#mnlead Archive
A Twitter chat for leaders and learners. Sunday evenings at 7:00 CT.
Sunday May 8, 2016
8:00 PM EDT
txeduchat
May 8 @ 8:00 PM EDT
We are one hour away from
#txeduchat
with
@Mann4Edu
on Personalized PD Hope you join us
#edchat
#mnlead
https://t.co/rtvE4Djwsg
PrincipalFrench
May 8 @ 8:01 PM EDT
Good evening, Mark here, elementary principal in MN. Blessings to all mothers.
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:02 PM EDT
@PrincipalFrench
Great to see you at
#mnlead
tonight,
@PrincipalFrench
!
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:02 PM EDT
For the next hour my tweets will be focused to friends on
#MNlead
Tonight's topic; Student Voice & Choice
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:02 PM EDT
@robert_schuetz
Always great to have you at
#mnlead
, sir!
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:03 PM EDT
Evening! Pattie Morales, 5th grade teacher in Milwaukee. Shout out to
@JackieC1989
for being a second mom and my rock.
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:03 PM EDT
Hey everyone! Thanks to
@msleevang
@abrownbyte
for leading us tonight.
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:03 PM EDT
Amy - elementary principal - I feel blessed to hold the title of mom!
#mnlead
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:03 PM EDT
Jenn Reichel, Dir of Teaching and Learning in Hastings. Happy to be here tonight!
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:04 PM EDT
@MoralesPattie
Great to have you with us at
#mnlead
, Pattie. It was great to meet you at
#edcamptc
!
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:04 PM EDT
Chris, MS Principal in Farmington. Happy Mother's Day Mom!
#mnlead
She's not on Twitter but if she was
@chris
'smom.
https://t.co/X1it0O1Iks
KalidKhalid1
May 8 @ 8:04 PM EDT
I guess this is only for an adults
#GeniusSquad
#mnlead
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:04 PM EDT
My name is Andre. I am currently a senior at
@washingtontech
Shout out to my mom who as been a teacher for over 20 years in SPPS!
#Mnlead
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:04 PM EDT
Hello Everyone! Bob, T/C
@PalatineHS
tweeting from Libertyville, IL where we just enjoyed one of the nicest days of the year!
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:04 PM EDT
Glad to see you both here tonight! Congrats, Mark on the new job!
#mnlead
@mahillmann
@PrincipalFrench
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:04 PM EDT
Kory, Innovations Teacher in Byron. In and out here at the beginning-have to get some groceries put away!
#mnlead
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:04 PM EDT
#mnlead
Intro: Please state your title, location & since it’s Mother’s Day, give a shout out to your mom or moms in general if you want!
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:04 PM EDT
Hey
#mnlead
er's. Check out tonight's questions here.
https://t.co/X4amRLC0VK
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:04 PM EDT
@millardamy2
Thanks for joining tonight, Amy! Looking forward to a great discussion about student voice & choice!
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:05 PM EDT
@JennReichel
Welcome, Jenn! Thanks for taking time to lend your expertise to
#mnlead
tonight!
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:05 PM EDT
Please state your title, location & since it’s Mother’s Day, give a shout out to your mom or moms in general if you want!
@mslee
#mnlead
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:05 PM EDT
My mom & I went fishing this morning. As usual, she had the catch of the day!
#mnlead
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:05 PM EDT
Evening Jen! Going to see you at the summer retreat?!?!?
#mnlead
https://t.co/ZjoWIHcMeZ
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:03 PM EDT
Jenn Reichel, Dir of Teaching and Learning in Hastings. Happy to be here tonight!
#mnlead
JoseRomero1399
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:06 PM EDT
Hello everyone I'm Jose, Junior
@Harding_Knights
and shout out to my mother for helping me though life
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:06 PM EDT
@korytellers
Good to have you with us, Kory. Make sure to get those perishables put away before diving into
#mnlead
!
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:06 PM EDT
Hi all. Bret, Elementary Principal living in Richfield, MN. Got to see two mothers today. Love them both dearly. Love my wife too!
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:06 PM EDT
@JoseRomero1399
Great to have you joining us, Jose! Thanks for sharing your time with
#mnlead
!
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:07 PM EDT
@mahillmann
Thank you Matt - glad to be here - you and others always make this flatlander feel welcome.
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:07 PM EDT
@KalidKhalid1
Bring on the ideas! All are welcome to
#mnlead
. We grow by learning together. Thanks for popping in Kalid.
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:07 PM EDT
@ABrownByte
Great to you have you with us at
#mnlead
, Andre. Thanks for taking some time on this beautiful Sunday to help us learn!
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:08 PM EDT
Ok lets get started with out first question! Q1: What does student voice and choice mean to you?
#mnlead
Remember the Q1=A1 format!
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:08 PM EDT
@robert_schuetz
@mahillmann
That's
#MinnesotaNice
;)
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:08 PM EDT
@JoseRomero1399
@Harding_Knights
Hi Jose, Thanks for moderating our
#mnlead
chat tonight! Great to have you.
kdgcallahan
May 8 @ 8:08 PM EDT
Amanda from St. LOUIS here. Kindergarten Educator and happy to be here. Much love to mom!
#mnlead
https://t.co/GBH8pUWDgK
PrasolovMisha
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:09 PM EDT
Hey everyone, I'm a senior at Highland Park and I'm hanging out in the park with my mom!
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:09 PM EDT
Q1: What does student voice and choice mean to you?
@ABrownByte
@mslee
#mnlead
PrincipalFrench
May 8 @ 8:09 PM EDT
A1) We seek input and feedback from students, incorporate that into our practices & let students guide their learning.
#mnlead
MrPChick
May 8 @ 8:09 PM EDT
Hello
#mnlead
, Paul, HS science T from PEM, MN. Happy Mother's Day to all moms. S/O to my mom & my wife, mother of our 3 awesome boys.
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:09 PM EDT
@kdgcallahan
Welcome to
#mnlead
!
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:09 PM EDT
A1 When I hear S voice & choice I think about agency, empowerment, "Lifeworthy" learning, authenticity -> self-determined learning
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:10 PM EDT
@PrasolovMisha
Hey Misha! Thanks for taking the reigns tonight on
#mnlead
. Glad to have you.
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:10 PM EDT
@PrasolovMisha
Great to have you taking some time to join us at
#mnlead
! Thanks for helping us become better educators!
GetAlma
May 8 @ 8:10 PM EDT
The time is now-
@GetAlma
today to start next school year off on the right foot!
https://t.co/tMkGqkaPQY
#edchatri
#mnlead
#wischat
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:10 PM EDT
A1: What He Said...BAM.
#mnlead
https://t.co/SrGdGjOf58
PrincipalFrench
May 8 @ 8:09 PM EDT
A1) We seek input and feedback from students, incorporate that into our practices & let students guide their learning.
#mnlead
kdgcallahan
May 8 @ 8:10 PM EDT
A1:Acknowledging students differences to make them feel comfortable using their voice and making their own choices
#mnlead
Clouducation_
May 8 @ 8:10 PM EDT
Tony peeking in from Rogers, Mn. Dig. Lrng Speclst. SO to my bride for playing zone defense in parenting with me for over a decade.
#mnlead
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:10 PM EDT
A1. Empowering voice and choice puts students in the drivers seat... Right where they need to be to make meaning of their learning.
#mnlead
dayankee
May 8 @ 8:10 PM EDT
A1 Students find that they have something to contribute to the common good and choose their path to do so!
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:11 PM EDT
A1) student voice = Ss ideas and input. Student choice = flexible seating, project/assessment options, etc. but still more T led
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:11 PM EDT
A1 It means giving a REAL say in what learning looks like. Less compliance to strict learning rules. Show me what you know and learn
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:11 PM EDT
A1 I really think that Ss voice and choice should be so natural in the classroom, that it should be present from day 1.
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:12 PM EDT
A1 Providing a variety of ways for students to engage in content & demonstrate their knowledge.
#mnlead
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:12 PM EDT
@korytellers
How do Ts make student voice and choice a natural, embedded part of their classrooms?
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:12 PM EDT
A1 It's hard for me to not imagine Ss having voice and choice in their classrooms.
#mnlead
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:12 PM EDT
A1.1 Letting go & giving Ss means taking time for personalized feedback, & acknowledging that stumbles are 1st steps in learning
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:12 PM EDT
A1 Give S's a chance to share feedback, design spaces, reflect on what works and what needs to change, ie flexibility yet keep rigor
#mnlead
Clouducation_
May 8 @ 8:12 PM EDT
A1. Actually voice & choice are different, but represent the right & left hand of student-centered learning. Students drive learning.
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:13 PM EDT
@msleevang
This is hard for me to answer because I honestly feel like I have always given them this, I don't know any different.
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:13 PM EDT
This is really evident at the elementary level with the
@responsiveclass
approach, isn’t it?
#mnlead
https://t.co/ly4jU3DicL
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:11 PM EDT
A1 I really think that Ss voice and choice should be so natural in the classroom, that it should be present from day 1.
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:13 PM EDT
A1-Do Ss feel a part of their learning-do they have a voice in the classroom when it comes to what they learn and how they learn it.
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:13 PM EDT
Just do it.
#mnlead
https://t.co/NyY6CZHPzb
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:12 PM EDT
@korytellers
How do Ts make student voice and choice a natural, embedded part of their classrooms?
#mnlead
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:13 PM EDT
A1.2: Asking students the right questions so they make decisions about their learning. You can pull out the roadmap if you have to.
#mnlead
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:13 PM EDT
gonna Repost the all the questions here:
https://t.co/XdAxUmqpxz
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:13 PM EDT
@dayankee
Yes! It has to matter. If that contribution means something then I will do it again.
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:14 PM EDT
Ah. I was thinking of them as separate entities. This makes much more sense!
#mnlead
https://t.co/WVBVblrD4d
PrincipalFrench
May 8 @ 8:09 PM EDT
A1) We seek input and feedback from students, incorporate that into our practices & let students guide their learning.
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:14 PM EDT
@mahillmann
@responsiveclass
Yes! I'm sure that's why it's hard for me to understand how this doesn't always happen. LOVE RC.
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:14 PM EDT
Excellent distinction, Dr. VB. Voice can inform, but not required, for choice. Better to have both.
#mnlead
https://t.co/IJIfurvgX2
Clouducation_
May 8 @ 8:12 PM EDT
A1. Actually voice & choice are different, but represent the right & left hand of student-centered learning. Students drive learning.
#mnlead
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:14 PM EDT
@chris_bussmann
This, & coaching Ss in creating their own "beautiful" questions - set the table - get out of the way!
#mnlead
Clouducation_
May 8 @ 8:14 PM EDT
A1 These should be woven into the fabric of education. Secondary lacks greatly in this area, especially HS.
#mnlead
MarkJWestpfahl
May 8 @ 8:15 PM EDT
A 1
#mnlead
. Create assessments in which students have options to showcase their knowledge.
https://t.co/pyi9y8dsKj
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:09 PM EDT
Q1: What does student voice and choice mean to you?
@ABrownByte
@mslee
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:15 PM EDT
@Clouducation_
I am shouting. :) WHY IS THAT? What happens between K and 8th grade?!?!?!?
#mnlead
smithdianemarie
May 8 @ 8:15 PM EDT
@msleevang
@korytellers
One way to start is: observe a T who often does this to see concrete examples & the difference it can make?
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:16 PM EDT
Finding this balance between support and empowering students to take the lead...
#mnlead
https://t.co/HEPLCbaA4m
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:13 PM EDT
A1.2: Asking students the right questions so they make decisions about their learning. You can pull out the roadmap if you have to.
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:16 PM EDT
@korytellers
@mahillmann
Morning meeting, making anchor charts together, reflecting after a lesson...All make S's valued& empowered.
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:16 PM EDT
@korytellers
...Another thing we have in common…RC groupies!
#mnlead
https://t.co/STfbjeRPib
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:14 PM EDT
@mahillmann
@responsiveclass
Yes! I'm sure that's why it's hard for me to understand how this doesn't always happen. LOVE RC.
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:16 PM EDT
Agreed!
#mnlead
https://t.co/BtYWS9xsYU
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:16 PM EDT
@korytellers
@mahillmann
Morning meeting, making anchor charts together, reflecting after a lesson...All make S's valued& empowered.
#mnlead
MarkJWestpfahl
May 8 @ 8:16 PM EDT
A 1
#mnlead
cont. I'll be startng a travel unit w/my
#MNstudies
Ss tomorrow. They have freedom in where it goes
@bretdom
@ABrownByte
@MsLee
Clouducation_
May 8 @ 8:16 PM EDT
A1. Also a challenge to make these authentic. Choosing between worksheets and bookwork is not authentic choice.
#mnlead
smithdianemarie
May 8 @ 8:16 PM EDT
A1:
#stuvoice
gives students opportunities to make choices and develop key life skills!
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:17 PM EDT
@bretdom
@korytellers
And the ‘hopes and dreams’ process helps Ts understand S needs & can fuel voice & choice!
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:17 PM EDT
@mahillmann
I wish more schools would see the value in adapting RC beliefs into their school environments. SO worth it!
#mnlead
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:17 PM EDT
Right on. So many Ss aren't given opportunities in their home lives to have voice that it isn't natural.
#mnlead
https://t.co/byuqHaDDEF
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:16 PM EDT
Finding this balance between support and empowering students to take the lead...
#mnlead
https://t.co/HEPLCbaA4m
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:13 PM EDT
A1.2: Asking students the right questions so they make decisions about their learning. You can pull out the roadmap if you have to.
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:17 PM EDT
@ABrownByte
What would your optimal
#voiceandchoice
be?
@JoseRomero1399
@PrasolovMisha
#mnlead
dayankee
May 8 @ 8:17 PM EDT
Our kiddos do 20% Time projects. They blog the entire year about them. They each find their voice and share their learning.
#mnlead
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:18 PM EDT
@korytellers
@Clouducation_
Other agenda become prioritized. Engagement & satisfaction declines over time -> relevance gap
#mnlead
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:18 PM EDT
Literally just witnessed this spinout while I am sitting here in
#mnlead
! Yikes!!
https://t.co/nTtfiGXUCh
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:18 PM EDT
@korytellers
Yes, it is. Intentionally teaching social/emotional strategies, logical consequences, & academic choice. Good stuff!
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:18 PM EDT
Do Ss truly feel like their voice is a valuable part of the room-do Ss feel respected-both are vital.
#mnlead
https://t.co/vttVuakpj4
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:16 PM EDT
Agreed!
#mnlead
https://t.co/BtYWS9xsYU
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:16 PM EDT
@korytellers
@mahillmann
Morning meeting, making anchor charts together, reflecting after a lesson...All make S's valued& empowered.
#mnlead
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:18 PM EDT
Can they travel to Chuck E Cheese? :)
#mnlead
https://t.co/AQBU3jut1i
MarkJWestpfahl
May 8 @ 8:16 PM EDT
A 1
#mnlead
cont. I'll be startng a travel unit w/my
#MNstudies
Ss tomorrow. They have freedom in where it goes
@bretdom
@ABrownByte
@MsLee
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:18 PM EDT
@korytellers
And I love all of the songs!
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:18 PM EDT
@mahillmann
@bretdom
This is long-9 minutes, but the school where we did RC. Just all sorts of awesome.
https://t.co/owUtYK2opM
#mnlead
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:19 PM EDT
@dayankee
How do you find time? This seems to be a constant issue for Ts trying to offer more engaging options for students
#mnlead
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:19 PM EDT
A1.2 My long form explanation of "relevancy gap";
https://t.co/2QONah1bvh
#mnlead
MarkJWestpfahl
May 8 @ 8:19 PM EDT
Yes
@chris_bussmann
! They "travel" Minnesota for 5 days, but they pick places to eat, stay, etc.
#mnlead
A1
@bretdom
@ABrownByte
@MsLee
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:19 PM EDT
#mnlead
I love open ended projects! I feel like when there are a lot rules and to follow it gives similar projects
https://t.co/jFAMnFBDqP
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:17 PM EDT
@ABrownByte
What would your optimal
#voiceandchoice
be?
@JoseRomero1399
@PrasolovMisha
#mnlead
smithdianemarie
May 8 @ 8:19 PM EDT
@Clouducation_
Yes! Choice should be choosing different way of proving knowledge-not just different sources of same type problems.
#mnlead
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:20 PM EDT
If we want creative problem-solving adults, we need to provide authentic opportunities for Ss to try!
#mnlead
https://t.co/nCb0jWjLwS
dayankee
May 8 @ 8:17 PM EDT
Our kiddos do 20% Time projects. They blog the entire year about them. They each find their voice and share their learning.
#mnlead
dayankee
May 8 @ 8:20 PM EDT
@msleevang
I give up one social studies class per week for kids to do their 20% Time work. That's a non-negotiable. I make it work
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:20 PM EDT
@msleevang
Oh my! A Corvette? Now I get the spinout. Summer is here...
#mnlead
dayankee
May 8 @ 8:21 PM EDT
Our 20% Time (Genius Hour) book Cultivating Genius tells how and why. Game changer!
https://t.co/egNGNAwX8e
#mnlead
https://t.co/6cwNYzmLNK
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:21 PM EDT
That's fantastic! What a great experience
#mnlead
https://t.co/WWgm9GUK8d
MarkJWestpfahl
May 8 @ 8:19 PM EDT
Yes
@chris_bussmann
! They "travel" Minnesota for 5 days, but they pick places to eat, stay, etc.
#mnlead
A1
@bretdom
@ABrownByte
@MsLee
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:21 PM EDT
@Clouducation_
I really do believe that if we could change that, we'd solve a lot of problems.
#mnlead
PrasolovMisha
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:21 PM EDT
@bretdom
For me it's important that Ts don't put voice/choice just for the sake of doing it, make it genuine!
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:21 PM EDT
Is there an economics tie, too? Do they have a budget?
#mnlead
https://t.co/LY42yVDqC8
MarkJWestpfahl
May 8 @ 8:19 PM EDT
Yes
@chris_bussmann
! They "travel" Minnesota for 5 days, but they pick places to eat, stay, etc.
#mnlead
A1
@bretdom
@ABrownByte
@MsLee
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:21 PM EDT
Ok Question 2! Q2: What is more important - student voice or student choice? Why?
#mnlead
dayankee
May 8 @ 8:21 PM EDT
@JennReichel
That's exactly right. It is the most important work they will do and will best prepare them for THEIR future!
#mnlead
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:21 PM EDT
@bretdom
AND he took off running?!?! Like really?!? That house has kids :( Nobody hurt thnkfully
#mnlead
#multitasking
#summerishere
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:22 PM EDT
Straight from a student. Open-ended projects! If there are rules, projects come out looking the same. Nice!
#mnlead
https://t.co/mGyIijDh6o
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:19 PM EDT
#mnlead
I love open ended projects! I feel like when there are a lot rules and to follow it gives similar projects
https://t.co/jFAMnFBDqP
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:17 PM EDT
@ABrownByte
What would your optimal
#voiceandchoice
be?
@JoseRomero1399
@PrasolovMisha
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:23 PM EDT
@Clouducation_
For some Ss, traditional means is their best modality. Shouldn't eliminate some choices in the name of providing it.
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:23 PM EDT
Give students opportunities to take the lead.
#gotthatright
#mnlead
https://t.co/HMpnQt4o0V
JoseRomero1399
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:21 PM EDT
@bretdom
@ABrownByte
@PrasolovMisha
I like the idea of giving students opportunities in taking the lead or have a choice in how they learn.
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:23 PM EDT
@bretdom
Projects should be a contribution to, & an expression of learning - not a recipe.
#mnlead
MarkJWestpfahl
May 8 @ 8:23 PM EDT
Certainly
@MoralesPattie
! They receive a budget & have to contact business too.
#mnlead
@chris_bussmann
@bretdom
@ABrownByte
@MsLee
Clouducation_
May 8 @ 8:24 PM EDT
A2. Voice. Not always able to give many choices, but voice, if even freedom of expression, still builds relationships and trust.
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:24 PM EDT
Keep
#studentvoice
real. Don't do it for the show. Be authentic and genuine.
#keepitreal
#mnlead
https://t.co/mDZ2dSw1Jf
PrasolovMisha
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:21 PM EDT
@bretdom
For me it's important that Ts don't put voice/choice just for the sake of doing it, make it genuine!
#mnlead
JK_McMahon
May 8 @ 8:24 PM EDT
A2: I say student voice. If Ss have voice, they can request choice from teachers.
#mnlead
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:24 PM EDT
Reposting the question! Q2: What is more important - student voice or student choice? Why?
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:25 PM EDT
A2 Choice is the ‘basic’ level, but still T driven. Better than not having it. Voice is the ‘level up’ b/c choice is inherent.
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:25 PM EDT
A2) Ss voice. It's what Ss choice is built on!
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:25 PM EDT
Q2: What is more important - student voice or student choice? Why?
#mnlead
@abro
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:25 PM EDT
Voice....relationships are vital and Ss need to feel valued. Compliance is not part of this equation...
#mnlead
SteeleThoughts
May 8 @ 8:25 PM EDT
A1: Students and their ideas have inherent dignity.
#mnlead
JK_McMahon
May 8 @ 8:26 PM EDT
Jessica McMahon, Digital Learning Specialist for Prior Lake-Savage. Checking in on our way home from my MIL's.
#mnlead
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:26 PM EDT
A2. Voice! Giving meaningful choice must mean that we've listened to our students, right?
#mnlead
smithdianemarie
May 8 @ 8:26 PM EDT
#mnlead
A2: I think it's through choices, experiments, & getting access to interests that students can develop a voice.No choice no voice.
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:26 PM EDT
A2 I think Voice. Voice helps build relationships, develop trust, create the bonds where Ss can feel they are in safe place to learn
#mnlead
SteeleThoughts
May 8 @ 8:26 PM EDT
A1: Students are always more engaged in activities that they have choice in.
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:27 PM EDT
A2 Can I say both? It depends on the moment. Voice matters b/c if it's not valued, what's the point in saying or producing anything?
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:27 PM EDT
This sentence has both immense power and simplicity. Well done,
@steelethoughts
!
#mnlead
https://t.co/KH6rAMaYqu
SteeleThoughts
May 8 @ 8:25 PM EDT
A1: Students and their ideas have inherent dignity.
#mnlead
MarkJWestpfahl
May 8 @ 8:27 PM EDT
A2
#mnlead
. Tough, because some kids need one more than another, & both can be displayed in different ways.
https://t.co/sGR6OxEAyV
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:25 PM EDT
Q2: What is more important - student voice or student choice? Why?
#mnlead
@abro
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:27 PM EDT
I agree, but if choice is based on Ss voice, then it isn't basic anymore. It's a chicken and egg situation!
#mnlead
https://t.co/pUG3OX5Jgm
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:25 PM EDT
A2 Choice is the ‘basic’ level, but still T driven. Better than not having it. Voice is the ‘level up’ b/c choice is inherent.
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:27 PM EDT
@JK_McMahon
Waving Hi! :)
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:28 PM EDT
A2 Choice matters b/c if I don't care about it and my opinion doesn't matter, I'll give you minimum effort to get the grade I need.
#mnlead
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:28 PM EDT
Ss voice is a foundational need that will transform learning but sometimes choice is how voices are amplified & relationships built
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:28 PM EDT
Absolutely! Without this...we will not see the growth that our Ss are capable of!
#mnlead
https://t.co/vRxVR35spA
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:26 PM EDT
A2 I think Voice. Voice helps build relationships, develop trust, create the bonds where Ss can feel they are in safe place to learn
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:28 PM EDT
@MoralesPattie
Agree, Pattie. That was what I was trying to articulate!
#mnlead
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:28 PM EDT
@bretdom
I was thinking the same thing. I don't think it's fair to offer one without the other Voice & Choice, like peas & carrots!
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:29 PM EDT
@SteeleThoughts
we practice this idea all the time. Everyone is deserving of dignity and respect, and so are their ideas.
#mnlead
KarinHogen
May 8 @ 8:29 PM EDT
Karin joining late. Just had to finish my book.
#mnlead
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:29 PM EDT
A2: They are pretty interconnected. Choice is what you put on the grill. Voice is how you season and cook it.
#mnlead
KalidKhalid1
May 8 @ 8:29 PM EDT
A2 Student Choice Leads to Student Voice
#voiceandchoice
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:29 PM EDT
People support what they help create- investment and motivation are huge....
#mnlead
https://t.co/DbgnuYFOnc
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:28 PM EDT
A2 Choice matters b/c if I don't care about it and my opinion doesn't matter, I'll give you minimum effort to get the grade I need.
#mnlead
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:29 PM EDT
A2: I think that Student voice will inevitably turn into student choice in the right classroom setting
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:30 PM EDT
@mahillmann
I'd say "great minds," but I'm not quite in your category yet!
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:30 PM EDT
Boom! Well said!
#mnlead
https://t.co/UOhXelaUNz
KalidKhalid1
May 8 @ 8:29 PM EDT
A2 Student Choice Leads to Student Voice
#voiceandchoice
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:30 PM EDT
How about we use the example "Cake and Ice Cream" instead? ;)
#mnlead
https://t.co/EqWFXCnWAw
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:28 PM EDT
@bretdom
I was thinking the same thing. I don't think it's fair to offer one without the other Voice & Choice, like peas & carrots!
#mnlead
SteeleThoughts
May 8 @ 8:30 PM EDT
A2: It can't be either or. What is paramount is that students feel respected and valued in the learning process.
#mnlead
KarinHogen
May 8 @ 8:30 PM EDT
A2: sad how sometimes Ss seem used to not having either and are surprised when I listen to them and give them choices. 😢
#mnlead
JoseRomero1399
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:30 PM EDT
love everyone's responses now lets hear some answers on Q3: How are students given voice and choice in your classroom/school?
#Mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:30 PM EDT
@MoralesPattie
You are already beyond it! I love the growth mindset, though!
#mnlead
JK_McMahon
May 8 @ 8:31 PM EDT
I do like the idea of choice helping Ss develop their voice. Especially younger kids and some with special needs.
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:31 PM EDT
A2 If I had to choose? Voice. I need to know my work makes a difference to the classroom, community, etc.
#WOW
#WorthyoftheWorld
#mnlead
TheAshleyWarren
May 8 @ 8:31 PM EDT
A2: Voice!! Focusing on voice means student ideas are being heard, means collaboration w/ Ts & Ss is happening...creates culture!!
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:31 PM EDT
Absolutely...not always necessary to "label" everything. Valued and respected Ss will learn and grow!
#mnlead
https://t.co/Q8DvgsiDtn
SteeleThoughts
May 8 @ 8:30 PM EDT
A2: It can't be either or. What is paramount is that students feel respected and valued in the learning process.
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:31 PM EDT
This is what needs to change!Need to make sure that by the time they get to Karin they are SO used to choice
#mnlead
https://t.co/0TUz32eiIW
KarinHogen
May 8 @ 8:30 PM EDT
A2: sad how sometimes Ss seem used to not having either and are surprised when I listen to them and give them choices. 😢
#mnlead
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:32 PM EDT
Q3: How are students given voice and choice in you classroom/school?
#mnlead
https://t.co/Lo58pwsCnE
JoseRomero1399
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:30 PM EDT
love everyone's responses now lets hear some answers on Q3: How are students given voice and choice in your classroom/school?
#Mnlead
Supt_Jordan
May 8 @ 8:32 PM EDT
A2: Student Voice often leads to Student Choice in a classroom that prioritizes individuality in learning.
#mnlead
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:32 PM EDT
A2.1: Voice necessitates the need for an on-going conversation.
#mnlead
KarinHogen
May 8 @ 8:32 PM EDT
A3: as an IB school, Ss are given voice and choice with the service learning projects they do throughout the year
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:32 PM EDT
Q3: How are students given voice and choice in you classroom/school?
#mnlead
@JoseRomero1399
@abrownb
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:32 PM EDT
A3 In my new position I am learning to sit back and wait for them to come to me with questions. I try not to talk "at" them too long
#mnlead
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:33 PM EDT
Meat & potatoes, peanut butter & jelly, eggs & bacon... OK, cake & ice cream works!
#mnlead
smithdianemarie
May 8 @ 8:33 PM EDT
#mnlead
A2: If Ss don't have choices, then the T's voice becomes the S's voice? Ss don't get a chance to find what matters/works for them.
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:33 PM EDT
Absolutely! Which means teachers need to create an environment where students feel like they have a voice!
#mnlead
https://t.co/CtxDpXSxBg
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:29 PM EDT
A2: I think that Student voice will inevitably turn into student choice in the right classroom setting
#mnlead
calliembush
May 8 @ 8:33 PM EDT
A3: I use self-paced, flexible space & options for demonstrating understanding/learning. I welcome Ss input & feedback.
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:34 PM EDT
A3 In
#nfldedu
, we have several ways that S voice is amplified. Examples:
https://t.co/ok6wsNMhaO
&
https://t.co/Z5tpU1wudN
.
#mnlead
SteeleThoughts
May 8 @ 8:34 PM EDT
A3: Students asked me for a talent show so we're having a talent show in a couple weeks. When Ss feel heard, they have ownership.
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:34 PM EDT
A3 I support this by tweeting, FB, parent communications, etc, sharing student work w our community. S's love knowing ppl saw it.
#mnlead
KarinHogen
May 8 @ 8:35 PM EDT
A3: I try to give authentic choice as much as possible to my Ss. Wish it was more. I'm controlled by curriculum constraints.
#mnlead
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:35 PM EDT
A3: We offer 20 elective options at our MS. Our Tiger Connections puts Ss in charge of planning activities for their peers.
#mnlead
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:35 PM EDT
A3. By empowering T voice & choice in district committees, I hope I'm modeling this as a process for those Ts who want to do more.
#mnlead
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:35 PM EDT
A3 As someone else said, giving choice 2 projects, problems 2 solve, as well as, options 4 sharing. Publish for authentic audience
#mnlead
JoseRomero1399
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:36 PM EDT
In the IB program, getting students to develop their passions and skills in learning with the IB learner profile definitely helps me
#Mnlead
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:36 PM EDT
Ss are always invited to contribute in meaningful, authentic ways like co-hosting a
#mnlead
twitter chat session!
https://t.co/kCVPF0doXg
JoseRomero1399
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:30 PM EDT
love everyone's responses now lets hear some answers on Q3: How are students given voice and choice in your classroom/school?
#Mnlead
Supt_Jordan
May 8 @ 8:36 PM EDT
A3: Allow students voice on board teams, improvement teams, etc.
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:36 PM EDT
A3) flexible seating, genius hour, class votes on monthly project topics, project choice, circle talks, hoping to do more next yr
#mnlead
MarkJWestpfahl
May 8 @ 8:36 PM EDT
A4
#mnlead
. In my
#WWII
, Ss will get to choose a 3 day mini-unit w/in the unit. Easy to cover more & excite kids.
https://t.co/WcvJwJA52Q
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:32 PM EDT
Q3: How are students given voice and choice in you classroom/school?
#mnlead
@JoseRomero1399
@abrownb
kdgcallahan
May 8 @ 8:37 PM EDT
A2: Without student voice there would be no stu choice. They are of equal importance to me
#mnlead
LauraGWillis
May 8 @ 8:37 PM EDT
A3: We have online talent shows each month. Ss have done time lapsed drawings, iMovies, rubik's cube, music, origami, math tricks.
#mnlead
JK_McMahon
May 8 @ 8:38 PM EDT
A3: I'm working hard to help teacher voice be heard and respected so they can empower their students.
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:38 PM EDT
A3) 2 - our Middle schoolers have mid-day options where they pick an activity for right before lunch
#mnlead
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:38 PM EDT
A3.1 I've seen powerful engagement & growth through class blogs, discussion boards, & portfolio sharing
#MNlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:38 PM EDT
A3 I like seeing classrooms in which the Ss developed the classroom rules…a great building block for S voice on a broader scale.
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:38 PM EDT
A3 The Ss know that I tweet out a lot using our
@InnovativeBears
account. I take lots of video and share what we are learning.
#mnlead
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:38 PM EDT
A3: Ss are given voice at district level by serving on Advisory grp to the Board of Ed & sharing skills & service as
#geniussquad
!
#mnlead
kdgcallahan
May 8 @ 8:38 PM EDT
A3 I struggle with this at the Kdg. grade level. Looking for new ideas
#mnlead
MarkJWestpfahl
May 8 @ 8:39 PM EDT
A3
#mnlead
: In my
#MNstudies
politics unit, Ss choose school policies they think should be changed, draft legislation, debate correct sigs.
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:39 PM EDT
@LauraGWillis
I love this idea! What platform do you use online to share?
#mnlead
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:39 PM EDT
registration forms here:
https://t.co/fS01LNexx3
This doesn't include our forced elective wheels!
#mnlead
https://t.co/mKwtIPvwuE
EdLead670
May 8 @ 8:37 PM EDT
@chris_bussmann
I would love to see a list of your class offerings! Always looking for new ideas:)
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:39 PM EDT
@JoseRomero1399
Did the learner profile help you understand yourself better? Did that change anything about how you work?
#mnlead
Supt_Jordan
May 8 @ 8:40 PM EDT
A school that exists without a structure for student voice and choice is a school that is failing its students.
#mnlead
PrasolovMisha
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:40 PM EDT
Q4: How can student voice and choice be nurtured? Thoughtful answers so far, keep it up
#mnlead
!
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:40 PM EDT
@JK_McMahon
what a great reminder that Ts need voice, too!
#mnlead
LauraGWillis
May 8 @ 8:40 PM EDT
@MoralesPattie
Students submit work through a grade-level Google Classroom. We've had about 100 participants in 4 months.
#mnlead
SteeleThoughts
May 8 @ 8:40 PM EDT
A3: Just started clubs for 6th graders. Students got to choose.
#mnlead
.
https://t.co/N56xiwSgZN
JK_McMahon
May 8 @ 8:40 PM EDT
@kdgcallahan
I'd say kindergarteners have amazing voice (it hasn't been conditioned out of them yet). Just listening might be enough
#mnlead
dayankee
May 8 @ 8:41 PM EDT
A4 Give kids room to think, create, innovate, dream, wonder and work. Busy can become the enemy of learning.
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:41 PM EDT
A3) Let Ss take the lead in building the classroom community- time to get to know each other & interact during unstructured times.
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:41 PM EDT
@kdgcallahan
Do you use
@Seesaw
? It's a cool way to empower Kinder S's. They want to share their work(and you control who sees it).
#mnlead
smithdianemarie
May 8 @ 8:41 PM EDT
#mnlead
A3: 1 idea: after a unit, have ss write what helped, what didn't help, what they like, what they didn't like& an idea for next unit.
bohndrake
May 8 @ 8:41 PM EDT
Teacher from NJ anxiously awaiting to see the responses to Q4!
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:42 PM EDT
Q4: How can student voice and choice be nurtured? Thoughtful answers so far, keep it up
#mnlead
!
@PrasolovMisha
@JoseRomero1399
@abrown
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:42 PM EDT
Our element arise LOVE seesaw!
@AndyLeiser
#mnlead
https://t.co/wbiNvJQOsn
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:41 PM EDT
@kdgcallahan
Do you use
@Seesaw
? It's a cool way to empower Kinder S's. They want to share their work(and you control who sees it).
#mnlead
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:42 PM EDT
A4: Have Ss focus less on "production" and more on the messy work of experimenting and creating.
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:42 PM EDT
A4 By providing it & being their to support Ss when their choice doesn’t go as expected…help them reflect & try again!
#mnlead
MarkJWestpfahl
May 8 @ 8:42 PM EDT
A4
#mnlead
: Continue 2 provide choice for Ss. If u only do it once in a while, they won't grow. Ask what they like
https://t.co/KSRp3cxa4b
PrasolovMisha
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:40 PM EDT
Q4: How can student voice and choice be nurtured? Thoughtful answers so far, keep it up
#mnlead
!
JK_McMahon
May 8 @ 8:43 PM EDT
A4: Build a safe environment and really listen to students. They'll know you are listening.
#mnlead
SteeleThoughts
May 8 @ 8:43 PM EDT
A4: Encourage teachers out of their comfort zones with their assessments. Traditional tests can be replaced by student projects.
#mnlead
Supt_Jordan
May 8 @ 8:43 PM EDT
A4: Nurturing student voice and choice starts at a ground level of relationship building. Building a culture of trust.
#mnlead
KarinHogen
May 8 @ 8:43 PM EDT
A4: frequency and honesty. Give Ss voice and choice often and don't be fake about it.
#mnlead
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:44 PM EDT
A4. When we understand our compelling why in education, we can help but nurture voice and choice!
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:44 PM EDT
A4 Share your thinking! Turn to a partner, make a recording, find a person who did it differently than you, all ways that encourage.
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:44 PM EDT
A4) starts w/ relationship building, moves to working in a growth mindset. Ss have to know its ok to try and fail then try again.
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:44 PM EDT
@JK_McMahon
Good point! We may need to teach Ss how to identify choices. We have sometimes “schooled" it out of them!
#mnlead
EdLead670
May 8 @ 8:44 PM EDT
A4. Encouragement, affirmation, practice, follow through
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
A4 Be authentic. Again, I feel weird saying that as the answer because I assume that should always be the way we are w/our Ss.
#mnlead
kdgcallahan
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
A4 Building a community that builds confidence & appreciation of differences. Most importantly building an environ. Ss feel safe in
#mnlead
Supt_Jordan
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
@chris_bussmann
Couldn't agree more..emphasize process over product. Its the journey we learn from.
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
Ding! Ding! Ding! We have a winner…it always comes back to The Why…a
#mnlead
staple!
https://t.co/KnhtPMoLX2
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:44 PM EDT
A4. When we understand our compelling why in education, we can help but nurture voice and choice!
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
Believe in your students. Empower them. And then watch them do GREAT things...
#mnlead
https://t.co/FqkEw9mn9Z
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
I have to ask, what's holding educators back from NOT allowing Ss to have voice and choice in their classrooms?
#mnlead
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
A4:By Encouraging it! Let students find their own way to solve problems in the classroom!
#mnlead
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
A4.2. When we celebrate the "try" rather than the result...it's all about growth mindset!
#mnlead
smithdianemarie
May 8 @ 8:46 PM EDT
#mnlead
A4: To nurture student voice/choice, follow through is a must. You can't ask for opinions or ideas and then not try any of them ;)
calliembush
May 8 @ 8:46 PM EDT
A4: From day 1 build respectful learning community where Ss know they have input & shared responsibility, expected to take risks.
#mnlead
SteeleThoughts
May 8 @ 8:46 PM EDT
A4: Foster a school culture where innovation is celebrated and failure is ok. Teachers and students have to feel safe taking risks.
#mnlead
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:46 PM EDT
A4 Model learner's mindset - share learning (successes & setbacks). Increases opportunities for genuine empathy.
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:46 PM EDT
@SteeleThoughts
Break the mold and mindset! S's WANT to show us other ways. They have to trust we will lead them to start it.
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:46 PM EDT
I found this to be true when we started genius hour. The Ss didn't know where to begin w/ choice.
#mnlead
https://t.co/t2sAkku5xp
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:44 PM EDT
@JK_McMahon
Good point! We may need to teach Ss how to identify choices. We have sometimes “schooled" it out of them!
#mnlead
smithdianemarie
May 8 @ 8:46 PM EDT
This is great!!
#mnlead
https://t.co/M6viHCexxG
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:42 PM EDT
A4 By providing it & being their to support Ss when their choice doesn’t go as expected…help them reflect & try again!
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:47 PM EDT
Help Ss to see obstacles as a great opportunity to learn new skills...celebrate failure and risk taking.
#mnlead
https://t.co/HaJ9vI40LC
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:42 PM EDT
A4 By providing it & being their to support Ss when their choice doesn’t go as expected…help them reflect & try again!
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:47 PM EDT
This is spot on — voice & choice needs to be part of a classroom’s DNA from the start. Be intentional.
#mnlead
https://t.co/HyXYXaZWhU
calliembush
May 8 @ 8:46 PM EDT
A4: From day 1 build respectful learning community where Ss know they have input & shared responsibility, expected to take risks.
#mnlead
MarkJWestpfahl
May 8 @ 8:47 PM EDT
We take the policies to the admin. This year, CFO of
@SPPS_News
asked us to share my Ss thoughts with her.
#mnlead
@EdLead670
@JenHardy38
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:47 PM EDT
Love it!
#mnlead
https://t.co/6KQMYxmqXw
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
A4.2. When we celebrate the "try" rather than the result...it's all about growth mindset!
#mnlead
JK_McMahon
May 8 @ 8:47 PM EDT
@mahillmann
I had a lot of disagreements with a 7th grade student who couldn't handle not being told what to do.
#mnlead
calliembush
May 8 @ 8:48 PM EDT
@mahillmann
@JK_McMahon
Sad, but true. Some of my HS Ss when given choice freeze, don't know what to do, ask me to just tell them.
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:48 PM EDT
District pacing guides, pressure to align everything to standards, etc
#mnlead
https://t.co/HO7psYNtb9
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
I have to ask, what's holding educators back from NOT allowing Ss to have voice and choice in their classrooms?
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:48 PM EDT
And...model this for Ts so they in turn model it for Ss...
#mnlead
https://t.co/EmOlDGTAwi
Supt_Jordan
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
@chris_bussmann
Couldn't agree more..emphasize process over product. Its the journey we learn from.
#mnlead
smithdianemarie
May 8 @ 8:49 PM EDT
#mnlead
A4: Scaffolding is important. Giving students increased choices and responsibility gradually.
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:49 PM EDT
@korytellers
Mandated content, too much testing, teacher evaluation processes - fear of letting go - fear of the unknown
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:49 PM EDT
I believe some Ts see compliance as learning and may even measure their success as a T based on compliance.
#mnlead
https://t.co/KUZvhUHDlT
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
I have to ask, what's holding educators back from NOT allowing Ss to have voice and choice in their classrooms?
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:50 PM EDT
@EdLead670
@mahillmann
@JK_McMahon
it's an hour a week where Ss work on passion projects. There's a lot online about it!
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:50 PM EDT
Insightful…should voice & choice in primary grades look different from senior high?
#mnlead
https://t.co/u117vco30B
smithdianemarie
May 8 @ 8:49 PM EDT
#mnlead
A4: Scaffolding is important. Giving students increased choices and responsibility gradually.
dayankee
May 8 @ 8:50 PM EDT
@millardamy2
Right. Compliance is NOT learning. Sometimes those who DON'T comply are the ones who learn the most
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:51 PM EDT
@robert_schuetz
I'm sitting here actually shaking my head while I read this. It just shouldn't happen.
#mnlead
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:51 PM EDT
I heard last week we have to "get through" the material. Actually, we don't. We focus on what we value.
#mnlead
https://t.co/gQlGUFVM60
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
I have to ask, what's holding educators back from NOT allowing Ss to have voice and choice in their classrooms?
#mnlead
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:51 PM EDT
Time. District mandates, core curriculum, pacing guides, lack of know-how, Ss who aren't used voice & choice
#mnlead
https://t.co/Ltx67a7mXt
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
I have to ask, what's holding educators back from NOT allowing Ss to have voice and choice in their classrooms?
#mnlead
JK_McMahon
May 8 @ 8:51 PM EDT
@calliembush
@mahillmann
I've seen 2nd grade Genius Hours more successful than 12th grade since they arestill free thinkers younger.
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:52 PM EDT
@millardamy2
@korytellers
so true! I love this comparison b/w engaged and compliant
https://t.co/R6b58PKYU6
#mnlead
AnIowaTeacher
May 8 @ 8:52 PM EDT
A4: How do we nurture student voice & choice? By giving them just that: nurturing &choice! Let Ss know they are more than a number!
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:52 PM EDT
@chris_bussmann
Did that come from Ts that work at your school? I would think that if I worked at your school I would know better :)
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:52 PM EDT
@msleevang
I'm learning and trying this, "You make time for the things that are important to you." It's hard but a motivator for me.
#mnlead
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:53 PM EDT
Have we done our due diligence to empower our Ts? Do they have voice & choice in their work?
#mnlead
https://t.co/UlXRDCo3Ab
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
I have to ask, what's holding educators back from NOT allowing Ss to have voice and choice in their classrooms?
#mnlead
ehfowler7
May 8 @ 8:53 PM EDT
@MoralesPattie
@korytellers
I think figuring out how to effectivly offer voice and choice takes practice-to avoid feeling of chaos
#mnlead
JK_McMahon
May 8 @ 8:53 PM EDT
@KalidKhalid1
@mahillmann
I did. He just honestly couldn't tell me because he hadn't been asked in school before.
#mnlead
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:53 PM EDT
@bretdom
Do you think it is because of your position? I hear Ts scared of admin to move away from the scoping guides and what not.
#mnlead
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:53 PM EDT
Ok last question! Q5: How do you encourage your colleagues on student voice and choice?
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:53 PM EDT
@bretdom
@msleevang
My mantra is "Less Is More." The less I try to squeeze in, the more my Ss learn. Always.
#mnlead
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:54 PM EDT
What's a scoping guide? :)
#mnlead
https://t.co/OSO0H4Fgqv
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:53 PM EDT
@bretdom
Do you think it is because of your position? I hear Ts scared of admin to move away from the scoping guides and what not.
#mnlead
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:54 PM EDT
@korytellers
You know I'm w/ U on this - it's tough 2 quickly change long-standing practices, even if they are presently ineffective
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:54 PM EDT
@ehfowler7
@korytellers
yes, it is hard sometimes, especially if you like a more structured environment. the payoff is huge though!
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:54 PM EDT
@msleevang
@korytellers
I'm learning if we dig deeper rather than covering it all, the rest falls into place. Permission granted.
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:54 PM EDT
@chris_bussmann
My fav line from this video: “I want to cover rather than uncover material. And use chalk.”
https://t.co/TEW47VlIL3
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:55 PM EDT
Great mantra!
#mnlead
https://t.co/JwIDhRfq7S
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:53 PM EDT
@bretdom
@msleevang
My mantra is "Less Is More." The less I try to squeeze in, the more my Ss learn. Always.
#mnlead
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:55 PM EDT
YES! Some Ss are NOT used to their voices being valued. Some prefer NO choice and just want best grade opt
#mnlead
https://t.co/L4JqbhGiiy
JK_McMahon
May 8 @ 8:53 PM EDT
@KalidKhalid1
@mahillmann
I did. He just honestly couldn't tell me because he hadn't been asked in school before.
#mnlead
robert_schuetz
May 8 @ 8:55 PM EDT
@JennReichel
Terrific question!
#mnlead
JK_McMahon
May 8 @ 8:55 PM EDT
@EdLead670
@MoralesPattie
@mahillmann
I wrote about it in our district blog:
https://t.co/Ww2jQ4icCV
#mnlead
calliembush
May 8 @ 8:55 PM EDT
@JK_McMahon
@mahillmann
I agree. It took a long time for some of my 9th graders to get into the
#geniushour
process.
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:56 PM EDT
@robert_schuetz
I know. I just feel so sorry (not best word) for those Ts that feel that way. Hard for me to understand that.
#mnlead
EdLead670
May 8 @ 8:56 PM EDT
A5 Ts get on board when they see others implement initiatives with success
#mnlead
Supt_Jordan
May 8 @ 8:56 PM EDT
A5: Leaders that allow for t's to step outside comfort zones and take risks...leads to s's doing the same. Model it every day.
#mnlead
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:56 PM EDT
Agreed. How often is PD personalized for Ts? How often are their voices taken into account for PD?
#mnlead
https://t.co/0NzACp5Usl
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:53 PM EDT
Have we done our due diligence to empower our Ts? Do they have voice & choice in their work?
#mnlead
https://t.co/UlXRDCo3Ab
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
I have to ask, what's holding educators back from NOT allowing Ss to have voice and choice in their classrooms?
#mnlead
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:56 PM EDT
@korytellers
This is key…but difficult given our societal expectations. We could provide greater value by focusing on fewer things.
#mnlead
MoralesPattie
May 8 @ 8:57 PM EDT
@bretdom
just another reason I wish I lived in Lakeville!
#mnlead
chris_bussmann
May 8 @ 8:57 PM EDT
A5: Give Tt permission...permission to try, do, fail, reflect, and try again. All with them knowing I have their back.
#mnlead
AnIowaTeacher
May 8 @ 8:57 PM EDT
A5: Give them a taste of what it could be like. Share a project, a student comment, an idea you have, then check up on them
#mnlead
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:57 PM EDT
In the film
#mostlikelytosucceed
Ss told the interviewer they just want to be tested-no choices, no projects. They need grades. Sad
#mnlead
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:58 PM EDT
@MoralesPattie
@ehfowler7
I believe in structured chaos. Takes a lot of time and modeling, but very much possible.
#mnlead
ABrownByte
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:58 PM EDT
Re posting the question! Q5: How do you encourage your colleagues on student voice and choice?
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:58 PM EDT
@kdgcallahan
@Seesaw
You only need access to a few iPads and watch what can happen!
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:59 PM EDT
I plan to meet Ts where they are at-not necessarily where I want them to be-and move forward with support
#mnlead
https://t.co/davI7T7znC
mahillmann
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:59 PM EDT
A5 By modeling it through leadership. As leaders, we too often don’t give Ts the same voice & choice we expect Ts to give Ss.
#mnlead
ehfowler7
May 8 @ 8:59 PM EDT
A5: model active, reflective listening. Ts need to do this well to to voice and choice well.
#mnlead
millardamy2
May 8 @ 8:59 PM EDT
Amen!
#mnlead
https://t.co/Qw15TPNgsc
Supt_Jordan
May 8 @ 8:56 PM EDT
A5: Leaders that allow for t's to step outside comfort zones and take risks...leads to s's doing the same. Model it every day.
#mnlead
bretdom
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:59 PM EDT
A5 Lead by example! Give, share, empower, ask questions, offer support. Do what it takes!
#mnlead
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:59 PM EDT
We're working on it...but it's going to take time for some of our Ts to be a self-directed learner.
#mnlead
https://t.co/vEN25YD8dM
msleevang
- Moderator
May 8 @ 8:56 PM EDT
Agreed. How often is PD personalized for Ts? How often are their voices taken into account for PD?
#mnlead
https://t.co/0NzACp5Usl
JennReichel
May 8 @ 8:53 PM EDT
Have we done our due diligence to empower our Ts? Do they have voice & choice in their work?
#mnlead
https://t.co/UlXRDCo3Ab
korytellers
May 8 @ 8:45 PM EDT
I have to ask, what's holding educators back from NOT allowing Ss to have voice and choice in their classrooms?
#mnlead
