
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:03 PM EDT
Please welcome my co-author
@hickstro
. Greatest writing mentor there is.
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:04 PM EDT
And a pretty awesome keynote speaker, IMO. . .
#teachwriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer, @hickstro
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:04 PM EDT
Welcome Jack. Hope we can help.
#teachwriting
In reply to @mrnewell83
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:04 PM EDT
How's it going, Ben? Wake up the Cubs!
#teachwriting
In reply to @bkuhl2you
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:04 PM EDT
No worries. They'll figure it out.
#TeachWriting
In reply to @skeeTX
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:04 PM EDT
Hi all, Scott from MD. I'm a 6-12 ELA Instructional Specialist. Favorite is definitely the interjection. Sike! First chat with
#teachwriting
mrnewell83
Apr 18 @ 9:05 PM EDT
Still remember argument w/ soph yr Tr about dangling participles. Scarred for life
#Teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:05 PM EDT
Bulls ahead tonight again.
#teachwriting
In reply to @bkuhl2you
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:05 PM EDT
Welcome!
#teachwriting
In reply to @Lyricalswordz
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:05 PM EDT
I'd love to see that continue - but I'm a Cavs fan. . .
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:06 PM EDT
1st question coming up in a few minutes. Welcome everyone.
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:06 PM EDT
NBA/NHL/MLB would be better if like European soccer w/ promotion & relegation! Too many games!
#teachwriting
In reply to @bkuhl2you
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:07 PM EDT
Agree - love that the standings have teeth. My Browns would have been relegated a long time ago. . .
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:07 PM EDT
"That is the sort of pedantry up with which i will not put" or something like that, maybe by Churchill, it's vague... 😀
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:07 PM EDT
Everyone ready for a grammar explosion? Here...we...go!
#TeachWriting
TeachWriting2
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:08 PM EDT
Check out the new book that our moderator has co-written with
@hickstro
- about grammar!
https://t.co/2Iu14YOvUM
#TeachWriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:08 PM EDT
Thanks Ben, glad to be here!
#teachwriting
In reply to @bkuhl2you
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:08 PM EDT
Soccer is still my fav. FIFA is corrupt but I love it so!
#teachwriting
In reply to @bkuhl2you
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:08 PM EDT
Q1: What issues do Ts face today with teaching grammar?
#teachwriting
KayBReynolds
Apr 18 @ 9:08 PM EDT
Kay, K-12 literacy coach from Georgia, joining tonight's chat on grammar
#TeachWriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:08 PM EDT
Welcome Kay. Glad you could make it.
#teachwriting
In reply to @KayBReynolds
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:08 PM EDT
Welcome, Kay!
#teachwriting
In reply to @KayBReynolds
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:09 PM EDT
A1 - Two things, I think. First, kids think grammar doesn't matter b/c of "spellcheck." Or the fact that others echo mistake
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:09 PM EDT
A1: it's boring to Ss, disregarded by society, and emojis are cooler to many
#teachwriting
massignmenthelp
Apr 18 @ 9:10 PM EDT
#Teachwriting
#TMchat
#eduldrcoaching
#txlchat
#TopTeaching
#risdchat
15 Websites to Increase Productivity
https://t.co/t6CXdTeYbl
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:10 PM EDT
That is one of the biggest responses I get from my middle school Ss. ITS BORING.
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:10 PM EDT
A1 - And two, teachers seem to have retreated on grammar. Or it's such a huge task with almost no support or incentive.
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:10 PM EDT
A1b: not many Ts get jazzed a/b teaching grammar. Though, with creativity & imagination, it can be done
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:10 PM EDT
I feel that Ts don't have the confidence to teach it. I may be wrong.
#teachwriting
In reply to @bkuhl2you
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:10 PM EDT
A1 - It's like, teachers and admins pound hard on PARCC testing content. If it ain't tested, we often don't teach it.
#teachwriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:11 PM EDT
A1 General lack of interest, both with the content and the manner in which it is usually taught. We need to supply a "why"
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:11 PM EDT
Yes, but it is a language with which we can do so much!
#teachwriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer
KayBReynolds
Apr 18 @ 9:11 PM EDT
A2 not teaching it in isolation but knowing enough about author's craft to teach it as part of reading & writing
#TeachWriting
mrnewell83
Apr 18 @ 9:11 PM EDT
A1: knowing that diagramming sentences does not make good writers; but struggle to engage Ss
#Teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:11 PM EDT
I know some teachers who shy away from it for that reason. But generally, it's about time, IMO.
#teachwriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:12 PM EDT
Hi Everyone! Running in late! Lisa, from RI!
#teachwriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:12 PM EDT
A1b I often see, too, that teachers lack confidence in their knowledge of grammar. Know what you don't know, and then learn it
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:12 PM EDT
Yes, it shouldn't be taught just in isolation.
#teachwriting
In reply to @KayBReynolds
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:12 PM EDT
Grammar is a must in all foreign language classes, but it is a dinosaur in English class
#teachwriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:12 PM EDT
Students get blamed for having "bad grammar," when in fact they are code-switching across media/genre.
#teachwriting
mrnewell83
Apr 18 @ 9:12 PM EDT
Where's
@writeguyjeff
tonight? He's the grammar king 👑
#Teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:12 PM EDT
This definitely turns Ss off.
#TeachWriting
In reply to @mrnewell83
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:13 PM EDT
Tru dat. Learned about the subjunctive in French class before I learned anything about it in English.
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:13 PM EDT
And....I'm fired up, when one speaks well, it's as if the speaker is perceived as arrogant!
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:13 PM EDT
A1 Not teaching in the context of the writing is a major issue. Grammar in isolation isn't transferable
#teachWriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:13 PM EDT
That is too bad.
#teachwriting
In reply to @KayBReynolds, @bkuhl2you
mrnewell83
Apr 18 @ 9:14 PM EDT
A1b: I also teach many ELs so that adds to the struggle. Also fight what they hear at home
#Teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:14 PM EDT
Love that guy - great ideas about incorporating grammar into writing workshop.
#teachwriting
In reply to @mrnewell83, @writeguyjeff
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:15 PM EDT
No and experts like Constance Weaver and
@writeguyjeff
would agree.
#teachwriting
In reply to @lisahughes196, @writeguyjeff
AssignmentHelpN
Apr 18 @ 9:15 PM EDT
#Teachwriting
#TMchat
#eduldrcoaching
#txlchat
#TopTeaching
#risdchat
A Beginner’s Guide on How to Make Mind Maps
https://t.co/HMbTauQCs5
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:15 PM EDT
That's the worst part. We need to encourage Ts to admit when they don't know something and then learn something new. It's okay
#teachwriting
In reply to @KayBReynolds, @Jeremybballer, @bkuhl2you
KayBReynolds
Apr 18 @ 9:16 PM EDT
Heard a great talk by
@MaryEhrenworth
at TCRWP about code switching with grammar. Fascinating stuff!
#teachWriting
In reply to @hickstro, @MaryEhrenworth
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:16 PM EDT
Also, we miss TONS of transferable writing connections & strategies only teaching to the test.Too formulaic..not real writing.
#TeachWriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:16 PM EDT
Hard to see the difference without careful reading and repeated examples - not common on grammar worksheets.
#teachwriting
In reply to @hickstro
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:16 PM EDT
Going to throw out Q2 here in one minute because I think it relates to our 1st question too.
#teachwriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:17 PM EDT
Indeed. Wwe've known this for many decades now, yet we still persist in believing that there is one "right" way to speak/write
#teachwriting
In reply to @KayBReynolds, @MaryEhrenworth
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:17 PM EDT
@hickstro
and I discuss code switching in our book and
@teachKHT
has some great articles on it as well.
#teachwriting
In reply to @KayBReynolds, @hickstro, @MaryEhrenworth, @hickstro, @teachKHT
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:17 PM EDT
Awesome to have
@hickstro
in the
#teachwriting
house tonight!
In reply to @hickstro, @KayBReynolds, @MaryEhrenworth, @hickstro
GOgreenGOwrite
Apr 18 @ 9:18 PM EDT
Ooh,
#teachWriting
chat happening now. Check it out.
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:18 PM EDT
Glad to have
@Jeremybballer
here!
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:18 PM EDT
Agreed! Don't fake your way through it.
#teachwriting
In reply to @Lyricalswordz, @KayBReynolds, @bkuhl2you
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:19 PM EDT
Q2: What reasons do you think Ss struggle with grammar concepts?
#teachwriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:19 PM EDT
So true. We need to have a growth mindset not only for students, but staff as well
#teachwriting
In reply to @KayBReynolds, @Jeremybballer, @bkuhl2you
scottmpetri
Apr 18 @ 9:19 PM EDT
Too much of this w/ my 11th graders. Can't capitalize to save their lives. Why don't they use
@Grammarly
#teachwriting
In reply to @hickstro, @Grammarly
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:20 PM EDT
AND Dr. Scott Petri tonight?!
@scottmpetri
Love it!
#teachwriting
In reply to @scottmpetri, @hickstro, @Grammarly, @scottmpetri
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:20 PM EDT
There are other tools out there besides Grammarly.
#teachwriting
In reply to @scottmpetri, @hickstro, @Grammarly
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:20 PM EDT
A2 - They're hard. Too many words, too many exceptions, too many ways to say the same thing . . . differently. . .
#teachwriting
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:20 PM EDT
Joining late. Renee, community college English teacher, Mississippi Delta.
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:20 PM EDT
A2: many are receiving it in isolation to memorize & regurgitate on a test instead of using context & application in writing
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:20 PM EDT
Welcome, Renee!
#teachwriting
In reply to @TeachMoore
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:20 PM EDT
A2: Most of the struggle is because they learn isolated facts about grammar, yet never explore the beauty of language.
#teachwriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer
SeanRuday
Apr 18 @ 9:20 PM EDT
A2: Ss who struggle with grammatical concepts often see little meaning or application related to their study of them (1/2)
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:20 PM EDT
Thanks for joining us Renee.
#teachwriting
In reply to @TeachMoore
scottmpetri
Apr 18 @ 9:21 PM EDT
Yes, but it is an easy Chrome extension that does all the work for you.
#teachwriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer, @hickstro, @Grammarly
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:21 PM EDT
Glad you could join us Sean. Dr. Ruday in the HOUSE.
#teachwriting
In reply to @SeanRuday
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:21 PM EDT
We also tend to predominantly focus on grammar via the written word and ignore the oral component
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:22 PM EDT
A2 - And it's not necessarily useful. Or, Ss don't see it that way. They think they should write as they talk . . .
#teachwriting
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:22 PM EDT
A2: Many of my students confused about basic grammar concepts, even those they have heard of before. lack terms & confidence
#TeachWriting
SeanRuday
Apr 18 @ 9:22 PM EDT
A2: Ss need to see grammatical concepts as tools for effective writing that published authors use to enhance their works (2/2)
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:22 PM EDT
Which in some instances is fine.
#teachwriting
In reply to @bkuhl2you
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:22 PM EDT
Q2 Because English is the worst? So many exceptions and illogical constructions. ELLs struggle with syntax, possessives, etc
#teachwriting
KayBReynolds
Apr 18 @ 9:23 PM EDT
A2 Ts and Ss don't get the power of author's choice w/ grammar & mechanics & the impact small choices make
#TeachWriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:23 PM EDT
A2 There is a disconnect between grammar & the writing.We spend our time nudging Ss to write then come the rules! Turns Ss off
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:23 PM EDT
A2 - I also have a large percentage of students who learned Spanish (or Polish) first, and still speak it at home or w/friends
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:23 PM EDT
Absolutely!
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:20 PM EDT
A2: many are receiving it in isolation to memorize & regurgitate on a test instead of using context & application in writing
#teachwriting
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:23 PM EDT
This is true, and not acknowledged enough.
#TeachWriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:22 PM EDT
Q2 Because English is the worst? So many exceptions and illogical constructions. ELLs struggle with syntax, possessives, etc
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:23 PM EDT
Yes and
#NCTE
and their position discusses how we need to discuss grammar and talk about it, not just do it.
#teachwriting
In reply to @hickstro
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:23 PM EDT
If real world ignores many rules of grammar, how much should we expect our Ss to retain?
#teachwriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:23 PM EDT
A2b Also we often teach them using ineffective methods. Eventually they don't understand why they don't understand and give up
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:24 PM EDT
Happy Anniversary!
#teachwriting
In reply to @scottmpetri, @hickstro, @Grammarly
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:24 PM EDT
Yes, and the English language doesn't follow its own rules.
#teachwriting
In reply to @TeachMoore
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:24 PM EDT
"If I retweet it, you should read it" Love that!
#teachwriting
In reply to @TeachMoore
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:24 PM EDT
That should be a good thing for their language development, isn't it?
#TeachWriting
In reply to @bkuhl2you
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:24 PM EDT
Agreed. We need to help Ss realize the importance.
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:24 PM EDT
DOL is a good example. Not the easiest way to learn. Need positive examples, models of the "good."
#teachwriting
In reply to @Lyricalswordz
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:24 PM EDT
Blogs are published and wildly popular, yet many I read are not grammatically sound. And I'm okay with that. Now what?
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:25 PM EDT
Need to have application too.
#teachwriting
.
In reply to @bkuhl2you, @Lyricalswordz
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:25 PM EDT
Sure - not saying they shouldn't continue to speak their native language, but when rules are so different from English . . .
#TeachWriting
In reply to @TeachMoore
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:26 PM EDT
Lot of debate over most effective, and culturally appropriate methods for this.
#TeachWriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:23 PM EDT
A2b Also we often teach them using ineffective methods. Eventually they don't understand why they don't understand and give up
#teachwriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:26 PM EDT
DOL? With you on the rest! Using mentor sentences really helps to teach challenging and creative constructions
#teachwriting
In reply to @bkuhl2you
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:26 PM EDT
If students don't learn to apply it then what are we actually teaching?
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:26 PM EDT
That's how we learn to write, am I correct?
#teachwriting
In reply to @Lyricalswordz, @bkuhl2you
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:26 PM EDT
Ah, yes. and English is notoriously unruly compared to other languages.
#TeachWriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:25 PM EDT
Sure - not saying they shouldn't continue to speak their native language, but when rules are so different from English . . .
#TeachWriting
In reply to @TeachMoore
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:27 PM EDT
@skeeTX
How's TX?
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @bkuhl2you, @skeeTX
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:27 PM EDT
Question 3 coming right up!
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:27 PM EDT
Great Q. If we teach something that is largely ignored, should we force it on Ss/to what degree?
#teachwriting
In reply to @lisahughes196
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:27 PM EDT
True, but no debate (IMHO) over drill and kill and grammar worksheets! Tried and true methods that fail students
#teachwriting
In reply to @TeachMoore
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:27 PM EDT
This is ultimately the struggle.
#teachwriting
In reply to @lisahughes196
katiablaskovich
Apr 18 @ 9:28 PM EDT
Q2.
#teachwriting
Ss see grammar as set of rules. In composition, grammar is more like rhythm in music. Relies on innovation w/in patterns
In reply to @Jeremybballer
scottmpetri
Apr 18 @ 9:28 PM EDT
A2 Watch my 12 yr old daughter struggle w/ grammar b/c she reads too much fanfiction and not enough lit.
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:28 PM EDT
And this is the way we should teach it.
#teachwriting
In reply to @katiablaskovich
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:28 PM EDT
Warming up! Rained a ton yesterday but I can see the finish line approaching. And RI?
#teachwriting
In reply to @lisahughes196, @bkuhl2you
askaouris
Apr 18 @ 9:28 PM EDT
A2: Too much emphasis on terms -isolated practice activities- ¬ enough on sentence patterns leaves grammar disconnected.
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:29 PM EDT
Is there a better way?
https://t.co/SJZqlWVnP7
#TeachWriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:29 PM EDT
That's the challenge. We impose rules on students we don't follow ourselves. Is this the best approach?
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:29 PM EDT
Q3: To what extent should tech be blamed for grammar issues our Ss demonstrate?
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:29 PM EDT
Yes. I feel like I learned grammar from reading AND writing, often on my own, and trying to sound like a "real writer."
#TeachWriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer, @Lyricalswordz
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:29 PM EDT
Great Question! Something to definitely think about.
#teachwriting
In reply to @Lyricalswordz, @skeeTX
pedagogilist
Apr 18 @ 9:30 PM EDT
Yessss! Language can be beautiful! Children can be taught to write beautifully!
#teachwriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:20 PM EDT
A2: Most of the struggle is because they learn isolated facts about grammar, yet never explore the beauty of language.
#teachwriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:30 PM EDT
A3 We need to embrace the digital natives that are in our classrooms. Let's stop blaming tech and start working with it!
#Teachwriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:30 PM EDT
Yes! We need to give students low-stakes writing so they can learn to write through writing, rather than write for a grade
#teachwriting
In reply to @bkuhl2you, @Jeremybballer
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:31 PM EDT
A3: tech provides a shortcut but that seems to be human nature. Quick fix, be done, move on. Abbreviations & emojis
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:31 PM EDT
Thank you! This is the same message
@hickstro
and I try to relay in our forthcoming book.
#teachwriting
In reply to @lisahughes196, @hickstro
SeanRuday
Apr 18 @ 9:31 PM EDT
A3: I don't blame tech. It provides Ss with authentic audiences for their writing and provides an example of code switching
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:31 PM EDT
Or write to a test! Or to a formula...like a factory...student in...student out...all the same
#teachwriting
In reply to @Lyricalswordz, @bkuhl2you, @Jeremybballer
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:31 PM EDT
A3 - Lots of negative models out there. Kids are writing more than ever thanks to tech, and lots is unfiltered, unedited.
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:31 PM EDT
But real writer use many different conventions so is proper grammar a necessity?
#teachwriting
In reply to @bkuhl2you, @Jeremybballer, @Lyricalswordz
scottmpetri
Apr 18 @ 9:31 PM EDT
Great point
@bkuhl2you
Many students do not read enough outside of class to appreciate inspirational prose
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:29 PM EDT
Yes. I feel like I learned grammar from reading AND writing, often on my own, and trying to sound like a "real writer."
#TeachWriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer, @Lyricalswordz
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:32 PM EDT
Like this analogy!
#teachwriting
katiablaskovich
Apr 18 @ 9:28 PM EDT
Q2.
#teachwriting
Ss see grammar as set of rules. In composition, grammar is more like rhythm in music. Relies on innovation w/in patterns
In reply to @Jeremybballer
mrnewell83
Apr 18 @ 9:32 PM EDT
A3: I don't blame tech per se but propagation of bad writing is allowed by tech. Ss understand diff Btwn txt and essay I think
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:32 PM EDT
Agreed! The authentic spaces are crucial places for our Ss to learn.
#teachwriting
In reply to @SeanRuday
askaouris
Apr 18 @ 9:32 PM EDT
A3: Not sure blame is right. Tech didn't cause this. Yrs of not exploring the conflict bw the codes students use is prob.
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:32 PM EDT
I would say that students do not write enough in school either.
#Teachwriting
In reply to @scottmpetri, @bkuhl2you
spiraledu
Apr 18 @ 9:32 PM EDT
A3. My S are aware of the squiggle when typing, so I think tech helps them know something is wrong but not how to correct it
#teachwriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer, @bkuhl2you
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:33 PM EDT
This reminds me of our 5 paragraph essay chat. Aside from academia, where is the essay required? Grammar focus in schools only
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:33 PM EDT
Great response. I appreciate your thoughts here.
#teachwriting
In reply to @askaouris
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:33 PM EDT
A3 - It's a good and bad thing. Bad when kids can't tune in to SWE.
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:33 PM EDT
Isn't that what many Ts do in many subjects??? Sad but true I think
#Teachwriting
In reply to @lisahughes196, @Lyricalswordz, @bkuhl2you, @Jeremybballer
pedagogilist
Apr 18 @ 9:33 PM EDT
This gets at worship of the (academic) written word as the pinnacle of intellect. IF we allow for dif conventions who loses?
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:31 PM EDT
But real writer use many different conventions so is proper grammar a necessity?
#teachwriting
In reply to @bkuhl2you, @Jeremybballer, @Lyricalswordz
bnjmn_k_wdcck
Apr 18 @ 9:33 PM EDT
@mslizkrause
This looks like an excellent text to explore from
@Jeremybballer
&
@hickstro
, along with the
#TeachWriting
thread.
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 8:36 PM EDT
Join me in less then 30 min to discuss grammar instruction in a digital age on
#teachwriting
. Can't wait to share snip-its from our book.
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:33 PM EDT
A3: Students have a keen sense of how to use language AND tech to convey messages. Sometimes subtle, sometimes not!
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:34 PM EDT
I think it's a social or class marker these days. Grammar = education. Back to the "snob" thing you mentioned.
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:34 PM EDT
A3. Tech has been a convenient scapegoat for frustrated ELA teachers to blame. These problems and issues predate smartphones
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:34 PM EDT
Students are global citizens now. They need authentic audience in digital platforms.
#teachwriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:34 PM EDT
A4 I don't blame tech at all. My generation didn't grow up with tech and we sucked at grammar too. Focus on how tech helps!
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:34 PM EDT
Thank you sir! It is due out May 23rd. Can't wait to share it with the world.
#teachwriting
In reply to @bnjmn_k_wdcck, @mslizkrause, @hickstro
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:34 PM EDT
A3: Look at hashtags trending on Twitter at any given moment. How many are unique combinations of language enabled by tech?
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:35 PM EDT
Students need to collaborate and write across genres, content areas, and tasks! Writing isn't just for English class!
#TeachWriting
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:35 PM EDT
A3; Anybody familiar w/Andrea Lunsford's research on effects of tech on student fluency and writing quality?
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:35 PM EDT
Yes, this is where our focus should be. We need to use tech to our advantage as teachers.
#teachwriting
In reply to @Lyricalswordz
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:35 PM EDT
I would LOVE to review this book!
#Teachwriting
In reply to @bnjmn_k_wdcck, @mslizkrause, @Jeremybballer, @hickstro
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:35 PM EDT
A3 - Language has always been about change. Tech is increasing the rate of change and the multiplicity of it.
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:36 PM EDT
Yes, so what does that mean for grammar as described by our old grammar textbooks?
#teachwriting
In reply to @lisahughes196
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:36 PM EDT
Please share out. It would be great!
#teachwriting
.
In reply to @TeachMoore
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:36 PM EDT
Nor do other Ts look at grammar necessarily.
#teachwriting
In reply to @lisahughes196
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:36 PM EDT
A3 - I think we might need to clarify what "grammar" is - comma rules (which are unclear and inconsistent), or clarity?
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:36 PM EDT
Agreed! The students we are teaching DID grow up with tech. Our schools and our teaching need to reflect this!
#Teachwriting
In reply to @Lyricalswordz
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:36 PM EDT
Would you like us to see if I can get you an advanced copy?
#teachwriting
In reply to @lisahughes196, @bnjmn_k_wdcck, @mslizkrause, @hickstro
bnjmn_k_wdcck
Apr 18 @ 9:37 PM EDT
Me too! Looking forward to reading it!
#TeachWriting
In reply to @lisahughes196, @mslizkrause, @Jeremybballer, @hickstro
askaouris
Apr 18 @ 9:37 PM EDT
Old grammar books are obsolete. New methods needed. Focused on patterns, models, real writing.
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @lisahughes196
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:37 PM EDT
Still a place for "old school" grammar. Knowing the difference b/w a subject and object is still imp. How we teach it matters.
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @lisahughes196
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:37 PM EDT
. . . and perhaps we have to know more conventions these days. Or making meaning can be difficult.
#teachwriting
In reply to @TeachMoore
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:37 PM EDT
YES!!!!!!!!!!
#teachwriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer, @bnjmn_k_wdcck, @mslizkrause, @hickstro
KayBReynolds
Apr 18 @ 9:38 PM EDT
A3 My responsibility if I don't cluster rdg , writing, & lang. skills in a way to highlight the impact grammar has on text.
#TeachWriting
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:38 PM EDT
I see that as part of my job; to expose them to texts they may not find on their own.
#teachwriting
scottmpetri
Apr 18 @ 9:31 PM EDT
Great point
@bkuhl2you
Many students do not read enough outside of class to appreciate inspirational prose
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:29 PM EDT
Yes. I feel like I learned grammar from reading AND writing, often on my own, and trying to sound like a "real writer."
#TeachWriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer, @Lyricalswordz
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:38 PM EDT
Sure but not if it is just b/c we are testing what it is.
#Teachwriting
In reply to @hickstro, @lisahughes196
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:38 PM EDT
Question 4 coming at yeah! Get ready. Loving this conversations so far.
#teachwriting
katiablaskovich
Apr 18 @ 9:38 PM EDT
Online just provides more genres for Ss to adapt to.If they see grammar as contextual discipline, can see/imitate new patterns
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:39 PM EDT
Fun grammar apps!
https://t.co/znbifFw4P9
#TeachWriting
SeanRuday
Apr 18 @ 9:39 PM EDT
I tell my Ss that some grammatical concepts are used for clarity, while others can add important details
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:36 PM EDT
A3 - I think we might need to clarify what "grammar" is - comma rules (which are unclear and inconsistent), or clarity?
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:39 PM EDT
A3 - Perhaps grammar is being inflected by locality, the way speech is, like a kind of "accent"? Discourse communities?
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:40 PM EDT
Q4a: What can we do specifically do to help Ss understand the difference between formal & informal writing?
#teachwriting
bnjmn_k_wdcck
Apr 18 @ 9:40 PM EDT
I wish more Ts accepted this fact and encouraged their Ss to write, write, write, (right?!) in their content areas.
#TeachWriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:35 PM EDT
Students need to collaborate and write across genres, content areas, and tasks! Writing isn't just for English class!
#TeachWriting
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:40 PM EDT
Yes they do!
#teachwriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:33 PM EDT
A3: Students have a keen sense of how to use language AND tech to convey messages. Sometimes subtle, sometimes not!
#teachwriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:40 PM EDT
Right. Not just for testing. For thinking about agency/action in a sent. Who does what? To whom? Grammar = rhetorical choices.
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @lisahughes196
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:41 PM EDT
Not just "these days." Standard English has been a social marker for some time.
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:34 PM EDT
I think it's a social or class marker these days. Grammar = education. Back to the "snob" thing you mentioned.
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:41 PM EDT
May 23. Can probably get it for written reviews only. Will check.
#teachwriting
In reply to @TheJulieSouth, @lisahughes196, @bnjmn_k_wdcck, @mslizkrause, @hickstro
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:41 PM EDT
I would love for my Ss to know/use whom but society, in general, has no clue about the usage. Sad.
#Teachwriting
In reply to @hickstro, @lisahughes196
bnjmn_k_wdcck
Apr 18 @ 9:41 PM EDT
A4a: I always introduce formal/informal writing with lessons/review on audience, colloquialism, and vernacular.
#TeachWriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:41 PM EDT
To me, this is the dif b/n teaching about sub/obj or active/passive construction and, instead, teaching critical literacy.
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @lisahughes196
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:42 PM EDT
In an online world, where other social markers are not as visible, it takes on even more weight, IMO.
#teachwriting
In reply to @TeachMoore
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:42 PM EDT
#teachwriting
scottmpetri
Apr 18 @ 9:42 PM EDT
Yep. 1 of my 11th gr Ss loved this by
@Nina_Willner
& got her older sis to read it
https://t.co/q5d6yxfVdk
#teachwriting
In reply to @TeachMoore, @Nina_Willner
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:42 PM EDT
A4a I think this comes down to audience. If we spend time examining our audience, we are led toward a certain type of language
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:42 PM EDT
A4: I think we need to consider that distinction first, then address the grammar. Ss need to write and want to write more
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:42 PM EDT
A4a - Personal examples. A speech at a funeral or a wedding, a joke with friends, talking to your kids, etc. . .
#teachwriting
ball_jacquelyn
Apr 18 @ 9:43 PM EDT
Haven't tweeted in ages - I will mess this up
#oldie
#teachwriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:43 PM EDT
For instance: "According to So & So from the government, the village was attacked." Who is the actor in this sent? It's hidden
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @lisahughes196
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:43 PM EDT
A4b: once they have the desire, not b/c T says so, we can polish and focus on the grammar
#teachwriting
KayBReynolds
Apr 18 @ 9:43 PM EDT
A3 my responsibility if I only talk about grammar in punitive terms associated w/grading writing or on standardized tests
#TeachWriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:43 PM EDT
A4 The use of strong mentor text is a viable way to teach the nuances between formal and informal writing
#teachWriting
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:43 PM EDT
Not necessarily totally obsolete in the hands of a highly accomplished teacher; just have to know how to use it sparingly.
#teachwriting
askaouris
Apr 18 @ 9:37 PM EDT
Old grammar books are obsolete. New methods needed. Focused on patterns, models, real writing.
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @lisahughes196
SeanRuday
Apr 18 @ 9:43 PM EDT
A4a I talk about audience, purpose, and language expectation. Also, look at linguistic varieties as tools for characterization
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:44 PM EDT
A4a - Having to give someone really bad news. Something serious. How would you want to say it?
#teachwriting
askaouris
Apr 18 @ 9:44 PM EDT
A4: Opportunities to write in many forms, open conversations about audience and voice. And repeat.
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:44 PM EDT
Here is a social media template that I use with my Ss to help Differentiate formal & informal writing
https://t.co/MiV6gjO9Ow
#teachwriting
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:44 PM EDT
Hmmm, this is worth consideration.
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:39 PM EDT
A3 - Perhaps grammar is being inflected by locality, the way speech is, like a kind of "accent"? Discourse communities?
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:44 PM EDT
Teaching grammar through games!
https://t.co/eSDM6869Kz
#TeachWriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:44 PM EDT
A4a - Writing - or saying - an apology to someone you care about. How should you sound? What should you say?
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:45 PM EDT
A4: the social media template is discussed in our book, but I can explain more later if you are interested.
#teachwriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:45 PM EDT
Or "According to So&So, 'We attacked the village.'" Or "The village was attacked by us." Words and the position of them matter
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @lisahughes196
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:45 PM EDT
A4: I use my own published writing as models. Have examples of both kinds, & talk about audiences.
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:40 PM EDT
Q4a: What can we do specifically do to help Ss understand the difference between formal & informal writing?
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:45 PM EDT
You should get in your cah and come visit Rhode Island for some chowda
@bkuhl2you
#Teachwriting
In reply to @TeachMoore, @bkuhl2you
complikatyed
Apr 18 @ 9:45 PM EDT
“
@hickstro
: Students get blamed for having 'bad grammar,'when in fact they're code-switching across media/genre.
#teachwriting
” YES, THIS!
In reply to @hickstro
bnjmn_k_wdcck
Apr 18 @ 9:45 PM EDT
And/or how to incorporate the skills/rules into a text or content or to address a common issue amongst S writing.
#TeachWriting
In reply to @TeachMoore
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:45 PM EDT
But Ss understand the general idea and do not want to dissect the grammar.
#teachwriting
In reply to @hickstro, @lisahughes196
pedagogilist
Apr 18 @ 9:45 PM EDT
I obsess abt giving fdbk. I dnt give my Ss any assn I can't give fdbk on & I can't assign too much writing or else whts the pt
#teachwriting
bnjmn_k_wdcck
Apr 18 @ 9:40 PM EDT
I wish more Ts accepted this fact and encouraged their Ss to write, write, write, (right?!) in their content areas.
#TeachWriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:35 PM EDT
Students need to collaborate and write across genres, content areas, and tasks! Writing isn't just for English class!
#TeachWriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:46 PM EDT
Hope that makes some amount of sense... in Twitter-sized bites.
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @lisahughes196
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:46 PM EDT
Specific, positive feedback is one of the most important factors in growing the writer!
#teachwriting
In reply to @pedagogilist
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:46 PM EDT
It happens. Sometimes feedback can be just a conversation.
#teachwriting
In reply to @pedagogilist
katiablaskovich
Apr 18 @ 9:46 PM EDT
Q4. Mentor text analysis. Notice at text, sentence & word level how outstanding writing (formal/informal) conforms/ innovates
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:47 PM EDT
I like the scene from the play WIT, where she's dissecting John Donne's comma usage. . .
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @hickstro, @lisahughes196
pedagogilist
Apr 18 @ 9:47 PM EDT
I want my kids (3rd graders) to write but I want to guide their writing. Writing just for writing's sake dsnt really happen
#teachwriting
scottmpetri
Apr 18 @ 9:47 PM EDT
A4a Immediate direct instruction w/ examples of how you can fix weak writing.
https://t.co/F9bNvVj6Ku
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:48 PM EDT
Question 5 is hot and ready. It's coming at ya fast.
#teachwriting
KayBReynolds
Apr 18 @ 9:48 PM EDT
A4 it's about teaching code switching like was posted earlier
#TeachWriting
bnjmn_k_wdcck
Apr 18 @ 9:48 PM EDT
I need to give more feedback rather than pts. Bracing for the culture change. Any advice.
#TeachWriting
In reply to @pedagogilist
ball_jacquelyn
Apr 18 @ 9:48 PM EDT
Ordered your book after MACUL - cam"t air
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:48 PM EDT
Analysis & close reading of the mentor text! What is that writer doing? How do they do it? Does the writing impact audience
#teachWriting
In reply to @katiablaskovich
bnjmn_k_wdcck
Apr 18 @ 9:49 PM EDT
How do you give structured and important feedback without overwhelming Ss and yourself?
#TeachWriting
In reply to @lisahughes196, @Lyricalswordz, @pedagogilist
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:49 PM EDT
Thank you for the support. We appreciate it!
#teachwriting
In reply to @ball_jacquelyn
complikatyed
Apr 18 @ 9:49 PM EDT
Coming in late on this
#TeachWriting
convo, but loving what you've said thusfar!
pedagogilist
Apr 18 @ 9:49 PM EDT
Conversing is a little out there w/ my Ss&their parents who want to SEE what I've been saying to get Ss to be better writers
#teachwriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:49 PM EDT
Have you used the template at all or
@padlet
?
#TeachWriting
In reply to @ball_jacquelyn, @padlet
mrnewell83
Apr 18 @ 9:49 PM EDT
Define "formal" and "informal" writing, plz
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:49 PM EDT
Q5: What are some strategies that you use in your classroom where Ss better understand grammar skills?
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:50 PM EDT
I LOVE Padlet! Such a great tool for collaboration and teaching!
#teachwriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer, @ball_jacquelyn, @padlet
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:50 PM EDT
I compare grammar instruction to Mr. Keating convincing the boys about poetry in Dead Poets. Need Ss to buy in and then go
#teachwriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:50 PM EDT
Read "Teaching Adolescent Writers" by
@KellyGToGo
, then put his philosophy in your classroom! It will change your life!
#teachwriting
In reply to @bnjmn_k_wdcck, @pedagogilist, @KellyGToGo
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:50 PM EDT
Have you tried giving them Audio feedback?
#teachwriting
In reply to @bnjmn_k_wdcck, @lisahughes196, @Lyricalswordz, @pedagogilist
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:51 PM EDT
Great question - I tend to use analogies. "Fancy writing, like getting dressed up for a special dinner," etc.
#teachwriting
In reply to @mrnewell83
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:51 PM EDT
One of my favorite movies of all-time!
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX
SeanRuday
Apr 18 @ 9:52 PM EDT
A5: Have Ss analyze how and why an author uses certain grammatical concepts. Get them thinking about impact of those choices
#TeachWriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:52 PM EDT
A5: I often stop and ask why a sentence is written in such a way or why did I use a particular pronoun/gerund.
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:52 PM EDT
Formal is writing assignments, emails to teachers, letters, notes to a boss. Informal is texting a friend, Facebook, Twitter.
#teachwriting
In reply to @mrnewell83
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:52 PM EDT
I use Audacity. Free download, easy to use. Converst to MP3. Kids can listen to your feedback as many times as needed!
#teachwriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer, @bnjmn_k_wdcck, @lisahughes196, @pedagogilist
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:52 PM EDT
Of course! It's how boys should learn to woo women!!!
#teachwriting
In reply to @lisahughes196
KayBReynolds
Apr 18 @ 9:52 PM EDT
A5 lots of imitating. Workshop where writing happens daily whether graded or not & revision is common. Not wed to 1st drafts
#TeachWriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:52 PM EDT
A5 - Model and imitate. Find a great sentence - especially something funny - with a mid-level grammatical concept, and try it
#teachwriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:52 PM EDT
There are some tools you might be able to try using like this Online Sentence Diagrammer:
https://t.co/77wxCUHgZX
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @lisahughes196
SeanRuday
Apr 18 @ 9:52 PM EDT
A5 (cont.) For example, "Why does this author use this relative clause? What information is added?"
#TeachWriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:53 PM EDT
A5 Conferring with individual writers and whole class mini-lessons are effective tools!
#teachwriting
bnjmn_k_wdcck
Apr 18 @ 9:53 PM EDT
I have not attempted audio feedback, but am willing to try it!
#TeachWriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer, @lisahughes196, @Lyricalswordz, @pedagogilist
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:53 PM EDT
Wait, there's an online sentence diagrammer....who knew?
#teachwriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:52 PM EDT
There are some tools you might be able to try using like this Online Sentence Diagrammer:
https://t.co/77wxCUHgZX
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @lisahughes196
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:53 PM EDT
Narrow your focus. Research says less is more. Give specific, actionable feedback. Ss must interact with your feedback!
#teachwriting
In reply to @bnjmn_k_wdcck, @lisahughes196, @pedagogilist
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:53 PM EDT
Also, you could use easy concept-mapping tools like
@poppletny
to have students put words in and then do sent combining.
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @lisahughes196, @poppletny
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:53 PM EDT
But do Ts always follow same rules we ask our writers to follow. I don't.
#teachwriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer, @mrnewell83
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:53 PM EDT
Great tool. I use this as well.
#teachwriting
In reply to @Lyricalswordz, @bnjmn_k_wdcck, @lisahughes196, @pedagogilist
katiablaskovich
Apr 18 @ 9:53 PM EDT
Within a novel, have mix of formal, informal language for character/ narration. Ways sentences collapse articles/conjunction
#teachwriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:54 PM EDT
My online composition students love this; and my face-to-face (blended) classes do too.
#teachwriting
bnjmn_k_wdcck
Apr 18 @ 9:53 PM EDT
I have not attempted audio feedback, but am willing to try it!
#TeachWriting
In reply to @Jeremybballer, @lisahughes196, @Lyricalswordz, @pedagogilist
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:54 PM EDT
I've also used
@padlet
for this type of exercise:
https://t.co/e7LAqAQFyI
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @lisahughes196, @padlet
EduGladiators
Apr 18 @ 9:54 PM EDT
🔥
#EduGladiators
is BACK this SATURDAY! Is failure a choice? Don't miss this convo!
#txlchat
#TWOTCW
#teachwriting
#teachlikefinland
#tmchat
bnjmn_k_wdcck
Apr 18 @ 9:54 PM EDT
Thanks! I understand the feedback needs to be relevant and useful, too, otherwise what's the point?
#TeachWriting
In reply to @Lyricalswordz, @lisahughes196, @pedagogilist
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:55 PM EDT
Though boring, I still have hard copy Warriners text book at the ready!
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:55 PM EDT
I have Ss create videos using Vocabulary words in real world settings. Helps bring authenticity.
#teachwriting
bkuhl2you
Apr 18 @ 9:55 PM EDT
A5 - And catch and praise. Pull a kid's sentence, share with the class, and have them find their own examples.
#teachwriting
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:55 PM EDT
A5: Years ago there was a grammar curriculum developed by someone with ATEG/NCTE...it was called KISS. Am I dating myself?
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:55 PM EDT
Classkick or any collaborative whiteboard tool could work for grammar instruction, esp diagramming
#teachwriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:56 PM EDT
Here are the instructions for the
@padlet
activity with sentence combining
#teachwriting
In reply to @skeeTX, @lisahughes196, @padlet
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:56 PM EDT
Q6: What are some strategies that you use where you are using TECH to help Ss better understand grammar skills?
#teachwriting
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:56 PM EDT
I like to talk with each student about a positive then one thing to work on...typically I catch them in a conference
#teachwriting
In reply to @bnjmn_k_wdcck, @Lyricalswordz, @pedagogilist
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:56 PM EDT
I've made short videos w/ Adobe Spark for grammar lessons
#teachwriting
hickstro
Apr 18 @ 9:57 PM EDT
Yes! Have kids record screencasts as they revise. Invite them to talk about their moves as writers.
#teachwriting
skeeTX
Apr 18 @ 9:55 PM EDT
Classkick or any collaborative whiteboard tool could work for grammar instruction, esp diagramming
#teachwriting
bnjmn_k_wdcck
Apr 18 @ 9:57 PM EDT
Very happy I stumbled into the
#TeachWriting
chat tonight! Resources, community, and insight have been refreshing and inspiring!
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:57 PM EDT
One reference to Andrea Lunsford's work:
https://t.co/35z4AKe9d1
#teachwriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:57 PM EDT
I have some specific articles on my work computer. Will look for them tomorrow. But Kelly Gallagher is a great place to start
#teachwriting
In reply to @pedagogilist, @bnjmn_k_wdcck, @lisahughes196
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:57 PM EDT
Peer feedback is a powerful tool when cultivated and authentic in writing workshop...must build a community of trust
#teachwriting
In reply to @pedagogilist
complikatyed
Apr 18 @ 9:57 PM EDT
A5 - I used Google forms for practice, w. branching logic to give students feedback on their (multiple choice style) answers.
#teachwriting
TeachWriting2
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:58 PM EDT
Are you interested in leading a
#TeachWriting
chat? We could use some guest mods for our May chats - message
@lisahughes196
or
@bkuhl2you
!
TeachWriting2
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:58 PM EDT
Thanks so much for your time tonight - we appreciate your contributions and your attention!
#TeachWriting
TeachMoore
Apr 18 @ 9:58 PM EDT
A5: Anybody used the GrammarFlip website? Some of my older, non-trad students really like it for review.
#teachwriting
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:58 PM EDT
Please join us for the ATEG conference at CMU in MI this August. Join the grammar nerds
https://t.co/dvlQHr5Qf9
#teachwriting
bnjmn_k_wdcck
Apr 18 @ 9:58 PM EDT
@KellyGToGo
is the man! Have already adopted a lot of his beliefs into my classroom. Always open to more, so please share.
#TeachWriting
In reply to @Lyricalswordz, @pedagogilist, @lisahughes196, @KellyGToGo
complikatyed
Apr 18 @ 9:59 PM EDT
I'm feeling very much the same.
#teachwriting
is rocking my night!
In reply to @bnjmn_k_wdcck
TeachWriting2
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:59 PM EDT
You can read more about his books on Amazon or from the publisher here -
https://t.co/TZoImh9zT4
#TeachWriting
TeachWriting2
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:59 PM EDT
Thank you so much,
@Jeremybballer
- great job leading this conversation tonight! Make sure you check out his new book!
#TeachWriting
Lyricalswordz
Apr 18 @ 9:59 PM EDT
This is so important. We MUST set aside time to engage in conversations about writing with our students
#teachwriting
In reply to @lisahughes196, @bnjmn_k_wdcck, @pedagogilist
Jeremybballer
Apr 18 @ 9:59 PM EDT
Thanks
#teachwriting
and all of the participants. It was an honor to moderate. I appreciate my co-author joining in. May 23 is the date.
lisahughes196
- Moderator
Apr 18 @ 9:59 PM EDT
AWESOME job tonight
@Jeremybballer
AND can not wait for the book guys!
@hickstro
GREAT stuff!
#TeachWriting