Joining #edchatie to see if other people think there is too much tech in classrooms. I teach in 3rd level spaces, some filled with dual screens and others with VR goggles.
Welcome to tonight's #edchatie discussion. As usual, before we begin, please introduce yourself + don't forget to include the #edchatie hashtag in all tweets for the next hour so they can be collated later for the transcript.
#edchatie I don’t think there is too much of an emphasis on tech ... I think schools can be uninformed at times when it comes to it and as a result , decisions are made that are not conducive to effective tech use
Thanks so much - I was just testing it on my family - and reckoned no better crowd than the #edchatie folk. This is a nice bit of tech in the classroom. Great to allow all to engage. #Slido
So, let's begin this hour of #edchatie discussion on the topic of "Are we giving too much emphasis on technology in the classroom?"
What are your thoughts?
#edchatie Miriam PP Business tchr in Thurles. I think the use of ICT has to have purpose, achieve something that cannot be done without it, or add value for sts. found this link today... https://t.co/shjsVnm2A4 via DCU.
FREE #MegaDojo coding event for children and young people aged 7-17 in Limerick and Maynooth next Saturday December 2nd!
Sign up for fun workshops for beginners & those with experience: https://t.co/9mEQ7SvgUT
Digital Technology is explicitly mentioned in 5 of the 6 Key Skills on the new JC. I think this level of emphasis on a particular area is rather unprecedented. DT is not an option, it is a compulsion #edchatie
One thing that could chance is online payslips. Bad for the environment posting them out every two weeks. A personal page for each teacher with incremental dates etc... would cut down on queries @Education_Ire#edchatie
There is a lot of info about tech in schools and that often give off the impression that they are trying to shove tech down our necks but that’s not the case , there is recognition that we now live in an age where tech can help us not hinder us #edchatie
I wonder if most students fully understand how we’re trying to enhance their learning using tech, and if we’re properly including them in the decision to do so? We need to practice critical pedagogy and understand our authority. #edchatie
There's 8 Key Skills now (Literacy and Numeracy included). You can check them all out at https://t.co/BSj0ee2yEh#edchatie
I agree that "DT is not an option, it is a compulsion"
And the key skills go across all subjects and are part of the Learning Outcomes in each subject too - so great chances to incorporate digital as needed
#edchatie
Use tech to suit your own practice . Teachers compare themselves to others which should never be the case ..! #edchatie . It stops many from exploring its uses which really needs to stop ..!!
#EdChatie I'd be interested to know if any teachers are using social media in any way in their work? Or is you job more focussed on trying to get students to stay off social media and pay attention?
@fboss#edchatie 2 much empasis on traditional pedagogic approaches that dont reflect 21st C learner needs. More emphasis needed on the integration of teacher skills-TPACK. Harry Potter +multimodal iBook + individual spelling and comprehension dev. (Neologisms!)📱🧐📚🧙🏼♀️
Not enough emphasis on Digital Citizenship in Digital Strategy, this should underpin any learning through/about technology. We have a responsibility to teach students about privacy, their digital footprint, copyright, data permanence etc. #edchatie#dld_ucd
#edchatie Use google classroom to help sts record homework, add mindmaps, revision ques. Sharing and colloaboration between sts. Use of ICT to help sts which in turn helps the tchr. But not all students have a device which limits our progress.
One thing I learned from my tech mentor @susanleahy is that you use tech to suit you and your students . If anyone outsiders benefit then that’s a bonus #edchatie
#edchatie Technology is another literacy and shame on teachers who ignore it due their own shortcomings. We are living in a tech rich society and this is important stuff for them to know
#edchatie Lately, more tchrs in our school are using Twitter to share what is going on in their class, great for getting ideas, ICT and non ICT pedagogies. But one tchr said will it may lead to competition between Tchrs. I hope not, as sharing should help us all.
#edchatie as someone working in a developed one to one, strong makerspace focused school district. You will be amazed at what students can do on their own.
Does this mean that DT should supersede all other strategies? We would agree that DT has a role where it can be used efficiently, but should I retire my wooden abacus in favour of the online version? #edchatie
Very true - there is a need for planning before any introduction and after a lesson it also needs to be evaluated to see how tech did/n't help in the learning #edchatie
Empowering students by providing relevant and up to date assistive technology is central to inclusive education and effective tech integration #edchatie
We're at tonight's halfway point in the #edchatie discussion hour on "Are we giving too much emphasis on technology in the classroom?"
A lot of very good points being made. If you have any links to share too, please add them in
We have volunteers in limerick to teach digital literacy to older people as its almost unavoidable as banking is with machines/online, self service check outs, online only resources, etc. It's surely an everyday life skill? #EdChatie
I'm all for technology if used effectively e.g. Google Docs great for students collaborating when problem solving and can allow for scaffolding by teacher. However no use to students who don't have access to suitable devices from home. #edchatie
DT should only be used as a support I think and only where it improves efficency of learning & teaching. Teachers should be trusted to decide on this issue in their own class' context. #edchatie
#edchatie a competitive working environment would lead to less sharing and a work environment whereby one person tries to be better than someone else, so yes competitive is not beneficial if a whole school approach is needed and wellbeing of staff.
The integration does not in itself improve the teaching and learning. Well thought out lessons that integrate technology for the benefit of all parties does #edchatie
I believe a whole school approach of sharing & learning from each other must be fostered, without putting pressure on people to adopt ICT pedagogies until they are ready, adequate training &support provided, showing how correct use of ICT can help tchrs work practices #edchatie
Concerning the emphasis that students should all have eportfolio in Digital Strategy. Will this widen the gap between more affluent and those who don't have technology at home? Is tech industry influencing decisions here? #edchatie
#edchatie I know loads of #homeeconomics teachers using Twitter & Instagram - I use Twitter myself. Find it great for CDP & keeping up to date and would link to my edmodo page for those thst are interested
So important that we don't become over reliant on tech however-always telling my students that Quizlet does not replace sitting down and learning vocab! #edchatie
#edchatie in Albemarle Co. on day one of New Teacher Academy, you are told don't be afraid to fail. @pammoran tells a great story of her failing big time on her first day #culture#vision
@johnmayo was thinking of you other day, I think any school interviews should facilitate skype interviews for good tchrs who have emigrated to enable them to return.. #edchatie@ncca
In reply to
@johnmayo, @clareire, @johnmayo, @ncca
#edchatie biggest problem is none of my teachers with NCTE, lecturing in ST. Pat's or workling in #ACPS will put me any higher on pay scale. Will reenter at the level of a 28yr old and I am 43!!
Here are the current output screens from #Slido#edchatie
Four views - Admin View, Participant View, Present View and Show Fullscreen
I should have used a multiple choice type poll in this instance. Always learning
Silicon Valley employees sending their children to schools that have no tech? Tech insiders advocating disconnecting from internet? #edchatiehttps://t.co/TT7dmHpf1s
From what I see, the foyers of Irish banks have become touchscreen learning centres for many over the age of 60. To manage your pension, you need some of the skills your grandchildren should be learning in classrooms. #edchatie
#edchatie biggest problem is none of my teaching experience with NCTE, lecturing in ST. Pat's or workling in #ACPS will put me any higher on pay scale. Will reenter at the level of a 28yr old and I am 43!!
#edchatie Technology is another literacy and shame on teachers who ignore it due their own shortcomings. We are living in a tech rich society and this is important stuff for them to know
That article has been shot down numerous times, #edchatie it is more a case of kids getting better tech at home and better digital stimulation than at some schools
A very relevant & interesting article for tonight’s #edchatie conversation! "Personalized learning won't be a cure-all," he wrote.But Gates also said he's "hopeful that this approach could help many more young people make the most of their talents."
I believe we need to teach ICT in a meaningful way, as the digital divide exists, we prepare our sts for life, for some they dont have ICT or wifi at home, it is vital they gain access to valid use of ICT for life. #edchatie
And because collaboration via tech is baked into primary school children's minds from Snapchat and Facetime, I conduct exit interviews of 3rd level students to validate who actually knows how to solve the assessments. #edchatie
I'm trying to attack scarcity of ICT resources in homes by showing students how to use their scratched phones to complete many of the assignments they previously thought could be done only with keyboards. #edchatie
Have to hint at @johnmayo earlier point about failure. Sometimes feels like Irish teachers aren’t comfortable being critical/reflective practitioners that are willing or willing or encouraged to learn from failure. The culture needs to change. #edchatie
With the new specifications with @JCforTeachers . Encouraging digital literacy is more important than ever . Sometimes teaching the basics is more important than anything else #EdChatie
Have to hint at @johnmayo earlier point about failure. Sometimes feels like Irish teachers aren’t comfortable being critical/reflective practitioners that are willing or encouraged to learn from failure. The culture needs to change. #edchatie
Whilst completing the PME some student teachers on my course were reluctant to integrate technology into class on teaching placement as some inspectors didn't like it in classroom #edchatie
That's true! I'm just coming from primary where many children are great with tech from using it at home but may not be able to tie laces, cycle a bike, express themselves fully through speaking, etc #edchatie
I really enjoyed that + collaborative learning occurred (when the students took pity on me and talked me through some of the processes needed)
;-)
#edchatie
I'm raising a dyslexic 6yo who knows all the spoken shortcuts when asking Google and Alexa questions. He can get weather forecasts, playlists, and cinema schedules but can't read. #edchatie
We're (well) into the famous final five minutes of tonight's on "Are we giving too much emphasis on
technology in the classroom?" in the #edchatie discussion.
Any last thoughts, comments or solutions?
